Reviews for Should Have
Bloodgalore chapter 1 . 3/19/2010
Holy Cow! That seems so real!
Fulgance chapter 1 . 8/23/2009
Strong. Powerful. And kinda depressing.

It's very good. I didn't get the 'It's not my blood...Sirius, it's not my blood!' part until the second time I read it, but when I did...Just that made me feel the panic, the fear that he must've felt.

It's clear without being too detailed. We understand what happened without having the graphic scenes. I very much like the trophy James probably chucked away, which I feel inserts a tiny bit of humor in an otherwise pretty dark fic. Which is kind of suited to the dark hours I'm reading this...What the hell am I doing on fanfiction at midnight?

The answer is reading excellent fanfiction, I think. And this is the best one so far.
adavisa chapter 1 . 11/12/2008
I got tears in my eyes reading this one! Tragic!
scorsby chapter 1 . 10/7/2008
this is really really sad. really sad. i feel very depressed all of a sudden.

sory if this is a crap review. it really is a very good story it just makes he sad. very sad.

very well written and sparce. well done.
rockstar-101 chapter 1 . 1/16/2007
wow, that was intense even though it was really short. good story.
rekahneko chapter 1 . 1/15/2007
So sad and angsty - love it! Poor Remus but even more sad is Sirius...
VoiceofDionysus chapter 1 . 1/14/2007
Wow, powerful I say this is the only Slash hint fanfic that I've read on purpose and I loved it! Great work :) Keep writing that wonderful and thousands of cookies might come your way lol.


Caitlin Wogberg (Athena)