|Reviews for Commentarius
| Guest chapter 4 . 9/21/2023
The reasons THEY were chosen for is that Dumbledore SHIPS THEM!
| Guest chapter 32 . 8/9/2023
Hello, I devoured thus ABSOLUTELY AMAZING fic in two days! It was SOOOOO good, I only now noticed that it was latest updated in 2013 and I just- my heart broke...
I understand if you have a new life and maybe don't even remember much of the future plot, I write a lot 2 and I know how it is to have everything in mind. Just PLEASE, Yes I'm begging you, write at least a comeback or just tell us what happens...
I guess that James wanted Lily to (in his face) see his love or something, I might be wrong... But please just write SOMETHING, I'm positively craving. Normally I don't idolize people but you are a great writer! I have somehow come to look up to you.
It is fine if you let this end in a cliffhanger, but as in the cliff game, if you don't come and save me by just writing a 'oh this happened plot spoiler and explainer' Im going to slip! PLEASE!
your somewhat new fan,
| 0301sjilyromionehinny chapter 32 . 6/16/2023
I knowww it's been really long since you last updated this . It's been five years since I read this and I keep coming back to it. It's my comfort fanfic.I really hope you'll update soon...
| sara chapter 25 . 4/24/2023
| sara chapter 19 . 4/21/2023
Wait so are you telling me that harry is also related to the Rosiers?
| sparksfly321 chapter 1 . 4/3/2023
This is absolutely amazing. I ACTUALLY like Lily here which is a rarity for me since in most fics authors make her completely insufferable. Shame that it’s been last updated nearly ten years ago.
| Nice567 chapter 20 . 3/13/2023
I'd forgotten how beautiful this was. It's been two years since I last read this. I sincerely hope that you find motivation to continue this.
| Guest chapter 32 . 2/11/2023
Can someone tell me what James was talking about in the last chapter? What was he trying to remind lily?
PLEASE UPDATE THIS STORYYYY
| Guest chapter 32 . 1/18/2023
Where is the rest
| SonntagMorgen27 chapter 32 . 12/14/2022
This was soo good! I loved reading it!
Yes Lily gets on your nerves a bit with her ever repeating drama but it is still highly entertaining! James is such a good guy! I wish we could find Spur what he and elisabeth did at this fateful evening…
| LadyPrefect chapter 32 . 12/8/2022
Firstly, HOW CAN YOU JUST DROP THE BOMB AND LEAVE LIKE NOTHING HAD HAPPENED?
GOOD GOD WOMAN it's almos 2023 and I just reach chapter 32 and I just can't live my life without knowing what's going to happen next.
Saying that, I just going to DIE and my whole family will be SAD because you didn't finish the story.
PLEASE CONTINUE! HELP!
Best Regards (and wishing you a Merry Xmas),
| Mary91 chapter 32 . 11/21/2022
I just finished reading this and the story is really fun (except the ending of this chapter ;p ). It has been nearly ten years since you updated, but according to your tumblr you still plan on updating someday (yes I stalked, sue me :p ). I really you hope you find the inspiration to get back to this. I really want to find out what happened to Lily, what she was meant to see and how James and Lily figure it all out.
| Caitlin.95 chapter 1 . 9/8/2022
for context on my previous comment i first read this around the time of the last few updates, so 2010ish? and all these years it’s been unmatched
| Caitlin.95 chapter 1 . 9/8/2022
this is my comfort fic i’m not kidding i come back to it all the time. i can’t thank you enough
| Guest chapter 32 . 7/29/2022
Hey, i just found this fanfic just a few days ago, and let me tell you. I've been reading this NON STOP! This is just insanely good, i can't believe how BRILLIANT this fanfiction is. You're just so unbelievably talented, and now I'm on my knees, begging you to finish! Just, PLEASE! I know it's been like almost ten years now, but I'm just dying to know what happened! That cliffhanger is killing me! I just absolutely love this story, i haven't been this invested in a story for ages! And i just really hope you'll update soon! Just letting you know that it doesn't have to be perfect, just an update will make everyone happy.