|Reviews for And Eye for an Eye|
| Lexy chapter 1 . 7/21/2012
As much as I can understand the sentiment of the whole Dean probally would have killed them if they'd have hurt Sam and Sam wanted to kill them because they tortured Dean but I honestly don't think however seemingly justified by those peoples' actions that it would have been that Sam could have done it and still been able to live with the weight
On his conscience of what he'd done, that he'd killed another human being no matter how twisted they were I honestly amd whole-heartedly believe that IF Sam had gone back and taken revenge on them that it would have killed him , not literally but it would have killed him inside because of how guilty he would have felt even if it was because they hurt and were going to kill his brother.
| medicgirl chapter 1 . 6/16/2010
Amazing story. I loved Sam's reaction to Dean's pain, and his guilt that he hadn't taken revenge. Interesting to point out just how perceptive Dean really is. loved the whole "turn the other cheek" comment.
| The North Wyn chapter 1 . 4/19/2010
Aw, cute brother banter and protective!Sammy for the win! :)
| Gohanzgirl chapter 1 . 11/25/2009
I loved there banter! Wonderful writing!
| bhoney chapter 1 . 4/9/2009
I really liked this tag. The Benders has always been a favorite episode of mine.
Lots of great banter throughout. I've been so missing it on the show lately. This made me laugh: “I was supposed to inherit the next super power, damn it.”
Aw..."As a kid, he’d become an expert at scoping out hidden injuries his brother was constantly concealing." Love this glimpse into their childhood.
This made me laugh too: “Have I told you how warped you are, lately?” Dean smiled at him. “Yeah, but you can never say I love you enough, cupcake.”
And this: "Sam continued to look at him, the whole puppy dog eye thing going on. “I’m immune to your persuasive mind-bending powers, Captain Amazing.”" *snort* LOL
I LOVE protective Dean: "“I’d have killed them,” he finally said, trying to get his heart rate under control. After all, it wasn‘t Sam they‘d tortured-it was him. “I’d have killed them all.” Dean had said as much when the bastards had rubbed Sam’s imminent demise in his face. And he’d meant it."
I also really love protective Sam, and liked that he was really angry about what had been done to Dean.
Ah, here's the Sam I love and miss: "Dean watched his brother struggle with his monstrous humanity and felt both sorry for him and extremely proud of him." Wanting to do what's right, even when it's hard and painful. Wrestling with his morality.
Really enjoyed this tag. Nicely done.
| Rebell chapter 1 . 8/5/2008
I loved this fic! It shows lots of that special brotherly bond that fangirls like me love to see, and not to mention you kept them both completely in character! I mean, I could literally picture our boys going back and forth in their little arguments, saying exactly those things.
Absolutely amazing. Great job!
| Rat chapter 1 . 5/25/2008
| catnthecradle chapter 1 . 4/14/2008
Wow, voices and characterizations spot on. I just wish they'd shown us this scene in the episode. Please keep writing.
| tanpopo no hana chapter 1 . 2/3/2008
That was... so cool. Their conversation was flawless, simply amyzing. This could have been straight out of the episode. Great work! I saw you have another tag to Benders so I'm going to check that out now :o)
| Ivy3 chapter 1 . 8/18/2007
That was a perfect post-ep. I noticed the look Sam gabe Kathleen and I'm glad you've addressed it. Great talk between the brothers.
| girlfan1979 chapter 1 . 6/13/2007
I want to say something deep and meaningful, but I got nothing. It's a great fic though. I especially liked the way you tied up Dean's reaction to Missy and the look that passes between Sam and Kathleen.
Best Benders tag/missing scene I've seen.
| lookaftersammy chapter 1 . 4/26/2007
Aww.. this is so sappy and mushy and beautiful.. well done.
| KatieLB chapter 1 . 4/24/2007
any tag that ends with 'love you too sammy' rules in my book LOL great job...this episode was so emotional...dean screaming he would kill them all echo'd in my head for days! great job
| Child of a Pineapple chapter 1 . 3/19/2007
You're right - there wasn't enough comfort.
I absolutely loved this.
The banter was amazing.
| Izzy4 chapter 1 . 2/26/2007
I liked it. Nice banter between the boys.