|Reviews for Ashen and Sober Skies|
| Adhara Raine chapter 25 . 10/19/2016
When are you updating?
| tanithlipsky chapter 25 . 1/22/2016
interesting. I like it a lot. I am following this.
| scgaraycochea chapter 25 . 10/13/2015
What a beautiful story, sad, but beautiful in itself.
I would like how it continues, and how it ends. Please continue writting it.
You are great at doing it.
Thank you for share this fanfic with us.
| daisycb chapter 25 . 2/28/2015
I hope you get back to this. I want to find out if he gets better
| Guest chapter 24 . 11/30/2014
Oh the travesty! The inhumanity!
Whatever did John, Paul, George, and Ringo do to merit being sliced with mathematical precision?!
Other than this bit of nonchalant cannibalism, I'm enjoying your work.
I think the chapter with Albus seeking Severus out in the library turned out especially well in Severus' pov.
| TheDeathChamber chapter 25 . 8/14/2014
OH. I tiptoed into this and then took a plunge as soon as I saw the quality of the writing and the depth of the character study, and I didn't realize this was unfinished. Damn it. Still worth it. I like that you decided to tackle such difficult moral issues in an imaginative way and with careful characterization for all.
| Mu-Nition chapter 5 . 2/23/2014
Ends with a punch right in the feels. Oww.
| excessivelyperky chapter 25 . 10/20/2013
Looking forward to more chapters; the ending of this one resonates with Le Guin, and when her character accepted his dark side, and became whole.
| Eru no Tsubasa chapter 17 . 2/18/2013
Poor Snape! :(
| MuggleCreator chapter 25 . 1/8/2013
Ooh. Wow. Love this exploration of dreamscape, etc.
Please continue! I want to see how it ends...
| Jeeun chapter 11 . 12/12/2012
Oh this was nice. Really nice. The tibits of Severus and Minerva's past interactions. It was amusing what has happened at that time, and at the same time so sad that Severus can't remember any of that. Wonder if that little girl is Minerva's youngerself. Maybe a bit of a crush on Severus's part? A memory of a picture of Minerva he has seen?
| Jeeun chapter 9 . 12/12/2012
Am I seeing a bit of an omage to Dante? It was good to know what Severus has in his mind, and Dumbledore's first trip into the mind was to act as an observer at least, so I think it was a bit of a success in a way, for Dumbledore to really grasp what Severus has gone through, and what he had to endure.
| Jeeun chapter 8 . 12/12/2012
Yup, Dumbledore isn't that caring. Severus is just another one of his reponsiblity and nothing more. Sure he weeps and feel sad, but that's what anyone would feel if they encounter something like this. Severus isn't that special in Dumbledore's heart. Severus thinks of him as his mentor, a person he really feels strong affection, but Dumbledore doesn't. Maybe I'm trying to find some more, too much more and getting disappointed by not getting enough. My fault. And the girl with red hair and blue eyes, that isn't Lily, right? Since Lily had green eyes? Wonder who she is.
| Jeeun chapter 7 . 12/12/2012
Is it just me? Dumbledore really doesn't seem to care for Severus that much. Yes, he cries, yes he is overjoyed that Severus seems to come back, and yes he thinks 'poor Severus' but that's about it. I don't quite feel that Dumbledore is quite compassionate in this story. Nor does Pomphrey for that matter. She's only acting in a professional way, and not at all acting as if she's caring for a colleague that she cares for. Well, she has to distinct herself with her patients to fully use her skills, but quite too distinct. Minerva seems like the only one who really truly cares for Severus. Maybe that was your main goal. I'll have to read further to really know, but well, I guess I'll have to read more to find out.
| AvadaK3 chapter 25 . 11/4/2012
Update... please? How are the four chapters going?