|Reviews for Prodigy|
| Guest chapter 1 . 2/12
| Ddragon21 chapter 8 . 1/14
well ginny weasley does not make sense for a pairing for this harry. even if you like it does not make it right just saying not bashing. I mean according to you made this harry extremely intelligent almost einstein level genius. How could he possibly relate to a regular girl like ginny in any way? unless you made her a genius it just seems weird. like how people usually gravitate to someone with at least one common interest. It's just my oppinion but the story is brilliant too bad its abandoned.
| Gemna Destiny Seer chapter 10 . 4/13/2013
Um... FYI, some people get really offended when you insult their ship choices. I may not be one of them but I know some people who are. Another thing that you should know is that originally in the books written by J. K. Rowling, Harry was going to end up with Hermione and Ron was going to die. Just so you know.
| WTF chapter 11 . 11/6/2012
In all honesty, I liked the way the original story was written. It had the makings of slow buildup of a relationship between Harry and Hermione, and a lot of people preferred it that way, not that I'm a fan of that pairing. And considering the fact that you just pretty much murdered one of my Favorite fics with the blunt inclusion of the biggest mary sue of this entire series and then made her an even bigger marry sue, pretty much turned me of from reading your "Version" past the first mention of Ginny.
And your little rant at the end of this chapter, well...
Considering your pretty much writing a fan fiction of a fan fiction (without ever crediting jmcgk6 by the way), it just pretty much turned me off of reading whatever fics you might have written, or will write in the future.
| Sena chapter 1 . 9/1/2012
Just read the AN at the end of chapter 10 (after stopping reading the fic itself at chap 9 because of the AN there).
You really *are* a crackpot. I've seen several stories where Harry and Hermione are like siblings and it's credible, I've never seen one that is canon upto 5th year and yet makes Harry-Ginny believable.
You, sir, are a true, blue, died-in-the-wool, moron.
| Sena Wario chapter 1 . 9/1/2012
I read upto chapter 9, then stopped out of disgust.
Not at your story; it was quite nice and I would have continued. Well it was a bit of a Gary Stu but still...
Not because the pairing is Canon (and I am a diehard Harmonian). I've seen a few believably rendered Harry-Ginny stories, although curiously nothing that is canon upto and including 5th year can do that - they diverge from canon by 4th year to make it credible. (So much for "canon pair")
But if you feel so strongly about Ginny (aka "potion mistress") that you have to make ANs like "long live the canon couples", in capital letters no less, clearly you are touched in the head.
| dragonlordrb chapter 12 . 8/9/2012
In my opinion this is the better for not removing it.
| Venus914 chapter 12 . 6/29/2012
I dont support the Harry/Hermione ship either. Im mostly for slash pairing but if it's het, then i would prefer Luna.
| Venus914 chapter 10 . 6/29/2012
Huhuhu. Why are you pro-Weasley? I mean, you could have gone canon. At least, they would have been portrayed as their real self. But no, you portrayed the Weasley family as more than what they are. Seriously? I mean, patient Ron without the jealousy? Lovely Ginny with a talent? Molly without the Banshee attitude? I think, you are are painting them to be a perfect family. And i was getting used to superpowered Harry who is into Weasley-bashing.
| V. L. Crawford chapter 9 . 6/14/2012
Great chapter. I was glad to see you aren't going to have Harry's love start this early. I was worried about that with how much you keep mentioning Ginny in your ANs. I hate when he has to grow up so fast. That was a problem for me with JKR and you have him doing it even younger. I can't imagine a 7 yr old living on his own no matter how smart he is. It makes me want to cry to think of such a thing. Achild who never gets to be a child. Sorry I'm not trying to say anything bad about your story. I'm just hurting for Harry in your last four years could have been filled with love and a true family instead of a little boy and an owl alone.
| V. L. Crawford chapter 8 . 6/14/2012
I love your story but your Ans are driving e crazy, because they keep mentioning Ginny. Argh!
| V. L. Crawford chapter 7 . 6/14/2012
Great chapter. I wish it wasn't going to be Harry/Ginny. I can't wait till Harry and Sirius meet.
| V. L. Crawford chapter 6 . 6/14/2012
Great chapter, but I didn't want it to be Harry/Ginny.
| V. L. Crawford chapter 5 . 6/14/2012
I hate that Sirius and Harry didn't get those four years together. That was mean on your part. You have given me such hope and then took it away. I could cry.
| V. L. Crawford chapter 4 . 6/14/2012
Awe come on. I want Sirius and Harry together.