Reviews for Casting Moonshadows
ArteMisCalima chapter 21 . 12/31/2020
Oh my. I don't know how much you know about child abuse, if you gone through some yourself (and then I would be really sorry) or just knew a lot about it, but you really did it well. It is horrifying how much truth is in this part of the story. That the kids really see themselves as the one to blame. It was really well written so I got goosebumps.

I learn to be a social worker and hope to help people (if not abuse children because I simply wouldn't make it myself). This is why we as people has to have always eyes open and know what to do when we suspect anything might be off in the family. (And it goes for elderly people as well as the amount of it is also enormous, more than we would think so.)

So thank you for this chapter as it is so well and thuthfully written. Thank you.
Guest chapter 61 . 12/26/2020
This chapter was absolutel !
person chapter 15 . 12/26/2020
And...I'm crying. Yet again. WHY DOES THIS FANFIC MAKE ME CRY SO MUCH JAMES STOP BEING AN A**HOLE SIRIUS TALK TO HIM I NEED ALL THE MARAUDERS FOR MY SAKE AND REMUS'S.
ICanAtLeastTry chapter 1 . 12/26/2020
Hi!

I just wanted to let you know that this book has been incredibly influential to me. I've reread it completely more times than I can count from when i first read it in middle school up until now. It helped me through a lot of hard times and has been an absolutely wonderful impact on my life as a whole. Not to be melodramatic, but this is without a doubt the best fanfic and probably book I've ever read.
This backstory is basically canon for them in my head and honestly with what's happened with JK, I mostly associate the world of HP with your works. The absolute dedication it must have taken to write this from 2007 to present is extraordinary, and the depth and beauty of your writing never faltered.
I apologize for being soppy, but I don't really comment on things a lot haha. Anyways, I wish you luck in your life, and I thank you for gifting the internet with such a beautiful story.
Guest chapter 32 . 12/24/2020
I have a bad feeling about this “Halloween Prank”...
no-longer-active-boi chapter 1 . 12/19/2020
Literally everyone: You should read Casting Moonshadows! It's really good!

*reads chapter 1*

Me: HOW IS THIS GOOD I'M ALREADY CRYING INSIDE

(but seriously, this is so beautiful)
ChristineBH chapter 87 . 12/19/2020
Somehow this fanfiction updates when I start reading from the first chapter again. Not that I'm complaining since it's actually pretty cool.
The time between knowing that there was a new chapter and getting to it was worth it, because omg I didn't think that I would ever care this much about Rebecca but I does.

Also, Peter's letter was written simplistically (as everyone in your story writes differently which is amazing) but so powerful. I felt my heart break for him when he wrote: "Everyone is all happy its summer here and i have to keep smiling and smiling, but inside its all black and I think I might never smile inside again. " I know that he will fall to the dark side but you've made him so human that I want to protect him from everything that made him turn out this way, and even if there was nothing to be done I feel so badly for how he's feeling now

Apropos that, your foreshadowing is once again heartbreaking. Alice wondering what's left of a person without their mind is the cherry on top of this dark and twisted cake
piep10 chapter 87 . 12/19/2020
Dear Moonsign, i don't know if you're still reading all the comments and reviews, seing the sheer numbers of reviews i can imagine its impossible for you to keep a track on al that. What an amazing story you've written. I do hope there will be more chapters to follow. I just stumbled upon this fanfiction two weeks ago and have read it two times now. Your story has made me tearfull, cry on occasions and laugh out loud a lot. The way you've portaited the four marauders is amazing, they have so many layers, feel realistic and their chats are priceless. I like the way you wrote about Peter, making him human and not some villain. And for the more slashy scenes...wow, they're actually sexy, sweet and hot. But the story is so much more, every chapter is new, surprising, sad, happy and funny.
I always loved the HP books (not so much the epilogue in book 7, let alone the horrific scene at the end of the 8th film, wonderfull that you've also wrote an afterHP story) but never read fanfiction before. After your story i tried a couple of other fanfictions on this site but i am just wasted...i didn't find anything that's up to the challenge.

A couple of chapters ago you mentioned your original novel up for sale at Amazon. Could you give me the title of your work, i'm really interested in reading it.

kind regards,

piep
does it matter chapter 87 . 12/16/2020
i cant believe it! I love it! Just Im Hoping you'll write more just it doesn't seem so
does it matter chapter 87 . 12/10/2020
ARE YOU GOING TO WRITE MORE? I JUST LOVE IT! AND HOPE U DONT STOP
Lexyreader1 chapter 87 . 12/9/2020
Love this book so much, do you know when you’ll next update ?
Lexyreader1 chapter 1 . 12/9/2020
Love love love this story, do you know when you will nest update? 33
AnyankaEllie chapter 87 . 12/7/2020
I'm still rereading your wonderful stories ) Thanks for the new chapter! You practically feel like all the atmosphere here in the story gets darker with each day.
derpydonuts719 chapter 87 . 12/7/2020
I have read the entire book over the course of 2 days. It is AMAZING and I am not even upset I got grounded for 2 weeks for staying up reading it. I love it so much, one of the best Harry Potter Fan Fiction I have ever read. Thank you so much for bringing a great sense to the time before Harry Potter. 3
Emma chapter 87 . 12/7/2020
it was a great story i wish for more but it is amazing thank you for it
9,300 | « Prev Page 1 .. 6 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 26 .. Last Next »