|Reviews for Roses, Guns, and Boys|
| sweetypie15 chapter 8 . 1/26
Loving the story it so good can't wait to read more update super soon
| Fire Fly Freiya chapter 8 . 11/3/2013
*sniffle* I can't wait for you to update again. I love the story. Looking forward to it, when you do!
| Regin chapter 8 . 5/15/2013
I Like, I Lust, I Love! Please Update Soon!
| Many Voices In My Head chapter 8 . 12/10/2012
Alright, so I just realized I haven't reviewed for the last few chapter. Don't take it personally, I only review when something is wrong or REALLY good. This time it's really good. I enjoy this story so much and how well it's written that I have forced my friends to read it. I can't really give you a much better compliment than that.
| Strata-Assassin chapter 8 . 12/1/2012
Woah, new review-thingy. I guess I didn't believe it when you left me a review or something. It is rather annoying, isn't it? Because I, like you, have a tendency to review straight as the story goes, just blurting out whatever I feel like and then trying to make up for it towards the end of the review as if something like that would make it all better. Anyway, "Boo!" for new review-thingy.
So, I see so many people squee'd about your story/content so I'm merely going to squee about the "Bonus." And maybe add in some insanity points of my own! :D
Haha! Every time I read about Tamaki and Kyoya I always hear the endearments, "Daddy" and "Mommy" after they address each other. And then to have the voice actors Vic and Tatum in my head only makes it so much funnier! Anyway, moving on past the first line...
Why is Kyoya mean? Well, without going into his stressful family history, let's just say he enjoys it. I mean, think about it. Now, I'm not normally the kind of person to do this to someone else, but (on a bad day of course) I might find someone with the same temperment as Tamaki and rattle him up a bit just to get a rise out of him. Have you seen him when he's upset? Of course you all have and it's rather amusing! Growing mushrooms? Having cosmic bursting moments. And even going so far as to think of Haruhi as his own daughter? Come now, why shouldn't Kyoya have a little fun? Does the dark-haired devil respect Tamaki? Of course! He just likes to poke the buttons every now and again. So, Tamaki my dear, please accept the fact that your best friend can be a bit cruel, but he gave you a compliment! Take it!
Now the revealing begins. Should I be a critic? Well, going back to my whole rant/statement about Tamaki I could say it's justified on my end, but I'll try to be nice to these thin-skinned Hosts. (And their very thick Gundam comrades. *sigh* Good one Heero. Ever the soldier.)
"M'lord! You have a chocobo on your head!" Ah, Cloud. At least you didn't put him in the wheelchair and have him bob his head up and down a few times. Although, Duo's idea would have been great! If that had been the case, Duo's long hair would have made the most beautiful of pigtails. Perhaps he shouldn't share his ideas so openly.
"Trowa, this is my story," mutters Haruhi, too bad she didn't know how true that statement really was.
And this is where us female Final Fantasy lovers would gleefully "Aw" and yell, "Vivi!" Yes, one of the cutest members of the Final Fantasy world and despite his pathetic/childish appearance throughout most of the game, we learn he is definitely growing to be my favorite mage.
When we usually see Quatre (at least before his utter insanity with the Zero system) he shines with a bright light, but since he's a bit devious in your story (we just know him better now) it's nice to see his glow dim a bit even if his Final Fantasy character has a "bright" name.
As for the Twins, I don't think they actually need a princess around to feel the urge to kidnap someone. They just seem that devilish to me.
Hm, I know we've been seeing Irvine in a different light over the past couple of years, but somehow I never saw the tie between him and Duo until you brought it up. I mean, it's almost uncanny! Aside from the panic attack about shooting Edea, Irvine's the same obnoxioussort of guy Duo is. And I mean that in the kindest possible way. *smiles before the God of Death can decide to unleash some sort of revenge for the miscommunicated comment*
Wufei, is it really type-casting? Meh, maybe a little. Although, Heero and Wufei should really lodge a complaint given who Heero is forced to be. Then again, since they're supposed to be playing some kind of role it's only appropriate that the worst actors are given the parts nearest to their real personalities, right? *another innocent grin to keep herself from getting beheaded by a beam saber*
Haha! And now the Mommy Tamaki and Daddy Kyoya makes so much more sense! After all, Cloud was pretty much Sephiroth's bitch throughout FF7. Haha! You should have made Tamaki's dog Antoinette a chocobo! Then again, Angelo would have made so much more sense. But we have a Moogle at least!
| Guest chapter 8 . 11/20/2012
I like your Wufei. He's fun to read.
| Parrot Post chapter 8 . 11/19/2012
I like it :) I think this would be a really difficult crossover to write but have written it very well. Could Wufei say that Oz killed his wife? I mean that doesn't really give away he is a Gundam pilot. I would think he could tell the truth about what happened if he is going as himself?
| Guest chapter 6 . 11/13/2012
He said doo doo XD
| The Dancing Bard chapter 8 . 11/12/2012
Yay! I'm so happy that you're continuing this. I love cross-overs and even though I don't always agree with your characterization choices, it's still one of the best Gundam Wing x-overs out there (and I've looked) because it's so entertaining. I'm so glad that not all the boys will be in the Host Club. It makes your story so much more believable. My favourite part so far was Wufei's analysis of Trowa successfully undercover vs. his own less than suave attempts. It makes him so much more likeable as a character that he can recognize his own flaws, and that he worries about blowing not only his own cover but also Trowa's. The group as a whole is much more believable when they all have strengths and weaknesses to plan around. I hate it when an author makes one character super-powered so that they end up looking like a mary-sue. It must be hard balancing two casts of characters in a cross-over like this, but so far you've done a great job of dividing screen time evenly. I eagerly look forward to your next instalment. Good luck with your studies!
| Guest chapter 3 . 11/11/2012
I see what you mean. Duo puts up a cheerful front but he can turn downright nasty at times, with the scariest grin of maybe any of them. But he also obviously cares, maybe more than he would like to admit, but it shows.
| TrenchcoatMan chapter 8 . 11/10/2012
Yay, I do love Dark Quatre... well I like a good mix of Nice Quatre and Zero Quatre.
I did like the Wu Fei part at the end, but im sad, I was sooo expecting the Quatre Kyoya Face-off... oh well, next time for sure
| Fox Loves Shinigami chapter 8 . 11/7/2012
LOL OMG the character's that I recognized from FF were great for the ones dressed as them. I especially likes Wufei as Tsung and Heero as Squall. Update soon _ Ja.
| Ookami Sakura chapter 8 . 11/7/2012
tehe I'm so glad you've continued this! I can't wait to find out how Quatre's going to get back at Wufei for not listening with so many civilians around.. Update soon!
| RememberMe-soon chapter 8 . 11/7/2012
A darker Quatre is awesome. Before becoming a pilot he was nothing short of a cynic, which caused him to be a bit bratty. He changes attitude and viewpoints radically and immediately based on his experiences in life. Without the 10% crazy the character washes out to a whiny, rich kid playing at war.
I liked that Wufei disrupted the pattern but in some ways it makes more sense. The fact that so many colony student are entering one day after another with little introduction to the school prior would be a red flag.
I find it interesting that each pilot finds separate threats within the host club. What is terrifying that each member is a force on their own but what they can actually accomplish together could be scary for a political world.
I get the feeling Hunny may be the only one to recognize and connect the pilots to their skill set. His character always seems to know what happens throughout his peers. Also Hunny's family traditions should have taught him to immediately recognize threatening stances, potential hidden weapons, and such.
Glad to see you continuing this story!
| SmileRen chapter 8 . 11/6/2012
I liked it. Can't wait for the next. Will Tamaki appear?