Reviews for Revolution
callietitan chapter 41 . 4/14/2023
I have just finished rereading this for the first time in a long time. It was just as enthralling this time around as it was way back in the 2000s when I first read it. Having grown from 13 to 30 in that time, I find that there are new things I appreciate. I love how you write the characters as realistically flawed, a skill that is often overlooked.
I realize now that so very often the Snape that lives in my head is your Snape, and I want to thank you for that.
Given recent events, so much of the joy has gone out of Harry Potter to me. I am grateful that there are things in the fandom that I still can love, that still make me stay up all night reading, even when I know the story.
I don't know if I ever finished Resolution back in the day- I recall the premise being a bit hard for me to wrap my mind around. Maybe that's changed in the last decade. We shall certainly see.
-callietitan (Sam)
tamer.of.the.wild.things.13 chapter 22 . 8/13/2022
I have picked this up at someone's suggestion on AO3 and I've liked it so much even though it is different than what I usually read, I've only slept a couple hours each night the last few days getting through this and the prequel. Your writing is good enough that even when I didn't agree with a lot of things, the piece was so good overall that I kept with it. I know this isn't the kind of comment authors like to hear, as I've written some myself too, but the situation in this chapter, where Arthur and Tonks (but realmy, everyone in that room) in particular turn on Harry is what has made me be turned completely off of this fic. I understand that authors can and definitely should write what they want, but as throughout the whole thing you have seemed to really like Tonks, keep circling back to her often which makes her seem important to you/your story- I just thought I'd share something a colleague (who teaches creative writing at a university level) reiterates all of the time: protect your main characters. Not like Mary Sues, but if you want people to be on their side, want people to keep reading about them, then don't make them do anything that would make the audience turn on them.
Annarog chapter 6 . 9/3/2021
Great story!
Guest chapter 41 . 7/20/2021
You are such a talented author. I’ve read this series three times and am currently re-reading:-)
M-chanchen chapter 41 . 6/6/2021
What a story! I enjoyed reading very much. You did great at writing. Very well done. The dark plane is a really interesting concept. I liked also that Kali made a recurring appearance.
Indian magic seems in parts quite different to what the British wizards know. Interesting idea.
Zander L. Jones chapter 1 . 12/22/2020
Fave Harry Potter trilogy with the dark world
Books85 chapter 27 . 9/19/2020
I know that Harry instructs authority, but it's stupid to notice a curse on the Ministers office door and not mention it to someone,especially if people are acting out of character.
Village-Mystic chapter 41 . 8/31/2020
Quite lovely. Enjoying your continued plot and character moments.
Village-Mystic chapter 40 . 8/31/2020
Cool reveal. And it could be possible. BTW we didn't have "on camera" with Harry telling Mr. Weasley that Percy wasn't responsible for his interrogation, only that Moody was still alive out there somewhere. It seems to me, if Harry was going to confide in Mr. Weasley, he might want to indicate that someone is messing with his son (and his son's reputation).
Village-Mystic chapter 39 . 8/31/2020
A good follow-up chapter, even if some things are still unresolved.
Village-Mystic chapter 38 . 8/31/2020
Parts of this chapter seemed a little rushed, not enough explanation of what was going on in elapsed time for me. Overall this long story has been very good. Was Percy imperio-ed or cursed? What happened to the house-evles who are imprisoned? I figured Hermione would be invited to teach charms sooner or later, though. I figured they might hire Severus or another snake animagus, and am curious what they may have done instead.
Village-Mystic chapter 37 . 8/31/2020
Well, here's hoping that Harry can remove other curses from people, too.
Village-Mystic chapter 36 . 8/31/2020
That's a lot of action, and still a lot of mysteries.
Village-Mystic chapter 35 . 8/31/2020
Maybe the house-elves have a special land they go to in the summer? Or their own funerals? Or are kept prisoner by the bad guys' house-elves. So many possibilities.
Village-Mystic chapter 33 . 8/31/2020
I hope you give Harry a chance to talk about his healing and Fawkes.
2,579 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »