Reviews for Goodnight
Guest chapter 1 . 2/3
good since this is just Erik dying it has some of the original Phantom but if you were to the rest of their lives the fell would weaken
AnElusiveDreamer chapter 1 . 11/11/2010
Awww, sweet and sad... nicely done.
anonymous chapter 1 . 12/1/2007
I'm a reviewer who actually adores all four main versions of Phantom-from movie to play, from Leroux to Kay...but I tend to prefer the former to the latter. Prior to Goodnight, I hadn't seen many good Leroux fics. But this story did something that very few pieces of published fiction, even, have been able to accomplish.

It made me cry. Hard.

So I decided to stamp out my normal impulse to just sit back and lurk, and let you know that your piece is a wonderfully woven, descriptive, and emotionally charged tale that kept me riveted from the first line to the last. The addition of the ribbon was, in my opinion, a particularly touching detail, as were the contents of the Persian's bundle. Be proud of Goodnight, Crystal, because it's fantastic.
Pertie chapter 1 . 3/23/2006
Breathtakingly beautiful and quite poignantly sad.

Wonderfully written as well.

Thank you.
tigersmeleth chapter 1 . 3/2/2006
Hello! I just wanted to tell you that your wonderful story has been ad to the C2 "Music of the Night"
scarlet dreamer chapter 1 . 2/27/2006
beautiful and moving am actually crying short but expresses alot of emotions
Ponee chapter 1 . 1/18/2006
omg, that was the first fan fic that actually made me shed tears...im getting my computer wet, i have to go get a kleenex. *sob*
Sue Raven chapter 1 . 10/15/2005
I read this story because it was recommended on a post on PPN. I'm grateful for that recommendation. This was a beautifully written, emotionally charged work. It's short, but Christine's character has made a definite change for the better. Thank you for sharing it.
orianna-2000 chapter 1 . 10/14/2005
Ah, found you! Took a bit of creative searching, since I wanted to leave a review here, rather than on PFN. The story is bittersweet and lovely. Very touching, and nice to see a Leroux fic for a change around here. I was curious why you stuck so closely to Leroux's version, but then used the Opera Populaire? It stuck out a bit, but aside from that, I loved it, and I'll be keeping an eye out for your other stories.
Alice chapter 1 . 8/24/2005
I shed two tears for this one, first from the right eye and then from the left.

This was beautiful. So unique - Erik dies, forgiven, and Christine lives.
fictionreader chapter 1 . 8/5/2005
Beautiful story...so well written...I actually wept..This is going on my favoites list.
ilsa chapter 1 . 8/3/2005
Beautiful story. I enjoy the Leroux!Erik and Christine, who really does feel only compassion - not passion! for her angel, her teacher, her Erik. Your story was really true to the spirit of Leroux and what a nice way for it to end - that Erik died peacefully and he had the chance to know that Christine really did keep her vow to him.
Gondolier chapter 1 . 7/28/2005
I mentioned this on PFN, but I love this story! So sad and beautiful. This is how I would like to think that Erik's life ended. Lovely writing, with just the correct tinge of darkness that is infused in POTO. I am putting this on my favorite's list, most definitely. I hope to read more from you!