|Reviews for Science and Magic|
| rnthenu chapter 22 . 8/12
damn, plot thickens..
| rnthenu chapter 21 . 8/11
Things are getting exciting...
| rnthenu chapter 19 . 8/8
Things are getting interesting fast.
| rnthenu chapter 16 . 8/5
Really nice end. Thanks for writing.
| Guest chapter 1 . 8/2
Oooh Science...like...magic...like...this seems to be my kinda story. Why has she turned up there though? What brought her when muggles can't see wizard things? Maybe "you're a wizard Harry" will be what happens here? Gotta keep reading anyhoo...
| rnthenu chapter 15 . 8/3
Thank you for writing this story. I have been enjoying the story for a while now, didn't get a chance to review. On a whole pretty interesting, although I found some parts to be slightly boring. I found the story to have good scientific musings and good character developments. I was sad to see so few F&Fs. I wanted to know that I enjoy your story and intends to finish reading all the three parts, please continue writing. Thanks again.
| mckertis chapter 7 . 7/30
Right. It's been 7 chapters and you completely failed to hook me, as i have no clue what this story is remotely about.
| KnowInsight chapter 18 . 7/2
I love the cliffie. "I solemnly swear that I am up to no good." :D
| Guest chapter 26 . 6/12
Wow, I'm glad I found this ~ thank you for writing such a well thought out story! I love science and Harry Potter, so this was just my cup of tea. I was absolutely invested in Cecilia navigating the wizarding world, you had me reading with a smile one chapter and then reading with tears down my face the next. I like how much you emphasize the prejudice against muggles, I feel like it's more realistic to how the wizarding world views them as innately inferior. Also, I commend you on how long this story was ~ I looked it up and the story would make for a novel around 900-1100 pages (depending on words per page), that's awesome! It felt a bit long winded at times, but I feel it helped engage the reader into the story better and I really liked that :) Will definitely read the sequels!
| FaithfulWarrior chapter 26 . 6/7
This was a good story...however I think you really drew it out, and went into too much detail sometimes. Also, it would be a good idea to put a pairing on Lupin and OC so people know what they're in for.
It was well done, well thought out, but definitely a little long.
Thank you so much for writing though and don't take offense to anything I said, it is certainly not my intention. Just my opinion. ;-)
| Montara chapter 27 . 5/29
| IAMiniquity chapter 26 . 5/15
I actually read this story a while back and just went searching for it again last night and had to re read the whole thing. I actually hadn't realized before hand that you had sequels written, so I'll have to get to them in the next few days, I'm very excited for them
I wanted to say that I loved this story. I'm not a very science oriented person and tend to enjoy the more fictional side of things. Magic, monsters, and myth more than logic, reason, and research, but I adore how you had Cecelia work the correlation between muggle science and wizard magic. I imagine this story took quite a bit of work, and I admire it very much.
Honestly, I was rooting for Severus the whole time, especially because he really wasn't so bad with Cecelia and I really love him (bias) but I liked Remus too. Even though he was a dummy and he left her for so long I am glad that they got back together in the end.
Of course, both Sirius and Harry killed me, but Harry was an impressionable youth. I think that you played on Pureblood/Wizard muggle prejudice very well.
It might take me a bit, but I'm going to read your sequels as well. Thanks for such an amazing story. :)
| Montara chapter 26 . 5/6
Severus found out about Draco's sample :)
Too bad Voldemort is not dead : So much suffering, so many deaths. But they still have hope, especially now Cecilia accepted to come back and help.
Thank you so much for sharing you story! What a journey! And there's more! :)
| Montara chapter 25 . 5/6
She's okay! So glad! And Remus came back to her! :)
Still, I'm so sad for Libby and her family :( Hope Freya will come live with Cecilia now.
| Montara chapter 24 . 5/6