Reviews for Can't Be Held Responsible |
---|
JoeBob1379 chapter 1 . 3/22/2004 Hate you? Flame you? Are you kidding? That is amazing! It's such a fascinating idea! I love it! I mean I really think this is a brilliant piece of work! "Cho Lee, an Asian girl who had a problem with split personalities" Hehehe... she does kind of seem like she's split- torn between Cedric and Harry and herself... :) I never really liked Cho very much... And Jenny! That's so funny... I know so many people who always say "Jenny" instead of Ginny... |
Dark Angel Katti chapter 1 . 3/15/2004 I'm not sure what about this story gets to me. I enjoyed it, don't think I didn't. But it gets me on a level, a deep level; makes me re-evaluate quite a lot of things. It's sad, it's beautiful. While my view of the books will always hold my own, I'm always open to new ideas. This story, well, it presented such ideas. And for some reason, it makes me think of "Mad World" by Gary Jules - it's sad, it's perfectly written. It's... is there anything I can say to explain how I feel about this without sounding like I'm trying to be overly gushing? I liked, no loved, this story, and I can't understand how people would see it as a ruining of their views of the books. |
Amara Tsu chapter 1 . 3/6/2004 This is a great story with wonderful ideas. I love it! I've always wondered if JK Rowlings is just going to say "And then he woke up" in the last HP book. This story rivals the original storyline if you ask me. |
Sapphire Dragons chapter 1 . 3/2/2004 A very new perspective. I like it, and i won't flame you. that's a cool idea, and i probably will try to write a story like that,even though i can't write. |
SpecialParanoia chapter 1 . 2/6/2004 Wow. I really liked this. You did a great job with something that could be so complicated. The only odd thing about it was the name Cedrico, but oh well. I mean really, Cedric is an odd name. What can ya' do? Really, though, great job! |
Cupsofgreentea chapter 1 . 2/3/2004 This is wonderful.I like it very and unique. You know what?Sometimes I wonder if Harry's life is actually his own fantasy...made up in desperation to get away from his "evil" family. Or parhaps, his parents did die in a car crash and he was in the car,he survived but suffer some kind of brain damage..or parhaps..Dudley sat on his head one day,to bully him,and he suffered damage from there... muhahahahah! |
AmethystPhoenix chapter 1 . 1/21/2004 Very interesting take. No, it didn't make me angry at all. It's just dark, that's it. I liked it, actually, because it shows an alternate world... except it's not really alternate. It reminds me of a fic I read before, where the HP books all are written by Harry, who escapes his normal life by writing. Very good job, and great idea. ~AmethystPhoenix |
Lady Russell Holmes chapter 1 . 1/15/2004 Now this is original. Poor Harry. Very good job, you know. Not more I can say, really. |
Trogdor the Burninator chapter 1 . 1/12/2004 :-( How sad! A good story though. Very well written. Very clever. Is there a real life Draco in your story? Oh, and you should write a sequel; it could turn out very well. |
Rana Eressea chapter 1 . 1/10/2004 Oh my God. I must hug you now. That was so creative and just plain excellent. You've got talent, honey, yes you do. Talent! I'm going to be haunted by that forever, I tell you! So sad...so very, very sad... *sniffs* |
badritual chapter 1 . 1/2/2004 Amazing. |
Nananabooboo chapter 1 . 12/27/2003 aww, so cute. Glad for Harry too. Really good job you did on this. |
ckat44 chapter 1 . 12/26/2003 OMG THIS WAS SO AMAZING! It was so original and stunning! |
kreaturecomfort chapter 1 . 12/26/2003 Bravo on an imaginative and highly entertaining interpretation of Harry! I never read anything like it before and it is totally heart rending. You know, the only complaint I could possibly have with your story is that it might have been longer, but that's just being picky. Really, you did a lovely job of bringing Harry's views into the muggle world, in a highly distubing manner. |
dragongirlG chapter 1 . 12/13/2003 Amazing! Very original perspective on Harry's world, and very frightening as well. I'm stunned. Excellent work! |