Reviews for Happy Holiday
yeya chapter 1 . 6/21/2013
I love it, is so romantic and beautiful...
arwen chapter 1 . 5/13/2013
me encanto esta historia
nilpferd20 chapter 1 . 9/24/2008
A desperately needed and rewrite of the last Macross episode. Fits very well in the saga. I especially liked the shown timetable and the exact phrases taken from the original story. The idea of _just_ reversing the events is plain brilliant!

A word about the event in front of Ricks house: Having Rick send Minmei away would be neither canonical nor make sense, considering his character and relationship with her. After all, on Christmas Eve? He maybe stupid when it comes to women (if not, why did it take him so long to finally chose Lisa?) but he is definitely not cruel. Besides, if Lisa had listened to Claudia and followed her advice in the first place, this might not have happened. But so...

Anyway, I'm so glad you finally told us the _real_ story!
Lunacharm chapter 1 . 2/13/2008
Yup, I like your version much better.
Hibiki54 chapter 1 . 3/17/2005
Good grammar and an excellent alternate ending for the Macross Saga. "What if" fics are so entertaining sometimes.
PattyBones chapter 1 . 2/1/2005
Another interesting rewrite of events. Well written indeed.
Embittered Flower chapter 1 . 1/17/2005
If only indeed! I enjoyed your take on what should have happened that Christmas Eve, most especially the part where Minmei discovers that she's not the only important woman in Rick's life. :D Great job!
RougeBaron chapter 1 . 12/26/2004
I'm still high on Christmas, and this story centers around Christmas, plus you so kindly put a review on my story, so I think I'd review this story.

Very good job on describing the angst / tension between Rick - Lisa - Minmei. Rick is a jerk. He shouldn't have invited Minmei into his quarter in front of Lisa. If I were him, I'd take her to a nice hotel, and continue to have my good time with Lisa. But maybe it's Christmas. Sorry. I digress.

Anyway, good job. I look forward to reading your other 2 stories.
Misa Hayase chapter 1 . 12/15/2004
I absolutely LOVED your story! The ending of the Macross saga was, admittedly, terrible. There was absolutely NO emotion or remorse put into the loss of the beloved crew of the SDF-1.

Furthermore, I really enjoyed how you reversed the situation when Lisa showed up before MinMei. Everything tied in really well with the episodes, and overall, you did an excellent job. More please? _
elyssalyn chapter 1 . 12/7/2004
I love this story and all but I was reading another story you posted when it suddenly disappeared on me. What happened? Are you going to repost it? Please do!
Lord Destroyer chapter 1 . 12/3/2004
This is the way how Robotech should have progressed after the failed pinic. But you could've done with out the Minmei song. You managed to capture the characters' personality just right, while changing the story line for the better.
aikiweezie chapter 1 . 12/3/2004
There are NO WORDS in the English language to sufficiently express how much I love this story! This makes up for terrible "To The Stars," episode, and should replace it forever. It will, in my mind anyway! You tied up all the loose ends perfectly. Bravo!