Reviews for Greatest
Araloth the Random chapter 1 . 11/20/2009

I can so imagine those two arguing over who's the greatest like that. Gah, musicians. The drama that revolves around my choir is phenomenal. Nice touch with Tinfang Warble/Gelion, by the way. I really enjoyed this! Nicely done!

Lady MSM chapter 1 . 2/21/2008
I love this. Maglor and Daeron sound like such a pair of arrogant rock stars.
Kestrel chapter 1 . 9/30/2007
I loved this! Glad to see my favorite minstrels, and it seems Daeron can be just as snooty as a Noldor. The idea was good, and the verbal sparring was very good. The ending was a bit...abrupt? And adding mention of Galadriel set the timeline. I thought this would be a good series, though, this is a good "first chapter".

Blodeuedd chapter 1 . 1/29/2006
I like it. As Daeron's fellow flautist, I felt impelled to root for him from the start, but as this little story continued I became less polarized and started really smiling at the easy flow of the dialogue and how it revealed the narrative's course (and not vice versa). Tinfang's quietness in comparison to the Maglor vs. Daeron bicker-session is especially funny. Nicely done.
Vana Tuivana chapter 1 . 12/10/2005
Silly Maglor. Of *course* the flute is better. ;-)

How clever to bring in Tinfang Warble along with the other two "greatest" musicians; I've never seen him before in fanfiction, which is rather a loss. Very silly argument... but altogether too plausible, sad to say, knowing our two favorite musicians.

I really liked this piece. Good writing!
Me chapter 1 . 12/8/2005
This was cute and funny. The arguing between Daeron and Maglor is quite amusing. Poor Tinfang, hehe
Ellfine chapter 1 . 12/8/2005
This is cute and funny! I loved the bantering back and forth and the pride and arrogance of the two. Poor Tinfang!

I enjoyed this very much. Well done!

**still snickering and shaking my head**