Reviews for Becoming Neville
Prackspoor chapter 7 . 8/23/2016
I wonder what the "driftwood" clue will turn out to be in the end.

Your Tonks is even better than the original. I always liked her, but here she's rising quickly to one of my favourite characters. Makes you wonder what would've happened if she'd been in the same year as Fred and George. They'd probably blown up Hogwarts between them.

Finally Neville is starting to notice he's not only being involved but also that he finally starts to believe in him self. It's high time the boy gained some self-confidence.

Favourite quote comes from Harry this time:

"I thought you were reading up on exorcism." - "I was, but I got sidetracked."
The personality of Harry Potter in a nutshell.
Prackspoor chapter 6 . 8/23/2016
Having Lupin grow up in St. Mungo's is a very cool idea. It makes sense seeing how sometimes parents just aren't able to deal with a severely impaired child. I don't see why this should not apply to the magical world as well.
The scene where they bond over lost parents is nice, although I must say that "The Orphan Welfare League" sounds like something Hermione would have come up with instead of one of those three.

Neville's in charge of the project - nice!
Prackspoor chapter 5 . 8/23/2016
Addition to Chapter 4: The scene were they figure out the messages on the wrappers is spine-chilling.

"Help me."

It poses so many questions. Why does she need their help? Against whom? I wonder if St. Mungo's is everything it makes out to be.
All in all, the scene is creepy as hell.

Chapter 5:

I really like the Golden Trio dynamics here and all the difficulties they are having. Ron and Hermione getting closer while Harry's being periodically distant. Neville is a good observer when he wonders about how they can be such close friends in the first place. Seamus and Dean having a betting pool is awesome and I'm adding that to my head-canon of Gryffindor house.

It's aggravating to read how inferior Neville feels next to the trio, though. He's always putting himself below them. While he might never be as close to the three as they are to each other, it's sad to see that he thinks so little of his own accomplishment. Then again, this is Neville we are talking about and it's a realistic way to write him.
You can relate to him and Ginny, when it is made clear that the trio is a private circle you cannot simply become part even if you might want to.
On the other hand it's interesting to read of his resentment against his parents being seen as another mystery to solve. I don't think the trio is seeing the mystery exclusively with no regard to Alice and Frank as people, but I can see why this might rub Neville the wrong way.

That being said, I really like your Ron. He seems more mature than the original and it requires less suspension of disbelief why Hermione would fancy him.
Prackspoor chapter 4 . 8/23/2016
Augusta Longbottom owns this chapter from the first time she makes an appearance. When you ignore that like almost everyone else she is underestimating Neville and putting him down in a way, she's awesome.
On the other hand, from a healer's perspective she is probably the worst patient you could have what with smoking in a hospital et cetera.

The scenes with Neville's parents are at the same time heart-warming and heart-breaking. It's sad that Neville is always worried about what Harry is thinking or that he'll be made fun of for something he does. But at least he allows his mother to groom him despite everything, because it matters more to him than other people's opinions. Good job on the scene where he is envious of Harry. The sentiment is very relatable. On the other hand, I think no one would say that Harry didn't deserve a bit of motherly affection as well which makes it all the more difficult.

I enjoy the little details you mention which make the whole story more realistic because those are things everyone subconsciously picks up on and can relate to, e.g. old women reading cheap paperbacks which are stacked on their nightstand, patients complaining about their food and so on and so on.
Prackspoor chapter 3 . 8/23/2016
And Harry's back to being a grouch - at least, it's consisent with the moodiness he displayed all through the Order of the Phoenix. That being said, for someone who is regularly getting worked up about how people aren't taking him seriously enough, he's amazingly insensitive when it comes to taking Neville seriously.

Tonks making an appearance is awesome.
"Tonks, it's a glass house." - "Of course!" - "That means it's made of glass." Those are my favourite lines in this chapter.
Prackspoor chapter 2 . 8/23/2016
Neat expansion of canon regarding the greenhouse, I must say. This is definitely going to make Neville's stay at Grimmauld Place more pleasant.
His dreams speak volumes about what's going on inside of him and what's nagging and tearing at him, Bellatrix especially. It's strange to read Neville even considering using the Killing Curse, but in this case I'm buying it.
Good to see Harry's getting over his grumpiness. Neville's not to blame for anything after all and each keeping to themselves won't make summer holidays any less boring.
Prackspoor chapter 1 . 8/23/2016
An interesting start to an interesting story. Your Neville is the most authentic and true to the original I've seen around here and your clear style of writing makes it easy to get into his head. You capture the gloomy atmosphere of Grimmauld place really well. I also like how you portray Harry and Remus and how hard Sirius' death is on them. Harry moved on very quickly in the original and while I can understand that the plot needs to move forward, he's a bit non-chalant about losing his godfather and does not think much of him at all during the sixth volume.
1sunfun chapter 34 . 7/11/2016
Nice Story.
OnyxBear22 chapter 34 . 7/5/2016
Aww... I cried a little at the end. it was too beautiful!
JuceBi chapter 34 . 6/20/2016
oh what a beautiful beautiful story!
of course I kind of expected a medical wonder but your solution is so much better. the ending is open and Neville is happy. it's great how you made it round and good. is there a sequel? it's really one of favorotes and I'm immensly satisfied with it but I awohld loc a to learn more about it. until now it fits right into cannon but the rest could be a bit more AU? oh I'm really excited .
it was one of my best reads.
NoMrDarcy chapter 1 . 6/4/2016
Hi! I don't know if you read these any more, but man, I just want to thank you so much for this story. Heart-wrenching and well-written and nuanced. It really meant a lot.

So - Thanks :)
MadHatter.Roar chapter 34 . 5/17/2016
I truly do not understand why this story doesn't have more favs. Truly the best fic I've read in a very long time.
Ella The Puff chapter 34 . 5/13/2016
Sequel? Or epilogue? Or something so I can stop crying? This story is the best thing ever!
Acutagava chapter 1 . 4/29/2016
Your story was amazing!
thepajamaqueen85 chapter 34 . 4/10/2016
This was wonderful to read!
1,349 | « Prev Page 1 .. 2 3 4 5 6 13 .. Last Next »