Reviews for The Perfect Rose
Wild Concerto chapter 1 . 6/17/2014
IamthePhantomoftheOpera chapter 1 . 7/6/2009
wow...i think this may have been one of the morbidest stories yet...i think Erik went stark-raving mad...anyways, great story! you definitely deserved those awards.
BrideofPhantom chapter 1 . 3/5/2009
oh my GOD. that was NASTY. just...ew. it was awesome. and also ew. did i mention ew?

don't mind me. i loved it. an insane erik. perfecto.

also...ew. .
Lia Felix chapter 1 . 6/13/2008
Oh my...the descriptions...loved it... dark...

No other words to describe it, it gave me chills! Adored it!
The-Phanatics chapter 1 . 2/10/2008
wow...we kinda like this side of Erik...we just didn't expect it to be Raoul. Good Job...and all that blood.

~The Phanatics~
Kinda-Mayvelle chapter 1 . 11/21/2007
Sa, I loved it! Perhaps it's odd of me to say, but I didn't find this disturbing at all. It actually made sense.

If that isn't a snapshot of my mental stability, I'm not sure what is...

But lovely nonetheless. It deserves all the praise it can get.
this is not a pipe chapter 1 . 6/8/2007
I tried to close my eyes in order to block the image out, but soon realized I wouldn't know what happened next. It's funny, I was reading a wonderful modern day Phantom story, when I look into the author's profile in search of a sequel. Lo and Behold! It was none other than kat097, a favorite of mine since the story What Should Have Happened.

So I immediately began scrounging your profile and went on a hunt for your horror fics. Truly gruesome, if I do say so myself. I don't know how I knew what a heart cut out of it's body would look like, but I could picture it in my head. And closing my eyes didn't work AT ALL. So good job on ruining my appetite, but I wasn't planning on eating much anyways.

Poor Christine...this would make a perfect Leroux Erik.
dark-hearted rose chapter 1 . 3/27/2007

wow. a COMPLETELY different animal from the other one I just read, "My Beloved Teacher". I could almost ::smell:: the blood, the decription was just gushing out from the screen at me (sorry, horrible pun...). and you have to feel a little sorry for poor Raoul...

hehe... well, I'll leave that work for someone else.

I liked it. very morbid, gory, etc. you write horror very well. and I think the most terrifying and fascinating part of this (and the other one I read as well, but mostly this) is that he just goes about it so clinically and calculated.

*shivers again* well done. I'm going to be seeing that over and over in my head for at least a week.

warm regards,

dark-hearted rose
Virginie chapter 1 . 2/17/2007
Morbid but oh that was great ! Perfect
Bye. See ya. Or not chapter 1 . 10/25/2006
o... skin crawling... sick... twisted... LOVED IT!

bb xx K.A.
gamgee chapter 1 . 10/9/2006
This story is so beautiful, yet its so sad! BEAUTIFUL. Please, please, please, write more!
mad about books chapter 1 . 9/24/2006
I love this story, even if it is dark and very macabre,

I love the way you portrayed Erik!

Fantastic job!
Helden chapter 1 . 9/13/2006
Ah, beautiful, dear authoress. Absolutely beautiful.


Caroline Butler
J.S. Mews chapter 1 . 8/7/2006
You have a sick mind...but I like it. Good writing - keep it up!
MyPhoenixLament chapter 1 . 7/15/2006
This was terrifyingly beautiful, though I shudder to think that you merely placed third. (Although I almost want to read the one that won, just to see...) Well, I most certainly did not expect that it was Raoul in the beginning, but as soon as she entered the room I had a small feeling in the pit of my stomach in anticipation of what she would find. Very, very morbid, demented, and the like. But also very believable, and absolutely, without a doubt, brilliant. Well done.
48 | Page 1 2 3 .. Last Next »