Really enjoyed this story!

Oi, essa história é linda muito doce mesmo adoro. Que bom que Sam teve sorte e encontrou uma família que o ama agora chorei com todo sofrimento pelo que Dean passou que ótimo que ele encontrou Nick e a esposa proporcionaram um lar pra ele depois de tanta dor, e eles encontraram o amor finais felizes são uma dádiva, parabéns

SQUEEEE! o. my. g.
i love you for this beautiful work of art. it is one of the best, wait maybe the best. *cross-checking... yes, the best dean/sam ever written. ok i will stop worshipping now. perhaps.
this is great :) 3 (lol i read it all in one sitting. i got to chapter 6 and was like - fuck. its 13000 words... here we go, grab the tissues.)

Aw this was great! Once again I was laughing and crying. Keep on writing you do a great job! -Dawn

huh there you go :)

I don't even ship them but this was one of the best stories I have ever read, mainly because they boys actually got to have a happy ending for once

I love this story and they got a happy ending and I'm so glad and happy and cheerful after that wonderful ending. That's the reason I'm a bit hesitant to read the next two sequels, but we shall see where we end up :D Anyway. I love the depth and understanding and complexity of your characters. I even love your original characters. They were so human and easy to accept and Dean broke my heart in this story and Sam healed it again. I especially love the last chapter. It was so hesitant and sweet and it was truly the perfect ending. I sincerely believe that your next two sequels will be just as good.

I'm so glad I became Wincest Curious because otherwise I would have missed out on this cracking story. Superbly told, real characters and true voices. And a happy ending to a difficult situation. As it should be. Thank you so much.

Great fic. I love a happy ending.

You are the best.

Heartwarming story! After John's journal showed up, I was dreading that the Yellow-Eyed Demon would show up in the end at tear their hard found happiness to shreds, and was holding my breath until just now. What a relief! To me, this story had everything a good story should have. I really enjoyed it. Thank you very much!

Read this a while ago but just found it again. It's amazing, seriously. I have a huge thing for the finding out they're brothers bit. Loved it!

Honestly...i think i've read all of your wincest fics now and i have got to say you are my favorite writer...like A keep up the good work...i didnt expect to be shipping this so much.

I adored that little intro with Nick and Gary. It made me sigh and smile. Your characters are awesome, believable and I love them as much as the boys.

Dean waking up to those old ghosts hurt. To be honest, I started to cry. :( I don't normally get worked up over stories, but this just hit me SO HARD. How tortured he is. And how you painted that picture of him and Renie...she's like his mother and it was just painfully beautiful to get a better look at that, at how they were together. Dean's already lost so much. Losing someone you love and on top of that one of the only people you trust...there's nothing else like that. :/ And you infused those feelings, portrayed them just right. I just really, REALLY feel for him here.

This is one of my favorite parts EVER. It's so sweet but mean at the same time:
Nick," Dean said innocently.
"Your partner Nick?" Sam demanded. "The old guy?" He didn't wait for Dean's answer, taking one look at his smirk and punching him on the shoulder.
Typical Dean. xD I just...there are no words for me to say, except this is just like him. Messing with Sammy. Any way he can. And you captured that.

Oooooh my heart! What have you done to me, woman? I cried again when I read the flashback of Dean chatting with Nick about getting his certificate and how he wanted him to change his name. I feel like the grinch, my heart has grown three sizes in one day. I have so much love for this.

Thank you for showing Nick's semi-freak out at first before realizing he was being silly. Older folks do tend to be very conservative, so it's realistic and makes sense he would at least feel awkward in the beginning. I just love so much how you handled it. I cheered Nick on when he had his change of heart, and even more when he ended up truly liking Sam, not just tolerating him. :D

This felt like a punch in the gut:
"Just treat that boy right. I like him." Nick patted Dean's shoulder and trod the worn carpet to his own room.
"I like him too," Dean said softly.
It's like...there is this darker meaning underneath what Dean has said. Like maybe he doesn't believe he CAN treat Sam right? I mean, it's obvious he's got issues, but I think his self-loathing probably runs even deeper than what I've seen so far. It just HURTS to think he would believe that he will hurt Sam or that he isn't good enough for him.

I feel a bit awkward leaving a review because nothing I say can prove to you just how beautiful I think this story is, but I'll try. I've read so many of your stories and am always drawn in immediately. They are warm, funny, heart-wrenching and just...perfect. I've read them many times, particularly Memories of Me. You make the boys REAL for me. I feel what they feel and I root for them and cheer them on. You make me laugh and cry, sometimes simultaneously. While I adore some sexy porn you bring it ALL to the table. Hot sex and a nail-biting story-line that always leaves me craving more. I never want to reach the end of your stories. May sound ridiculous, but it doesn't make it any less true.

Old Ghosts is no different. I don't know why it took me so long to read this one. Should have known you wouldn't disappoint! The concept threw me a little at first, I guess. I don't particularly care for obvious AUs. Yours WORKS. Oh man does it work.

Your Dean breaks my heart. He's so damn strong, yet so haunted and...damaged at the same time. I connect so well with his defensiveness, how he's trying so hard to push those old memories and thoughts down, especially when they are threatening to ruin his time with Sam. Oh, Sam. 3 I hope that Sam's gentleness can knock down Dean's walls he's created for himself. I'm in love with Sam already.

I'm really pissed about this John thing, trying to figure out what good reason could he possibly have not to raise his boys (if he isn't dead, that is). Like, seriously. Way more upset than I have any right to be over a story.

Oh, BOYS. I'm anxious to find out how Sam deals with learning about Dean's past. Something this big has to come up at some point. And I assume there will come a time where they realize they're brothers. I just can't imagine it any other way, really. Crossing my fingers for a happy ending, but I realize those aren't always possible.