Reviews for Old Ghosts |
---|
debzzz chapter 6 . 9/9/2009 Aww...Seemingly that's all I can think of to say...Aw...That was so, so...cute! I just can't stop aww'ing! You did an awesome job out of this and it was so interesting that you didn't totally ignore canon, but instead you made the boys make a choice and never believe in what John did(hunting)! Trully amazing fic(even though there were no smutty scenes in the last chapter *wink*)! And I still keep thinking 'aw...' |
debzzz chapter 4 . 9/9/2009 Oh man! I tried, I really did! I tried very hard to contain myself and not review about silly stuff but I can't help it! Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying anything's wrong with the fic, far from it but...damn!I'm Greek and I just can't help myself...'moussaka', 'pastitsio' and 'Petrakos'? I was laughing(good-naturedly) so hard...especially when I think of yesterday's argument with my mum(-What's for lunch tommorrow? -Chicken soup. -But I want moussaka! -I don't have time for moussaka! -But! -It's chicken soup! Deal with it! -But! -You've been eating aubergines for the past week! It can't be healthy! -Fine!)...I just find it so weird when people mention things like that in fics! Btw this fic is totally awesome! It's amazing how you've kept both Dean and Sam in character while giving them totally different backgrounds! I really can't figure out how they'll find out that they're brothers in just two chapters but I bet it'll be very interesting! |
mapomi chapter 6 . 9/8/2009 Well, Wincest is not my kind of story, but yours is a good one and I enjoyed so much reading it. I'm quite offended with people that thinks an treats homosexulity as a illness or something to be ashamed of, people that thinks God would punish it... God is supposed to be Love and homosexulity is love as much as it is heterosexual love. God doesn't punish people to love one another! Another thing that I dislike is when all the characters that are homosexual in a story are supposed to behave as ultrageous pigs. There are dogs everywhere, but be homosexual doesn't mean to be a bad person. It just affects your love interests, nothing more. In your story you trated homosexuality with respect and there's nothing outrageous in the story, its developement or the characters. As a fact is such a sweet love story. Probably nobody would have any problem with it if Dean and Sam were called Dean and Samantha and they weren't related; but the fact is that you pointed out a harsh matter (at least for me): what does make family? Blood ties or continuous relationship? Does two brothers became brothers because they share same background and memories or because they have same genetics? I want to thank you for sharing it and tell you that you made a great work with it, at least under my humil point of view. Thank you! :) |
TheThirdSibling chapter 6 . 8/6/2009 I gotta say I usually never read Wincest, but this was just AWESOME! I like your descriptions, and the whole story is just perfect, love it!(: |
Mr Jakey Fakey chapter 6 . 7/31/2009 BEAUTIFUL! GREAT STORY! when it got to the 4th chapter and they still hadent found out they were brothers i was like hm where is this going, then when reading the fifth i was even more like HM *raises and eysbrow and pouts like preppy girls do* but then... THE TWIST! and THE PROBLEM AROSE! and THEN THE ANGST! AND THE RESOLUTION! and THE ENDING! it was perfect, a happy ending but not that kind of 'running over the hills with flowers in your hair and bunnys chasing you' kinda happy ending. (thats does not aply for me, bunnys scare me...theyre so small and innocent. i always think theyre just gonna fall apart when i touch them)...but yes. The ending was perfect. They accepted the problem. embraced it and made a future fro themselves...why am i telling you this...you wrote the story...*a brick flys out of no-where and hits me* god im all hyped up, must be my caffine addiction finally taking its toll. but about this peice of writing. fabulous. fabulous like Sammy's hair. xxJakey |
tracyg10 chapter 6 . 7/9/2009 Wonderful story really enjoy your writing |
The Sleeping Creature chapter 6 . 6/2/2009 Eehee. I read about half of this on your livejournal (or was it livejournal? whatever other website you have this story on) and meant to read the rest, then lost the link. I'm so happy to have found it again. I love that you tackled the tangled issue of GSA, and I love how the brothers are the different and the same. All in all, I've really enjoyed my time reading this (instead of studying for my math final tomorrow... DX). I'm really glad I can favorite it now! Thanks for posting such a great read. |
Sofi Stree chapter 1 . 5/19/2009 Alright, I don't know if you're even on this site anymore, but I just had to drop you a review and let you know how much I love this story. I'd never, ever been into Sam/Dean before I found this story by accident (the title is awesome, btw). I'd just never seen any sort of sexual tension on the show and honest the the thought of two brothers was kinda yuck to me. But holy freaking cow, you did a fanTAStic job with this story. When I first read it, it completely converted me to the whole Sam/Dean thing. Only now I can't read the tacky ones - I need quality, which is where you set the standard. :) Anyway, I love the story. It's sweet and sad and funny and sexy as hell. You make both characters very real and amazingly entertaining to read about. I seriously could not stop reading. It's just this quality you have in your writing that I love, and on top of that the setting and the plot is AMAZING. Muy bien! I had so much fun with the progression of their relationship, I can't even tell you. It's probably one of my favorite stories of any kind, canon or not. You not only gave them a slightly different characterization while still keeping their core attributes, you also put them in a fantastic setting with fantastic other characters (I love Dean's adoptive dad, especially with him being Greek). I love the scene with Sam and his friends and Dean being all jealous. Wow, I think I may be gushing a wee bit, but it's late and I'm tired. :) So, in conclusion, I like the story. If you ever decide to write more (than this one and the other two) in this AU, I would love to read it and review it. Very well done. Sofi |
Mel Storm chapter 5 . 5/18/2009 i loved this story! cant wait to read the sequel. peace mel storm |
shadowglove chapter 6 . 5/8/2009 *SQUEE!* THIS WAS AMAZING! I LOVED IT! *CONTINUES TO SQUEE LIKE CRAZY* |
kihe chapter 6 . 5/1/2009 I loved the story! |
Nfinity chapter 6 . 4/11/2009 I really enjoyed this story, even though I don't normally read AUs. I like how you tied in little bits of their actual canon past, making it a lot more interesting to read. And the fact that you kept them as brothers. The five stages of grief metaphor was a great touch. I thought it really fit what Sam was going through with the changes in their relationship. And, finally, I'm glad that Dean's past wasn't a major focus of the story. Some fics that have past abuse tend to get bogged down by the emotional baggage, but you handled it really well. Nfinity |
ElementalStar2019 chapter 6 . 3/31/2009 This will probably be the only AU I will ever love of Supernatural! You did an amazing job on this fic and I'm glad you wrote it. |
J.Gabrielle chapter 6 . 2/1/2009 I loved it! Every moment of it. It was amazing, awesome and super fun to read. Thanks for writing it and I wish your next venture well. |
CarolAnnly chapter 6 . 1/9/2009 This was a long, delicious Sam and Dean story beautifully told. Thank you for a wonderful glimpse into what might have been. Totally enthralling and filled with love. Perfect... |