Memorable tale. Loved the story's depth.
Balian really changed the lives of the Fellowship. Wonder if his faith in God will grow?

Thank you so much for writing this, can't wait to start the next instalment!

I remember reading this as a teenager and absolutely loving it.

i remember reading and enjoying this story several years ago.

What a delight to happen back upon it!

:)

Gandalf is Santa Claus

The entire story was one of the best fanfics I've ever read. I truly liked this but as it is your 1st fanfic, it is not perfect. For example, the part where Legolas tells Balian about Sauron and The One Ring is too short. I don't think such a little explanation would do a lot of good. You forgot to include Theoden's death and Eowyn killing the Witch-king (that may be because Balian or Guy were not with the Rohirrim but still that is an important part). And the final battle is very short. You should have made it at least a chapter long. But still it is great for someone who has written for the 1st time. I've read your other stories as well. They're really great and I have almost nothing to criticize in them. 'Its an odd coincidence' is your best story.

Man you have a torture Balian fetish or something lol seriously

I just want to say that this is an amazing piece of work. I really enjoy your writing. It's not cliche which is such a relief. I'm very glad I was searching through the KoH crossovers one day. Thank you for sharing your writing with us. I am usually quite critical with writing, especially with fanfics and yours are some of the only fanfics I consider truly well written. So many people on fanfiction write about the most cliche things, myself included (my writing isn't very good), and they still get a lot of people who say that the writing is good. I am less inclined to think like the rest of my generation but I wanted you to know that your writing is something I actually consider you again for sharing this with us. (Sorry for the long and badly written review)

I can't wait to read the next parts of the series!

Bravo! Bravo! This is truly a wonderful fanfic!

Oh my god. We get it. You're turned on by torturing your characters. Can you keep your fetishes to yourself?

Ah, so he's going to pretend to be a servant of Sauron to get into the dark city, and then do something to sabotage them?

Lolol Hunan lol at the reactions of balian meeting will meeting Paris meeting legolas. THEY ALL LOOK THE SAME

Awesome story. One of those rare gems to find in the fanfic universe. Love the trailer on youtube that got made for the next story. And now, off to read the next!

Possibly one of the most amazing things I have ever read :0