Reviews for Eight
guest chapter 21 . 2/4
Wonderful! Thank you so much.
guest chapter 18 . 2/4
Well done. HP got books, the slimy tosser got tossed, and SS and HP got a hearty laugh - and neighbors who know magic! Perfect!
guest chapter 15 . 2/4
If you got complaints about McG's being OOC, you can ignore them. She joined the abominable Dumbles in aiding, abetting, and always believing the revolting Marotters (perfect sobriquet from Alethea27) for seven everlasting years as they repeatedly tortured and even tried to murder Snape. I can easily believe she caned both boys and intentionally hit harder and ever harder when each was silent. The kindest interpretation I can possibly imagine for her behavior over all those years is that Dumbles potioned or spelled her into joining in on his biased cruelties.
guest chapter 12 . 2/4
Lovely; HP has a friend as well as "My Snape." Progress should speed up a bit from here even though it won't be uniform. Excellent writing.
guest chapter 8 . 2/4
Damn! I was hoping she'd talk to Snape before the unspeakable Dumbles horned in with more Snape-torture.
guest chapter 5 . 2/4
Finally the actual talk begins! Excellent portrayal of the situation all along.
guest chapter 4 . 2/3
Well, at least Snape isn't a mean drunk, and he told HP to go play. ... Not quite ready to believe SS would brew while drunk, though, too dangerous ... More misunderstanding since SS forgot he told HP to go out, but he seems finally to have twigged.
guest chapter 2 . 2/3
Proceeding nicely. I like the tailor: he ~asked~ instead of making an assumption.
guest chapter 1 . 2/3
Good start. You've shown the mutual misunderstanding well. I probably won't review extensively, too tired, but thank you for writing and posting this. Your hard work shows.
Rege chapter 17 . 12/1/2022
I thought that was little Princess. One of my favourite stories
Calmzone1 chapter 21 . 12/1/2022
What a great story. Well done.
Bettina chapter 12 . 11/9/2022
what a breakthrough!
Guest chapter 6 . 2/17/2022
Eh, ok, tired of Snape repeatedly traumatizing an already traumatized kid. Not into child abuse. Moving on.
Guest chapter 1 . 2/17/2022
Feels so weird reading a story written so long ago that they actually thought Sirius had a trial, that Severus grew up elsewhere (how then did he meet Lily?) and that Lily was somehow a saint. Well-written, though.
TexasTurtle chapter 21 . 12/11/2021
Thank you for writing and sharing your wonderful story.
2,299 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »