|Reviews for Signal to Noise|
| Borednbrowsing chapter 1 . 10/22/2008
Whoa. This is deep, and really well-written. :o
| atrum infractus chapter 4 . 8/9/2008
It takes quite a bit to get me to say "wow". But this honestly makes me say "wow".
I can tell that you're writing from at least some personal experience, because I have NEVER read a story with such amazing detail to the steady atrophy of the mind after such trauma. And as sad as it is that you've gone through some awful things, what a phenomenal way to use experience in writing!
I'll be honest. I am much more of an Supernatural reader/writer. I wrote for HP a long time ago, and I was rather discouraged by how limited some of the fanfic authors thought the realm of Harry Potter is. They limited it mostly to the world of magic. But you include both- you balance them perfectly. You even contrast between the worlds- when Hermione said something about how St Mungos smells compared to the muggle hospital! It's just rather thrilling to see an author who can balance two worlds within their writing.
That is my very rambly way to say- "I love this story, and I sincerely hope you update very soon." ] Keep up the amazing work!
| anon chapter 13 . 7/24/2008
This story is amazingly well written. I really like the way you have experimented with different character POV. A suggestion: maybe a doctor's POV, especially if Harry's wizarding backround was revealed (accidental magic?). The chapters in JKR's books where muggle POV are shown seem to work really well (eg. prime minister chapter at the start of book 6). Maybe it could work here too?
Anyway, whatever you do, I hope uou update soon.
| Avada Cait-davra chapter 13 . 7/11/2008
why have you not finished!
or it will kill me.
i love this story so much. the detail is great.
please please please continue.
| Avada Cait-davra chapter 4 . 7/10/2008
this is so so so so good.
i wanna finish right now.
but im falling asleep. ):
im finishing tomarow.
i love this so much. all the details.
its so amazing.
| Guest chapter 1 . 6/20/2008
I just reread this story, and I'm excited to see in your profile that you're working on a new part. I hope we see Harry's perspective again soon! Thanks for writing. xx
| snapes wife to be chapter 13 . 6/13/2008
i have truly loved reading this so far, you write about the issues with realism and sensitivity. I hope you are able to continue soon, though i know, as you do, that sometimes real life just sucks x
| xHarryIsMyHomeboyx chapter 13 . 6/1/2008
Oh my God. I love this. I love this so much. Oh my God. Everyone is so in character, and it's amazing, and...wow.
I have suffered a lot with anorexia, and some bulimia, but not so much, and am now "recovered." Of course, I do still find myself expressing my old anorexic tendencies now and then, but at least I'm at a healthy weight. See the way you depict the disease has been incredible.
I love this. PLEASE update soon, because I don't think I'll be able to stand it if you don't. Thank you for writing this.
| nothingblankempty chapter 13 . 5/28/2008
Great story, hope you update soon.
| Spiorad chapter 13 . 5/15/2008
This is truly one of the best fics I have ever read and I cant wait to see what happens next. Please update soon.
| Laoise chapter 13 . 5/12/2008
I see that you haven't updated in some time, but I implore you, please don't give up on this. You are doing some real good with this story, it would be such a shame for it to be forgotten.
| little phoenix chapter 13 . 5/10/2008
This is one of the most poignant, heart-wrenching fics I've found here. I always thought that JK's Harry seemed too unscarred emotionally. I mean, he was emotionslly, physically, and psychologically abused, yet he never seemed to have any emotional issues, other than a longing for a family and being unused to affection. But I think that's illogical and unrealistic. Harry would have to have major psychological issues from the Dursleys' treatment Your Harry is exactly how I believe Harry would behave as a child of abuse and neglect.
| anon chapter 1 . 5/5/2008
I keep checking this, but no update :(
Was my favourite story too...
| Daniel chapter 13 . 4/30/2008
I really enjoyed reading this. I want to find out what happens next! I like you including a chapter from Snape's POV, though something about it seemed- rough, to me. I guess I expected Snape to know more about medicine and muggles...
Anyways, I- can relate to a lot of the story. I have problems (a lot better these days but not- gone) with self-injury, and an eating disorder and a background of trauma... And I have to say this story convenes- those realities really, really well.
| ks chapter 13 . 4/17/2008
Please update! I love this story and I've had it saved in my favorites for ages.