|Reviews for Casting Moonshadows|
| Lara chapter 86 . 3/8
Hey, I’d just like to know if there is a way I can keep track of this? I don’t have an account if that’s what I need (p.s. I hecking love your work omg)
| SiriuslyPink chapter 15 . 3/7
If I were Remus I would refuse to be James’ friend. I’d rather be friendless than join that group. Sirius is alright but the other 2 are meh.
| Chelsea chapter 1 . 3/4
Moonsign, I am a big fan of this series and I hope you can write more, maybe about Sirius and Remus growing up in that house together or something. I have read your series twice now and eveyrtime I read a chapter I couldn't put it down and I had to keep reading until I finished the chapter. This storyline was so perfect and I love this ship along with Drarry.
I am a big fan of TheMischiefManagers and I have watched them do some of the episodes. I love watching them and I along with them are very grateful you mentioned them and that people go and watch them because I am obsessed with them. Especially because they do Remus X Sirus ship and Drarry.
- Chelsea (Your biggest fan!)
| HANNAH chapter 86 . 3/4
OMG I LOVE THIS FIC SOOOOO MUCH IVE READ IT LIKE 10 TIMES BUT ON WHATPAD PLEASE UPDATE !
| SapphireTheFourth chapter 1 . 3/3
God I love this story so much. I've come back to it to re-read chapters for The Mischief Manager's videos cause they acted out some of the chapters.
| DeadlyHuggles chapter 8 . 3/2
I'm feeling a lot better now that it's March.
I had exams this week though so that sucked.
So, I'm perfectly on time this month, which is great.
The moon is huge and I love it.
I think I'm going to head outside a bit.
Not until midnight though.
I've been working on writing more.
But it's been kind of hard.
I keep getting distracted.
For the longest period of time I was stuck in the past with WolfStar and then some more time with Drarry.
Then I spent a giant amount of time on YouTube before be forceful dragged up Mt. Ebbot and falling into the Undertale fandom.
(I swear that fandom is the weirdest thing in the world and I love it.)
Despite not originally wanting to fall in, I'm not sure if I want to leave.
Even if I did, I don't think the annoying dog would let me...
But I did manage to write some and pumped out two chapters for my story within one week.
I've got the next one half finished already.
I'm kind of proud of myself...
Are you happy with what you've accomplished?
Bye for now Moonsign, but I swear I'll be back.
| Guest chapter 86 . 3/1
Love all of this so far! I really appreciate how you've brought the mental health struggles of the characters through in a way that's moving and not stigmatizing of mental illness.
Also, my heart breaks every time a character references something that happens in the future (like Alice talking about not wanting to spend the rest of her life in a hospital). Because I'm a sappy human being with no tolerance for tragedy, part of me is still hoping that your fic takes place in an AU where everyone lives happily ever after.
| Camro chapter 86 . 3/1
I read your fanfic in just four days ! I couldn't close my computer, it is a good thing it is winter break or I am sure I would have had trouble focusing during classes !
I loved every thing about this story. I especially enjoyed the pace of it. You managed to keep it interesting and "plot densei don't know if it makes sense) while still covering an extensive period of time. I am so looking forward to next chapter ! For now your story is canon compliant and I really really want to know if it is going to say that way.
You are an amazing writer
Thanks for sharing
| Guest chapter 86 . 2/28
This is, without a doubt, one of the most phenomenal fics I've ever read, and I've read a lot over the years. The pacing, the characterization, and the original elements added to the Marauder's story is so well done. There were moments that I felt my chest grow tight and my heart stutter, and I was absolutely amazed by your talent as a writer. Thank you so much for creating this. It's beautiful.
| teddyvictoire'slovechild chapter 1 . 2/20
Amazing! I️ am speechless. Thank you!
| lennytheunicorn chapter 86 . 2/15
I just finished chapter 86 and first of all I am completely in love with your fanfiction. Started reading it Tuesday and I couldn’t put my phone away! It’s so wonderfully well written and you got the characters so well.. it’s honestly amazing and I’m in awe how much it felt like coming home (a feeling that HP gives me all the time!) Loving the way how you portrayed the relationship of Wolfstar, Remus’ lycanthropy and even more important and serious topics like child abuse and homophobia. I really really really adored this fanfic and lost count on how many times it made me so happy and giggly but also sad at the same time! Such an amazing work you did there and I can’t wait for the next chapter!️
| whofan1212 chapter 1 . 2/15
thank you so much for tjis. all the characters are written perfectly and you acctually left peter in and fully written too! i love the way the wolfstar relationship worked and all the animagus fullmoon scenes, especially the blood moon. i would absolutely love if one day this was given a proper end, though that wasnt the worst place to leave it. thank you so much
| Snowyday chapter 86 . 2/13
Hii i just wanted to say that i am so in love with this. I especially like, besides beautiful wolfstar, relationship between Sirius and Regulus. Their brotherhood is so touching and when i thought about what happend to Regulus... I would love so much to read about this in your story. Thank you so much for this
| TheLoud chapter 86 . 2/13
Wow. Thank you for writing this beautiful story. The Marauder pranks and teasing dialogue were perfect. The backstory you gave Remus was disturbing, and different from the backstory Rowling eventually gave him on Pottermore, but I guess it works. Poor Remus. It’s a wonder he likes books so much, considering writers just keep making his life miserable.
Sirius’s backstory makes perfect sense. Of course his family was abusive, and of course his alcoholism has roots in his past. Your writing here seems perceptive rather than creative, as if you’re just observing and describing a real person instead of making stuff up. Of course, that’s a sign of some very impressive creative skill.
I also like your description of Peter. He’s believable as a Marauder, and also as an eventual traitor.
Lily’s study of ancient protective magic involving sacrifice is an absolutely brilliant explanation of Harry’s survival.
This is the first fanfic I’ve read that has sex scenes that are actually sexy, instead of pornographic and embarrassing. That scene where Sirius helps Remus accept his body, scars and all, is beautiful.
I’d like to read any original fiction you’ve published, so let me know where I can find it. Thanks!
| unzufrieden chapter 86 . 2/12
I was fully convinced this fanfiction was finished until about 1 1/2 chapters ago... and since you postet the last chapter an awful time ago Im not even convinced I will ever have the opportunity to finish reading this fanfiction... and I don't like that.
To be honest I didn't really like the first /-10 chapters, the eleven year olds don't really act like eleven year olds, but the moment they grow older the whole story just gets awsome, like really awsome. You changed very much about remus' family and some other stuff, I don't get for example why Lily and Snape don't sit together in the train the moment they go to hogwarts for their first times, but it's still a fanfiction so some changes are okay and at some point you really managed to write like Rowling when you wrote about pranks and their conversations in the common room... I think I'm going to read those parts for about 1000 times in future when I'm not feeling well. Also I really love what your marauders are like, especially sirius. Remus too, even if I always had a very different version of his teenager self in my head your remus started to replace mine with the time. I don't really like the way James (and Sirius too kind of) bullied Remus in the beginning and snape all the time, it just doesn't fit in the picture I build in my mind when I read Harry Potter (though I was 8 so some of those pictures really are quite illusional, but as often I read Harry Potter since then they stayed), but it's what you always thought them to be like and I think Rowling really would like your version.
Another wonderful part about the story is of course the whole remus-sirius realtionship, you really are a genius in writing this stuff, and the whole moonshadow stuff (I love Cat Stevens;)).
Maybe it's good that I didn't get a happy end, because so I don't have to feel the pain of knowing what will happen in about a year and how every happinnes will leave all of them... although I don't know when you will end this story so maybe there wasn't even a chance for me to get a happy end...
I don't see myself as a crazy Harry Potter fangirl since I know lots of them via instagram etc and can't compare myself to them, but I always loved HP and the whole world just has this magical pull on, letting me dream about being one of its characters and I really really needed a great marauder fanfiction like this to get away from all the stress I have at the time, so thank you thank you thank you for posting so much of the story... I don't really think I should expect getting some more chapters in the near future since you really haven't postet in an awful long time and I am no one to judje you on that or something, but I will still watch out for some uploads next months, hoping you get yourself to writing more;)
So all in all I really love your story (especially parts like the end of this chapter when Rebecca suddenly gets an own personalty and you realise that ALL OF THEM have one, I am just to ignorant to think about them) and I really really wish you to continue writing (My birthday is next week, I know yo don't know me but you really could make some dissatisfied austrian girl a great birthday present;)))).
ein unzufriedenes Mädchen:)