|Reviews for Recompense|
| CrowX chapter 14 . 12/14/2013
Oh, just reread the whole saga and I love love love it! So much. It's wonderfully written, a perfect plot and the characters done so well.
The best AU Star Wars book I've ever read!
| Garbouw Deark chapter 14 . 5/17/2013
I love Castle in the Sky! I can't believe I didn't see the reference...But this trilogy was amazing, and one of the few that makes my top 10 list. I know that this wouldn't fit very well with any of the novels, and the a time travel would be shit, but I'm still sad to see it end.
| Sanna Black Slytherin chapter 14 . 8/21/2012
Y'know, whe I started reading Innocence, I thought, 'hey, this fic is more humor than anything, there are thousands like that out there, noting special'. But, as it turned out, I was wrong.
I've read this trilogy and seen it going slowly from humor (almost satir, something really funny in any case) to angst, H/C and complete seriousness. These fics is unlike any other I have read. They have this special... thing. You're not afraid of making sacrifices, killing off characters for the 'greater good'. It's really funny trying to predict what's going to happen. (By the way, I have succeeded in predicting Bekme as a traitor, Vader getting paralyzed and then getting his youth back. And othr stuff, but I can't bother remembering it all.)
It was a real pleasure reading this, and I look forward to reading more of your SW works!
| Mireilles3 chapter 14 . 7/7/2012
How could I missed this awesome story when it first came out, I'll never know but I'm glad I came across it last week :)
It was simply addictive, so right on the mark, and reminding me of the golden age of L/V AUs fics :) (sigh)
I wish you wrote more of those, and that I could write descriptions the way you do :)
Looking forward to anything L/V you might post again :) please?
| Eve chapter 8 . 3/26/2012
Wow. You did a great job with the Sith fortress and it's traps and the visions... Really well done. I applaud your imagination.
| Eve chapter 5 . 3/25/2012
Not a bad story, but I have to say... Why are you copypasting dialogues from the movies when, in this new context, they make no sense?
Let's say here:
"No more training do you require," he said at last.
They stared at him a moment. It seemed too much to comprehend. They were truly Jedi?
Yoda must have read their thoughts, because he shook his head slightly, grimacing as the injudicious movement stretched the burned skin of his neck. "No… not yet. One thing remains." He drew a deep, shuddering breath. "The Emperor." His eye fixed Vader's in a penetrating look. "You must… confront… the Emperor. Only then…. Jedi Knights you will be."
No, just... no. Luke may be or not a Jedi, but Vader is not a Padawan no matter what, I mean he's been trained for like fifteen years in the Jedi Temple. You cannot put them in the same bag just like that. Luke lacks experience, Vader does not; he's got different issues, of course, but dark Jedi or whatever, he is not an apprendice. What is there for him to learn?
Sorry about the criticism. It just pisses me off when a good idea is messed up. The story is quite interesting when you don't mindlessly stick to the script or put one character's dialogue in another's mouth.
| TheGirlInTheMentalHospital chapter 3 . 2/29/2012
"What the stang is happening here?"
"The pirate's gone crazy!"
"The short one!"
"Which short one, you idiot?"
"WHO YOU CALLING SHORT?"
Dude! I lol'd so hard because for a moment I was thinking "Wait...Edward Elric is here? OMG! Where's Alphonse!" XD Total Fullmetal Alchemist moment there. I love Ed's short rants! So friggin funny! Teehee!
But overall, i've already read all of your Reborn trilogy and I only came back here to comment on this part here. Yeah, I love how you made Vader have amnesia and have fun adventures with the Rebel Alliance! Wooo! I kept giggling throughout the whole stories.
The Girl in the Mental Hospital
| WrittinInStone chapter 14 . 8/4/2011
I don't know how I feel about Anakin having another love interest. Actually, yes I do, I didn't like it, at all. I mean, Padme loved Anakin so much that she died when she lost him to the Dark Side.
I like Forenze...I liked her a lot, but I would have rather they had been friends.
Despite the implied consent by Padme at the end, it still seemed a smack in the face...disrespectful even.
I guess Padme wasn't the love of his life...what with her simply 'always having a a place in his heart'.
The rest of the story, though, was great, although like I said before, the last part kinda ruined it.
| Theiata chapter 2 . 4/7/2011
"Vader grabbed Luke's arm and pulled him toward the throne room, keeping up the appearance of one of Jabba's underlings. But he did manage to make eye contact with his son, and the young man nodded in understanding."
Eye contact isn't so easy when wearing a mask... enthralling, anyway, gotto read on :-)
| grace1237 chapter 14 . 11/22/2010
Awesome trilogy...I really enjoyed it :) Good writing, pace and characters.
Now...back to studies :(
| anemix chapter 14 . 2/1/2010
Yay! I really loved this trilogy, and especially this part! Keep writing!
( . .)
| Seirei Nightlord05 chapter 14 . 7/6/2009
Ah...At last a happy ending...I know that one review will not justify the trilogy, seeing that I had read all three, 'Innocence', 'Experience' and 'Recompense'...
At first, it hard to imagine that Anakin will become a honour rebel officer but as I continued reading the story...It became easier to imagine...
When I was reading 'Experience', I can't help but pity Master Yoda for having to train two younglings that love to play around...That part was the cutest part of the story...
Vell,I know that most writers don't a very long review, so I just stop here...I truly like your story...
Keep up the good work... Take care...
| Lielac chapter 14 . 5/8/2009
... I KNEW THAT WOULD HAPPEN.
No, seriously. Ani Forenze w00t.
... 80 jedi to train... HOO boy. *snrt*
| FireChildSlytherin5 chapter 14 . 10/26/2008
Great sequel! I love the thought of Anakin/Forenze shipping. Know any stories of like that? Padme being dead and Anakin finding love that isn't human?
Anyway, I was curious of you would write a short story in either or both of Anakin's time with the Tuskens from this story. And/or the time with Forenze! Or better yet, the 8,0th Padawan! lol!
Great sequels. (I thought I reviewed this years ago...)
| Celebwen Telcontar chapter 14 . 10/9/2008
This was lovely. Beautiful. Now, I have a rather unorthadox question... what will Ani and Forenze's children look like? I'm imagining something like a humanoid and armed instead of winged archaeopteryx.
Loved the entire trilogy, Ms. Starflight!