Reviews for Harry Potter and A Grandfather's Gift |
---|
HoneyBear84 chapter 29 . 10h Love it |
BlazeStryker chapter 3 . 9/18 Reading this, I imagine Kreacher being stone-cold dead. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Severus: (To the goblin that delivered reacher's carcass) And what, exactly, am I to do with a dead house-elf? Goblin: (sneering with a shrug for accent) You're the Potions master, I simply deliver things and handle money. Do as you like with the carcass as per the will; Gringotts will gladly invest any profit you make off of it. |
Leslie chapter 29 . 9/12 Wonderful story. I’m pretty sure I read it before, but I lost all my bookmarks. I’m not sure if I finished it. I don’t remember the confrontation. I remember some of the stuff on the island. So, I got to reread it and enjoy it all over again. :) |
peggy77 chapter 28 . 9/4 Yeah no, I couldn't forgive him. At least not that quickly anyway. |
peggy77 chapter 2 . 9/4 Wow! What a trunk! First thing I would do would be to go back to the day Sirius died but before leaving Hogwarts then simply not leave. The next thing would be to have Sirius and Remus move into it. I read this a long time ago and put it in my favorites and am re-reading it now but I really can't remember what happens. I love it when I can't remember because it makes it more interesting. |
Siriusmunchkin chapter 29 . 8/30 They were very definitely wrong. A good story with more than a few surprises. The tardis/trunk being my favorite |
Siriusmunchkin chapter 11 . 8/28 One reviewer said something like the story was worthless because Dumbledore was forgiven so easily or something like that. Very positive they are wrong. |
Siriusmunchkin chapter 4 . 8/27 Could be a lot of fun happening here |
Siriusmunchkin chapter 2 . 8/27 Very intriguing |
Guest chapter 28 . 7/31 "I did not check on you in all those years because I did not want to know if they were mistreating you. If I knew, then I would have to do something about it." Yes. That's called being a responsible adult. Sorry Dumbledore. That sounds like a cop-out. 'It was easier on me if I didn't know the extent of your mistreatment.' I understand why he made the choices he did for his daughter, but he could have made sure Harry was in a good family that treated him right. Dumbledore decided to place Harry with the Dursleys, so he was responsible for making sure they treated him well. I think the only reason Harry was willing to let him back in his life was because he has had such little family. If it were me, I'd forgive Dumbledore, but never forget. I'd make sure Dumbledore never had any authority over any child of mine. Overall though, I have read this story multiple times and I really enjoy it. |
Guest 83 chapter 29 . 5/3 I really enjoyed reading this. Thank you for a well written story. |
Razeus1 chapter 10 . 1/25 How sad that Harry is once again allowing the enabler of child abuse into his secrets and confidences, why would Charlus or Sirius allow this? Remus is still under Dumby's thrall? This had so much new and fun plots, but you lost me when Dumby was let back into their circle after all the damage he has done. Sorry, but I can't suspend disbelief that much to read more and this had such promise! |
Basil-Duuuval chapter 29 . 1/23 ️️️️️️ |
Guest chapter 4 . 8/26/2023 I love that you came up with a way to save Sirius. |
20000 WPM chapter 29 . 8/27/2023 I really enjoyed your story. I loved the trunk and all it could do. Also loved Harry's Grandad Charlie. |