Reviews for Boromir's Journey Home Amon Hen to Minas Tirith
Sailor Sapho chapter 31 . 8/6/2005
Wow... I would have reviewed throughout but I could not put this down... the OC's of Garad and Haradna were wonderful...

Definitely one of the best Boromir-lives fics I've ever seen. I wish there had been more of Eowyn, though... but where would you have put her?

Speaking from one writer to another... how did you get this done in 2 MONTHS? How is that possible... I must know your secret! Do I need to steal a Palantir to find out?
Hel5gen chapter 31 . 8/5/2005
I love this story and the one called "A Gentle Touch". I hope you write some more at all possible may I PLEASE print the stories to keep and reread. I find it hard to read off the I keep getting interupted at work and home. May the blessing of all Elves and free folk be with you. Thanks. helen
lindahoyland chapter 31 . 7/14/2005
Congratulations on a wonderful story ! If only the film had ended like this with 10 !I eagerly await more stories from you.
lindahoyland chapter 30 . 7/14/2005
What a beautiful story is excellent full of beautiful imagery.I love the bond you create for Aragorn and Boromir.
lindahoyland chapter 29 . 7/11/2005
This chapter was just amazing ! What a brilliant stroke of imagination to use the Elessar like this and link ARagorn and Boromir.(I wish they had kept the brooch in the film) Your use of the eagle was very imaginative too and the way you linked all that was happening and used the healing power of the Elessar.
lindahoyland chapter 28 . 7/10/2005
This was a brilliant chapter.I loved the conversation between Boromir and Beth, your description of the ride to the Black Gate and then the terrifying confrontation with the palantir .Nice to see some explanation of why Denethor's Guards let him almost roast his son. As soon as Boromir took off his sword, I guessed something was going to happen !I loved the way Aragorn 'remotely' helps Boromir.
lindahoyland chapter 27 . 7/4/2005
This is a great chapter,crammed with original ideas !I loved the way the Captain was found and Boromir's use of words !
Evendim chapter 31 . 7/1/2005

Congratulations overall on a most well written, well thought out, and above all, credible story. The characters are crystal clear; exactly as I see them in my mind's eye,(Boromir,Gimli and Pip were especially good)lovely to have the visual of the actors who portrayed them as I read. I so much prefer to envisage the choices PJ made for Boromir and Faramir as opposed to the dark haired 'book' version; just a personal preference, of course, so thanks for going with 'movieverse' on this.

I have been reading this again, in the printed form, (the artwork is lovely), and I must say to you, that I am so taken with your Garad, I caught myself typing the wrong name into 'Aderthad' all morning. (I have now shooed Garad away, and have re-instated Gareth)

Looking forward to seeing more of your work here. There has to be a follow through on Boromir's Journey chasing around in your head, surely? Very well done!
lindahoyland chapter 26 . 6/26/2005
This is a new chapter to me that I haven't read earlier.I just LOVED the way the light catches Aragorn's sword and the White Tree,every bit as inspiring as Tolkien's star moment !
Keeter chapter 31 . 6/20/2005
Oh oh OH! Of course I'll give you some feedback. I'm so distraught that its over!

First off, especially in this chapter, I adore the way you've written the hobbits. Not many can pull it off correctly. I know you're saying how hard can it be? Very. And you're one of the few who's gotten it right!

Second, a feast? A sequel? Bring it on! If you want, I can forward you all sorts of yumy descriptions of feasting foods. I've made myself hungry. Except for the furry feat, I'm a hobbit at heart.

This has been an absolute pleasure to follow along on this journey and I hope you'll write many more. If you already have more, point me in the right direction please?


lindahoyland chapter 25 . 6/19/2005
I love the way you suggest that Aragorn's very touch brings hope. Also enjoyed Faramir's compassion to the Hobbits
lindahoyland chapter 24 . 6/17/2005
I love the way you write Aragorn and hope you will include him in any future stories. You gave him and Boromir a lovely scene in this chapter and Boromir and the Hobbits. I liked the way Boromir was concerned that everyone is fed.

Those steps by the great hall just demand fight scenes as I have faramir and Eomer fighting in my story, it makes one shudder to think of falling there as Boromir did.
lindahoyland chapter 23 . 6/16/2005
Another enjoyable chapter.I loved the way the brothers react to the sword and Aragorn's interpretation of the scene in the film
lindahoyland chapter 22 . 6/15/2005
Another wonderful chapter to count amongst my favourites. I loved Faramir and Aragorn's scene especially as well as the brothers together. You really brought it home too,how hard it must have been for book Faramir to cope with losing both his brother and father. Beautifully written
Daughter of Olorin chapter 31 . 6/15/2005
The end? Well, I can handle that if it's only for now. Sorry it's taken me so long to get to this. Summer semester can be quite (insert expletive of your choosing). “The Fellowship is at last whole again.“-note the reviewer's sigh of contentment. I can definitely see Boromir thinking that he had a will of his own instead of being completely controlled by the ring. “You are a fortunate man if you have never found need to forgive a friend."-nice line! I never really thought about it, but if Boromir had survived, he and Frodo would have a kinship of some sort by being 'overtaken' by the ring. Great story! I loved it and I can't wait for more! The website doesn't allow for e-mail to be put in chapters (why? we'll probably never know), so I wasn't sure where to send anything. I figured leaving a review would be safe. It you don't post the sequel here, I would love to know where you do post it.
371 | « Prev Page 1 .. 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 21 .. Last Next »