|Reviews for Roses|
| Gotham's Forgotten Crimfighter chapter 51 . 1/31/2007
Thanks in making me cry. I can't believe that you finished it. Hmm...You want to collaborate on a story? Maybe not Newsies, because I haven't watched it in ages, but we could co-write something else. I'll talk to you about it in V.E
| RoeBoat chapter 51 . 12/1/2006
Oh my gosh.
It's actually OVER.
I didn't get a chance to review chapter forty (I had to leave for play practice right after reading it)...
I didn't actually think that Cray was... dead. I didn't. Oh my gosh.
I'm so happy that Lefty lived... and then the sad phenomenon of Cray getting killed was so unexpected.
So... it's over? It's really over?
I must confess that I still crave more, and it's depressing to think that I'll now never have it. There are so many unanswered questions...
What happens to everyone?
How does everyone react to Cray dying and Lefty living?
How does Spot cope with her death?
Is she really dead, or just gravely wounded?
Will I ever stop asking questions?
I can only answer the last question with a quiet whisper of a "nope".
It would be impossible to ask about one certain scene of this story and how it applies to you as a writer and your life. I want to know all of it... I love things like that. I think it's amazing.
This is quite a masterpiece you have written, and I hope you see that.
I'm not ready for it to be over, and I didn't think it was over until the ending Author's note.
Also, I do recomend that you keep a backup copy of this just in case it is ever deleted (you know, idiots will report stupid things), and also for yourself.
You are very talented, my friend, and I hope you keep writing. E-mail me sometime, 'kay?
Your loyal reader,
| Emba chapter 51 . 11/30/2006
I'm so sad it's over! The Spot/Cray interaction at the end was truly heart breaking. I still can't believe you killed her! And so suddenly! Poor Spot. But, I love the Higgins family and I nearly cried reading that last chapter. I love this story and although I wish you didn't kill Cray (so sad!) I am going to add it to my favorites. It was beautifully written and I hope you come out with a new story eventually.
| ladydaphne chapter 49 . 11/29/2006
oh my god...
| Emba chapter 48 . 11/29/2006
YOU CAN'T KILL CRAY! WHAT ABOUT SPOT? PLEASE DON'T KILL CRAY!
| Jules chapter 49 . 11/29/2006
WHAT? You thought since you didn't kill off Lefty you have to kill of Cray? NO PLEASEE this ISNT FAIR! Why not a happy ending? Please don't let her die no!
| Jules chapter 47 . 11/22/2006
Yay for Spot and Cray! Yay for Lefty's life! Update again son!
| RoeBoat chapter 48 . 11/22/2006
Oh, I had hoped... I had hoped with all my might that you would purposely NOT use the ending to the one-shot...
I LOVE YOU!
I'm so happy!
Great chapter, and I loved reading about Jack's take on the situation.
| Emba chapter 46 . 11/19/2006
So sad! Race is the sweetest guy alive, I hate how this is happening to him. I hope everything turns out okay!
| RoeBoat chapter 46 . 11/19/2006
Y'know how I keep saying I hate you for making Lefty die?
IT'S NEVER BEEN MORE TRUE!
(y'know I'm just kidding... I just hate the way this is turning out...)
Can't she spontaneously get better?
C'mon!I'm begging you!
Beautifully written... Poor Race, poor Anthony... Ugh. Poor everyone.
This will not end well.
I also like how you've been updating lately... It rocks...
| Emba chapter 45 . 11/18/2006
Heartbreaking. I can't believe Lefty is gonna die! She can't! Anthony broke my heart when we ran in to her room :( update again soon
| RoeBoat chapter 45 . 11/17/2006
I HATE YOU FOR BEING SUCH A FREAKING GOOD WRITER.
I think I'm crying.
AND LEFTY... NO!
| Emba chapter 44 . 11/13/2006
So sad! Lefty can't die! And wheres Cray? And poor, poor ol' Race. Update again soon!
| RoeBoat chapter 44 . 11/13/2006
NO, NO, NO!
Please let Lefty live... Prove that ol' one-shot one...
| RoeBoat chapter 43 . 11/12/2006
NO! I HATE YOU!
This IS turning into that one-shot!
Update soon before I blow up, and keep up the good work.