Reviews for Miranda
babythor chapter 20 . 11/24/2014
I really enjoy your back story for Shepherd Book. This is something like the fourth or fifth time I've read your Horseshoe Nail series through, and your version of Book's life prior to Serenity is, to my opinion, so much better than canon. Book being an idealist kid who joined the Marshals when the government was for the good of the people seems so much more in line with his character. Which I noticed you slipped in your reasoning within this chapter, Book's sense of justice and his need to do his part, amongst other qualities. "I don't give a half-hump if you're innocent, so where does that leave you?" always seemed to me to be something that you say and then regret until the end of your days, than being a callous non-sequitur from a platform of hate and self-righteousness as it was in the comics. It seemed to me a betrayal of Book's character that he was a spy sabotaging the Alliance on behalf of the rebels. I couldn't figure how the man he was current with Firefly and Serenity could have been born out of that twisted ideology-even if he had found God, that transformed man would still have a reconciled a version of his original moral structure with his faith. It would have resulted in an entirely different character from Book as we know him. Mostly, it seemed Whedon cared more about perpetuating "the Alliance is EVIL," and refusing to allow the Alliance to have a dynamic storyline borne of good intent-all at the expense of Shepherd Book's character.
Natrix chapter 22 . 11/15/2014
This is how it shod have happened. Why can't you be joss whedon? Such a great story, there was enough action and tension even having watched the movie. I don't think I've read a story where every character was saved and managed to pull it off without it tainting the writing. But you did it, and you did it all classy like too!
Elenna123 chapter 12 . 9/30/2014
Maybe you did this on purpose, but isn't it "filling the darkness with order and light"? Not chaos?
yummyjellybean chapter 22 . 9/5/2014
Wow I love this :)
soatwd chapter 22 . 5/14/2014
EagleJarl chapter 22 . 4/17/2014
This was epic. Thank you so much for writing it. Granted, you paint Jayne a bit smarter than I think he was in canon, but not a genius. Everyone else is right on target. And the sheer amount of schmoop you managed to pack in has me at serious risk of going D'awwwwwww for the rest of tr day.

Great job.
EagleJarl chapter 21 . 4/17/2014
Well. That was quite something.

Mal and Jayne are both very lucky that River was there or one of them would be seriously hurt. I'm glad the others were all being sensible though.
EagleJarl chapter 18 . 4/17/2014
Ok, you maimed Wash but didn't kill him. Ok, I can accept that. Maybe they can even break into Ariel again and get him a new leg, although that's probably too much to ask for.

Looks we get our Big Damn Heroic River scene after all. For a minute there I thought you were going to skip it.

Now they're going to have not one but two Operatives working sorta-kinda on their side. And possibly the other Operatives will see the 'wave and shake loose as well. Should be interesting.
EagleJarl chapter 17 . 4/17/2014
Yayyyyyyy! You saved Wash! You shiny guy! [/reverse SouthPark]

So, time for some hot Operative-on-Operative battle time. This should be good. One of them is, as far as I know, armed only with a syringe while the other has a sword. Should be interesting.
EagleJarl chapter 16 . 4/17/2014
Good point - there was a hole between what Simon told them on the how and what was shown in the BDM. Good explanation for it.

So...Mr Universe may or may not die. He likely won't be able to leave the recording in Lenore, but he can probably rig up a speech synthesizer or just an onscreen typed note. Be interesting to see where this goes.

And, of course, a few bazillion Reavers and Alliance and a ruttin' huge space battle ain't nothing compared to the storm of go we that's going to hit when the crew finds out that River and Jayne are together.
EagleJarl chapter 15 . 4/17/2014
Well that weren't morbid and creepifying at all.

Nicely handled and I'm glad we still get to have our giant Reaver vs Alliance just better not end up with Wash dead again! You've been fixing everything else in this story so you can damn well fix that too.

Speaking of fixing - wouldn't you think that the Alliance would try some small scale experiments with the Pax before turning it on an entire planet? Something like:

"We put it into a 10-person research vessel and they all lay down and died. Well, except for that one guy who went nuts and ate everyone else."
"Huh, interesting. Well, maybe we should cancel the Phase II trial on Miranda."
"Oh yeah, good point. I hope they don't cut our funding."
EagleJarl chapter 12 . 4/16/2014
Yep, that's about how the Operative should behave. I don't know why they're keeping him; they won't get anything from him.

River's dancing / singing scene was lovely. I'm glad to see that Jayne finally confessed his feelings. Should make life interesting when the others figure it out.
EagleJarl chapter 11 . 4/16/2014
I never was clear on how she managed to pull up a picture of a planet that was explicitly expunged from the records. I mean, it's not going to be on Wikipedia, right? And I doubt she just hacked some super secret Alliance database in two minutes from the Cortex connection on a tramp freighter. So where did she get it? Bit of a plot hole in the BDM.
EagleJarl chapter 10 . 4/16/2014
Well now, that was a much more satisfying conclusion to that scene. And I think it will do Mal good to hear that River considers him a father. Zoe is the only one that he really trusts; he likes Kaylee and he loves Inara even if he won't admit it, but he won't let either of them close. Maybe now that River had changed how he thinks of her, maybe he can let her in.

I'm curious to see what they do with the Operative. Can't random him. Torture isn't in Mal's playbook, and likely wouldn't work anyway. Perhaps use his credentials to break in somewhere and erase data on the Tams. Anyway, I'll see.
EagleJarl chapter 5 . 4/16/2014
Poor Jayne. What a crappy situation, not knowing whether what you fell is real or forced on you. Then again, that's kinda River's entire life.

If Jayne actually tries to punch out Book, Jayne may just be in for a rude surprise.
549 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »