|Reviews for Keep it a Mystery|
| Guest chapter 38 . 2/22
I know this was yeas ago. But thank you. Thank you so much. Possibly one if not the best Phanfic I have had the pleasure of reading. Brava x
| Ayliane chapter 38 . 8/7/2016
I loved your story since the beginning. The characterisation was great and the premices were original. Finally a modern fanfic where Erik is not some kind of assassinor mercenary but a composer! I really enjoyed the way characters of the Phantom of the Opera were put to use in this work. Most of all, the relationship between Christine, Raoul and Eril was, I think one of the best written I have ever read. I really liked your Raoul especially his last phone call to Christine where he is the one to acknowledge Christine's feeling for Erik.
The best part though remains the unmasking scene and its aftermath. It was great! Never before had I read a version of this scene where it happened as I felt it should be. Yes Christine screamed, because as she said it, she is only human, and Erik did howl in betrayal, but calmed himself enough afterward to listen a bit to Christine.
I loved your Christine, how despite her naiveté and her difficulty to confront her feelings, in the end, she managed to find freedom by herself, not by being rescued by Raoul once again. I must admit that the bit about being an investigation journalist put me off at the begining because I really couldn't see Christine do something like that. But in the end, it was all good.
Finally the interactions between Erik and Nadir were some of my favourites bits. I love both of them, how their differences creates a unique dynamic and you wrote them wonderfully.
Thank you for the amazing read.
| Guest chapter 38 . 6/15/2016
You know how Erik hates broken promises. I believe your exact words were, "But I haven't forgotten the story and it will be finished by the end of august! I promise that." Well then I hope you meant august of 2016! Please oh please update! I might have to bring out the pitchforks and torches if you don't. Ugh.… just kidding! Sort of, anyway I just really love this story so I would love for you to update!
| Child of Dreams chapter 24 . 5/18/2016
Where in the world have you been hiding?
Really, you were perfect!
I only wish I knew your secret!
Who is your great tutor?
| Child of Dreams chapter 23 . 5/18/2016
(frowns in confusion)
I don't recognize the name, are you sure you didn't mean Aminta?
| Child of Dreams chapter 3 . 5/18/2016
Bouquet, not bonnet.
| Kalia of Camelot chapter 38 . 2/2/2014
Wow. What an amazing story! I loved it, thankyou for writing
| MademoiselleLovely chapter 1 . 11/22/2012
God, I just love this story! I've come back to it and found that I love it even more the second time around! I REALLY didn't think that was possible. Honestly, if you ever see this review, PLEASE consider finishing this story, it's amazing as is, but with an ending... just please think about it. :)
| Camelot Emrys chapter 38 . 10/29/2012
This story is AMAZING! I love it! You put soo much detail in the characters! Usually in many stories, the authors tend to change how they first envisioned their characters. It gets a bit tiresome to read stories where the characters are soo compete occ or just randomly change all of a sudden. This makes your story sooooo fantastic because you kept the characters in, well, character (I hope you understand what I'm trying to say :)). Soo I love it! Please update soon! I can agree that you left the story in a way that chapter 38 could be the ending...but I do want to see more of this story. Perhaps that last chapter you talked about and the epilogue? Please!
Sorry, I tend to ramble :D. I do have to say that you are definitely one of my favourite authors now. This story is just beautiful and I enjoyed reading it.
| MademoiselleLovely chapter 38 . 6/28/2012
Lovely! Simply lovely! Words cannot adequately describe how very much I have enjoyed reading this masterpiece of fan fiction, and as much as I would LOVE to know the ending, you left this story at a point were you can almost settle with yourself how you personally think it should finish. It can almost be philosophical, you can delve into your psyche after writing your own ending and see what it tells about yourself, but enough with my crazed ramblings, thank you for being an AWESOME writer! You are officially now my favorite author!
| BirchTreeWoman chapter 38 . 6/18/2012
please don't stop!
| Skyler-A-Teloiv chapter 38 . 5/4/2012
Im terriibly unhappy that you left this story at such a point Z! I want Erik to whine and have Christine love him into singing and them get married and Erik meet Meg!
Am i wasting my time by hoping it will happen?
| Scarlett Raine chapter 38 . 2/19/2012
This is an AMAZING story. The amount of technical detail you implemented is astounding. The characters and story progression were all very believable and just wow. It was great. I read the entire thing in one day.
I just wish it were finished!
But, at least you made it to the point where Erik and Christine are reconciled and to-be-wed. :)
I must know though: what did you intend for the rest of the story?
| AddictedToBooks97 chapter 38 . 1/31/2012
OMG! I love this phanfic! ( Yeah, yeah, I know that I say that about a lot of phanfics. But I love a lot of them! XD ) You said at the beginning of this chapter that you would post a epilogue. Please do! Cause even though it's a bit obvious what happens next, you still left it a bit of a cliffhanger. If that makes sense. But a epilogue would be awesome!
| SkyBirdDance chapter 38 . 7/20/2011
Hey, I thought you said you were going to finish this story by August, 2009, and that was nearly two years ago!