|Reviews for A Rogue's Journal|
| Sooty85 chapter 61 . 11/15/2022
Well that was just excellent !
I thoroughly enjoyed it all :~)
(I just wish it hadn’t ended on a cliffhanger with her reappearing powers, hopefully if they do come back she has gained total control over her skin, fingers crossed)
| jenwincart chapter 1 . 6/24/2021
| Whisper184 chapter 16 . 7/28/2014
Aww! This makes me want a John/Rogue so bad! But I still like the Scott/Rogue going on here.
| KraZiiePyrozHavemoreFun chapter 61 . 7/9/2014
A wonderful read!
| Sophi chapter 61 . 9/5/2013
I loved your story! I liked how you incorporated God at the end without making it preachy. And I would like to think Rogue will learn to control her powers...I know she does eventually in the comics. At first I was hesitant because of the format but I really liked it. I liked how you kept her relationship with Logan intact and kept the plot strong. Really great! You've got some real writing talent. :)
| Capofmyheart chapter 61 . 8/14/2013
Amazing, loved it!
| greenskinned chapter 61 . 3/3/2013
This was the kind of story I was looking for! The best one I have read in months! It was amazing...kept me awake all night but it was worth it. BRAVO!
| Suze Nora chapter 61 . 10/9/2012
i love this. i also love how her 'poison' skin came to advantage during scott's 'can't see-hear-talk' period. good job :)
| SaltWaterSwimmer29 chapter 61 . 12/7/2011
Wow, this was really good! The character development was so interesting to read! Great job! I really enjoyed reading this!
| CindersAndRain chapter 61 . 12/7/2011
This was one big story and I have to say, this is also one of the finest that I've read on . Great work!
The inner conflicts, the theories, the development of character, moral and beliefs, it was all greatly written. Coupled with the time gap, it was actually a very believable journal. I could actually picture Rogue doing all that in spite of the fact that this is the first Scott/Rogue fanfiction that I've ever read. Usually, I got for Logan/Rogue. You've made me a shipper of yet another X-Men couple!
The final battle was very beautifully written and I must compliment you on writing the scenes, thought processes and reactions in great detail.
I look forward to reading more from you.
| Ileah chapter 61 . 7/29/2011
Wow, that is a long story. The style is interesting- how Rogue would digress onto different topics and add pieces to the story that might have been difficult to otherwise fit in. I like it.
| Witchy-grrl chapter 61 . 6/25/2011
OHH THIS WAS AWESOME. :D I LOVE LOVE LOVE how you portrayed everyone here, especially Rogue. I remember being irritated with her in the movies, thinking she was SO much weaker and whinier than I wanted. You definitely highlight that side of her LOL, but you also gave her such badly-needed strength, and total kickassery. Balancing the teenage insecurity with more adult confidence is tough, but you definitely pulled it off!
And SCOTT. OH HOW I LOVE YOUR SCOTT. He's serious but playful and HOT when he wants to be, which has been sorely lacking in X-men fics I've been reading lately. I REALLY appreciated that. :P
ABSOLUTELY going in my favs!
| mizgardenia21 chapter 61 . 4/22/2011
I think you did a really good job with this. It definitely kept my attention and it was refreshing and very unique in some places. I enjoyed it.
| Trevor X chapter 61 . 5/7/2010
You've got quite the epic here. Didn't run into it until lately, but enjoyed the read. Hope you know that.
Happy writing on whatever else you may put your hand/mind to.
| The Reserved Reader chapter 61 . 4/23/2010
Wow... my eyes burn from being in front of the computer too long. I can't believe this is over it was so good. This is my favorite story and I can't believe I actually found something this amazing to read. I loved all your characters. You made them flawed yet incredibly likeable. I enjoyed the way you kept Marie's relationship with Logan in place which is something I usually see fall apart when it comes to Scott/Marie fics. How I wish the third movie had gone in this direction. There were some typing/spelling errors most of which were small so I'm guessing they were just overlooked. I think it would help if you read it out loud or have someone else read it so that they can be found more easily. I was really impressed at how well rounded it was. You had action, angst, drama, romance, and more combined with the wonderful voice of Marie. You even kept her powers intact while advancing them and still you gave her such a sensual relationship without much physical touching. Thanks for the amazing read!