|Reviews for Circular Reasoning|
| darqhorse chapter 29 . 8/15
| GenericCraft chapter 29 . 7/4
very good chapter loved it.
| Zasha the Cat chapter 29 . 6/28
Holy shit, an update of my all-time favourite fic? Am i hallucinating?
| dtonebu chapter 29 . 6/25
This story is too old and this is its main plus and minus. Mediocre borrowing from different fandoms is also annoying. And the way you dump the background along with the plot causes indifference at best. A whole chapter about the prehistory that it would be nice to stretch for the whole fanfiction a little bit, but why when you can make everything easier? In general, it is weak and overrated for my taste.
| NonsensicalRants chapter 29 . 6/25
This was pretty high up on my lost of great stories I thought would never be finished. I thought you were gone man, and based on your tale of woe you almost were. I had a stressful couple years too. One of them lost to alcoholism after a devastating financial setback. Nobody in my life died and I had good family to help me through the tough times. Hope you get better too.
In fact it had been so long since I first read this story that I had to go back and reread the first chapter to remember most of the story. Even now a cant remember a few things. Did Harry always have the ability to dream about places and things like an out of body experience? I remember him doing that once with the ghost girl. I also don't remember what most of his gear the servant was playing with. May actually
This chapter took me a few days to get through. Your chapters are so long! It's amazing. I quite liked it. I especially liked the past memories bits. You correct the show don't tell mistake in the first chapter by just mentioning the Harry as a serial killer thing as an after thought.
Just that but more fleshed out would be a fantastic story by itself and I want to read more of it.
I'm sure you understand that I positively do not give a single iota of a care about the baron and his problems. But that's because I don't remember them and may change that opinion when I do eventually reread the story.
God bless, keep up the work writing. Also do you have a 1 dollar tier patrons?
| dbreezy93 chapter 29 . 6/24
I am so happy this is being finished. I just binge read the whole thing in two daysto refresh my memory.
| automaton14 chapter 29 . 6/22
absolutely phenomenal! beyond pumped you're picking this up again, thank you so much for the update
| Zoanzon chapter 29 . 6/22
Holy shit, it's...done?
I think I first stumbled on this around...2009, 2010? Back in fucking middle school. And now, half a decade after college, I get to see it finish. (And finally have motivation to truly, once and for all, go back and take it from the top because I remember maybe 20% lol.)
But goddamn, despite the miasma that now hangs over the HP fandom now for obvious reasons and the way lives drift and etc etc, I'm glad you're able to put this to rest in a way you're satisfied with, and I'm glad to see a bit of my childhood get an ending.
| Novicewriter 9907 chapter 29 . 6/22
| The one who hates one-shots chapter 29 . 6/21
you are an excellent writer, it's fun to read and appreciate how much your writing has mattered over time- especially within the latest chapter.
I'm glad you have found the interest to finish this story and I will watch more me great content when you do!
| Akashic Vinyl chapter 29 . 6/20
Sucks he got the shitty Lady. I kind of want him to hook up with Lily, just because it would definitely piss of literally every other Queen of faerie. Assuming Liliy is Lily right now and not Aurora still. Crazy this updated after so long.
| Armiture chapter 1 . 6/19
This story was recommended by one of my favorit authors, as having started updating again. It's dark and gritty and I especially liked Harry's FU spell at the end. I look forward to reading the rest, albeit slowly.
| Drachna chapter 29 . 6/17
Whoo! I was hoping that Circular Reasoning would get another chapter, and what a chapter it was! I really enjoyed having more insight into how Harry became the way he was, and you didn't disappoint. You're writing has definitely improved a lot and it was already very good, so kudos I guess.
I'm looking forward to the next one.
| Bluesnowman chapter 29 . 6/19
Very interesting and very happy for the update.
| ForsensProgeny chapter 29 . 6/18
This is so surreal to me. This was the first well written fic I found on this site, and it's shaped the way I write myself. I never thought I'd ever see it updated. Welcome back, and I hope you continue it 3