Reviews for Mastermind Hunting
G Fawkes chapter 37 . 5/9/2019
That crap about making Crabbe into a bomb wasn't your best work.
Maybe you forgot he's an idiot, and barely magical? So , only worth like, less than one percent of good, quality, explodin' material?
Fat is good for soap, though! (Fight Club)
Schwalek chapter 40 . 5/7/2019
you may have just made me fail out of uni.
found this fanfic shortly before exam period and just COULD NOT STOP READING.
CURSE YOU THRICE
CURSE YOU AND YOUR FAMILY
LET NOONE IN YOUR LINEAGE WRITE SOMETHING HALF AS GOOD AGAIN
(love the fanfic if you cant tell)
G F chapter 36 . 5/6/2019
Grrrrrr! Magic and oaths are all about INTENT! If you conjur a wall to BLOCK curses and protect others from bad guys, and the wall falls on someone, light OR dark, then that is an ACCIDENT and would NOT trigger an oath, therefore costing the subject their life or magic.
What if the bad guys fire killing curses at Flamels wall, and the shrapnel kills one of the students. Clearly he did not INTEND to kill a student. No clause trigger. What if he cuts a bunch of trees down to levitate into a physical wall, and before he can catch it one of the logs falls on a bad guy (taking the light side out of the equation)? He wasn't trying to kill anyone. no intent, no foul.
You are nitpicking your own a/u rules against your own characters. Aside from being completely bored at the length of this, I'm ALMOST pissed off enough to quit reading, just from some of your interpretations.
I know. Go ahead. But it already cost me several days to read thirty five chapters out of the forty, so I AM trying to finish. Doesn't count on my tally if I quit. Except the QUIT tally, and that's over two hundred in itself.
Guest chapter 4 . 5/5/2019
Your grammar leaves much to be desired!
G Fawkes chapter 36 . 5/5/2019
Uh... Your sandbox, and all, but you're still wrong. Games won is all that matters. . I win two and you win one, then even if you scored a thousand points more than me, you still lose.
Maybe you are thinking some kind of Euro trash, World Cup points BS, for standings in a double elimination bracket? ( Still goes by WINS)
There is NO SPORT that points accumulated EVER supercedes WINS...
Thinking...
NOPE. I am wrong.
The FedEx Cup in PGA golf (USA). Weekly, wins matter. But at the end of the year you could conceivably have less wins, or not win the final Championship match, and still get the ten million dollar prize.
Guest chapter 3 . 5/5/2019
Teenagers AND preteens go to Hogwarts!

What happened to Vernon?
Guest chapter 2 . 5/5/2019
Why th Fuck was Malfoy in China?
G Fawkes chapter 35 . 5/3/2019
Three hours to heal the seekers while the match played on without them

FOUL!

YOU wrote, at the beginning of the year, Dumbledore standing at the first announcements of the new year, saying each team WILL choose a second team for practices an substitutions! Where are your backup seekers?!

Later...
'While he (Riddle) was walking towards the Department of Mysteries...'

No. While he was walking the twenty or thirty so meters, past the fountain and to the LIFTS (elevators)...
The freaking building is an upside down, sub terranean, ten story building. Floor one iS the Atrium. Nothing else on that floor. Pick a lift, pick a floor, down. There is no UP.
Down one floor, not UP, is level two. Three through nine, on down, all accessible by the lifts. Level ten is stairs only down from nine. And no... The freaking lifts do NOT go sideways, backwards, diagonal, flip over, spin around, or ANY of that movie SH**!
You cannot just walk in and casually stroll TO the DoM.
GF grrrrrr chapter 33 . 4/30/2019
From earlier, but my tablet died before I could finish.

Adrenalin infused plot foul! (Comes from typing while too excited, and NOT thinking)

If the blinding storm is wreaking that much havoc, and visibility is THAT bad, then no one saw the last vampire jump, dive, fly, whatever... And NO ONE saw the explosion, good guy or bad.
(The ONLY visibility is through the spelled sights of the crossbows. )
GF going nuts chapter 33 . 4/30/2019
If "Lily's smoky body was absorbed by the sword" (direct quote) then she is NOT there to interact with James patronus being/ghost. You keep eliminating characters, and bringing them back in the next paragraph!? Later... Lily is NOT going to "See you soon, love" if her soul is sucked into hell, like YOU claim.

'Archmage Snape' sent FIVE spells at Harry, homing in on him to accomplish what? Fiv wittle ouchies that left booboos? I doubt the INeffectiveness of his spellwork, even IF he 'was tired', from earlier, with the snowstorm.
GF foul caller chapter 33 . 4/30/2019
Tracey is flying high over the battlefield?! I missed something... or you forgot where you are. Harry, Voldysnake, and Dumbles are all in the entrance Hall(!), if I follow like I thought I did. Flamel is the ONLY one outside. A bunch of teachers (?) (there are only like, ten teachers to BEGIN with!) are up on the second floor (but MOST of them are dead according to that first wave of vampires and werewolves, where "they fell" to the insurmountable numbers... and where are all of THEM, NOW?)
So, apparently you are just makin' sh## up as you go!
GF chapter 28 . 4/27/2019
I just dont get why, if you can become a huge sabretooth tiger, you wouldnt fight a weretiger in that form. tear its throat out and be done. Why have the ability? Why WRITE the ability?
G Fawkes chapter 26 . 4/25/2019
All this time in Venice, there's no mention of going back to Japan on Weds to teach?

I REALLY think mass must have some kind of boundaries in transfiguration. A single hair turned into a trunk is a bit extreme. Mcgonagall's desk into a pig seems ok. Her animagus of a small tabby cat is a little off, too. James into a stag. Sirius into a large dog. All ok. Peter into a rat is too small if you go by mass. No one is ever going to be an elephant animagus... Or a draft horse... Or a water buffalo.
A match can be a needle, but Harry turning a knut into a katana? Too much. Even though it IS fiction, and even if MOST of science's laws are broken by magic, physics HAS to have SOME bearing.
G Fawkes chapter 25 . 4/24/2019
Fanfiction or not, and historical date of a REAL tsuNami or not, how in the (expletive) do you justify voldysnake even thinking a tsunami could reach Harry, when NO One knows where Harry IS?!
Surely, you have to target WHERE you want a ritual storm to hit? The swirly, whirly, magic waves cannot just encompass the whole world and FIND Harry?
What if he was in Nebraska? Is the nearest river going to rise up and chase him like in LOTR? Maybe a really big wave at a public pool? Killer birdbath attack as he walked by?
Guest chapter 2 . 4/23/2019
The dragon is here to protect, and your poems you must perfect. Come on let’s have some fun, and ride into the setting sun. I’m writing this review, to dedicate to you.
2,742 | « Prev Page 1 .. 2 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 22 .. Last Next »