Reviews for Commentarius
Dani chapter 32 . 1/5
I've read this fanfic so many times, I can't even count. My comfort fanfic.

I recently read it again and it took me a long time to finish the last chapter, because I knew I would be upset with the ending of the last chapter.

I'm curious to know what direction your life has taken. What you do for living, if you have children, if you still write...
I hope you're doing well, Bee.
Nox chapter 32 . 7/16/2024
Hi, I saw your post on tumblr saying you were still working on the chapter, but it had been a long time since you wrote it. Is it possible that you will come back with something new?
Swasti Jain chapter 32 . 3/9/2024
I know you completed this fanfic in 6 years but it is already been 7 years. It is so captivating... I read the entire thing in 2 days and now I come back each time just to check if there are any new chapters. Well, you're also a human and have your own personal space but please please please think about the new chapter and like please take your time we do not want a before lockdown ,after lockdown story and like the story line should not change ... But the wait is eating us...Please think about it. I really wanna know how did they get to know and what happened, it's frustrating to wait.
Pleaseeeee
Guest chapter 4 . 9/21/2023
The reasons THEY were chosen for is that Dumbledore SHIPS THEM!
Guest chapter 32 . 8/9/2023
Hello, I devoured thus ABSOLUTELY AMAZING fic in two days! It was SOOOOO good, I only now noticed that it was latest updated in 2013 and I just- my heart broke...

I understand if you have a new life and maybe don't even remember much of the future plot, I write a lot 2 and I know how it is to have everything in mind. Just PLEASE, Yes I'm begging you, write at least a comeback or just tell us what happens...

I guess that James wanted Lily to (in his face) see his love or something, I might be wrong... But please just write SOMETHING, I'm positively craving. Normally I don't idolize people but you are a great writer! I have somehow come to look up to you.

It is fine if you let this end in a cliffhanger, but as in the cliff game, if you don't come and save me by just writing a 'oh this happened plot spoiler and explainer' Im going to slip! PLEASE!
PLEASE

Most sincerely,
your somewhat new fan,
CantSayMyName
0301sjilyromionehinny chapter 32 . 6/16/2023
I knowww it's been really long since you last updated this . It's been five years since I read this and I keep coming back to it. It's my comfort fanfic.I really hope you'll update soon...
sara chapter 25 . 4/24/2023
yessssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss!
sara chapter 19 . 4/21/2023
Wait so are you telling me that harry is also related to the Rosiers?
sparksfly321 chapter 1 . 4/3/2023
This is absolutely amazing. I ACTUALLY like Lily here which is a rarity for me since in most fics authors make her completely insufferable. Shame that it’s been last updated nearly ten years ago.
Nice567 chapter 20 . 3/13/2023
I'd forgotten how beautiful this was. It's been two years since I last read this. I sincerely hope that you find motivation to continue this.
Guest chapter 32 . 2/11/2023
Can someone tell me what James was talking about in the last chapter? What was he trying to remind lily?
PLEASE UPDATE THIS STORYYYY
Guest chapter 32 . 1/18/2023
Where is the rest
SonntagMorgen27 chapter 32 . 12/14/2022
This was soo good! I loved reading it!
Yes Lily gets on your nerves a bit with her ever repeating drama but it is still highly entertaining! James is such a good guy! I wish we could find Spur what he and elisabeth did at this fateful evening…
Hm…
LadyPrefect chapter 32 . 12/8/2022
Good evening,

Firstly, HOW CAN YOU JUST DROP THE BOMB AND LEAVE LIKE NOTHING HAD HAPPENED?
GOOD GOD WOMAN it's almos 2023 and I just reach chapter 32 and I just can't live my life without knowing what's going to happen next.
Saying that, I just going to DIE and my whole family will be SAD because you didn't finish the story.

PLEASE CONTINUE! HELP!

Best Regards (and wishing you a Merry Xmas),
Me.
Mary91 chapter 32 . 11/21/2022
I just finished reading this and the story is really fun (except the ending of this chapter ;p ). It has been nearly ten years since you updated, but according to your tumblr you still plan on updating someday (yes I stalked, sue me :p ). I really you hope you find the inspiration to get back to this. I really want to find out what happened to Lily, what she was meant to see and how James and Lily figure it all out.
3,740 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »