|Reviews for Rewritten Tragedy|
| sami1010220 chapter 1 . 11/17/2012
Oh god, why would you write that?! I'm about to cry all over my phone. Fantastic job, you did great with both characterization and details, and the writing itself was beautiful
| Alactricity chapter 1 . 4/23/2012
So I was reading this in bed on my phone and the whole time I was just sobbing, literally sobbing and now my nose is stuffy and my face is all red but OH MY GOD THAT WAS JUST. I don't even know how to articulate myself, that was heartbreaking. Probably the best piece of fanfiction I have ever read, ever.
I was seriously sobbing. How in the world... your writing made me cry. I didn't even cry during the show. I hardly cry during books. I mean I love your other stories too, I've read like all of them... but this was just intense.
I love you right now. It was so perfect. I can't praise you enough, really.
| Callette chapter 1 . 3/6/2012
That was simply brilliant... and it really says a lot about the show that this is actually happier than their version.
Dean's grief was so potent and raw; it was incredibly well done.
Thanks for such a poignant story.
| Arilaen chapter 1 . 7/26/2010
FINALLY! A story where Dean actually DEALS with Sam's death WITHOUT a deal or the whole "we die together" gig! Even though it's hard, it was incredibly realistic in this story. Great job D
| Medusa -the writer chapter 1 . 6/15/2010
I don't know how I missed this story until now. And reading it after the season 5 finale seems so ironic and fitting. Faye, you made me cry! This was beautifully written.
| Oroburos69 chapter 1 . 9/21/2009
Oh my god, it's so sad. I'm crying. I like it, but can't you break out some happy? Please?
| asdfjkl chapter 1 . 8/20/2009
wow. that's one of the best 'one-of-the-brothers-died-and-the-other-has-to-move-on-with-their-lives' fics that i've ever read.
i love the characters: i think you captured them all really well.
i like teh way dean moved on with his life. it seems...realistic.
| Holly Lukeman chapter 1 . 1/18/2009
Wow. I cannot begin to tell you just how painful that story was. I think as difficult as it is to think about one of the brothers surviving the other in a cloud of revenge-driven kamikaze missions, it inexplicably causes me more pain to think of one of them actually living while the other is dead. Perhaps because it's so much harder to do. After all, I'm sure someone has once said that dying is easy, life is hard.
I'm not sure how soon I'll be recovering from this story, especially the part when Dean left his father. I'd like to think that if Dean actually did let Sam stay dead, then maybe Dean would have been able to live again after a while. Unfortunately, that doesn't seem possible. Once again, great story. Well done.
| Zil chapter 1 . 7/27/2008
wow, what a lush and inviting tale you have created! I thought the pacing was marvelous, it held my attention well. A particular favourite: -He couldn't tell his dad that, wouldn't tell him that. His father wouldn't understand, and Dean wouldn't risk it. So he'd play bait, let his father do the dirty work, and wish the entire time he'd thought of necromancy before they'd burned Sam.-
I recently read a introspective one-shot called Sundown that explored who the Winchester men would save if they were forced to choose, and it had me convinced that John would save Sam, but you've swayed me the other way now. I'm not sure it's intentional or not, but throughout the story I didn't feel like John was an 'evil' character; he just came across as a man who made a difficult decision to the best of his ability. Excellent job all around!
| Orange Autumn chapter 1 . 7/24/2008
Wow, this really got me deep down, lol. I cried so much. I'm so partial to Dean. This was a very interesting and awesome take on how things could've turned out differently. Great job, and thanks so much for sharing this!
| Tomorrows Dust chapter 1 . 6/30/2008
Oh my god, you totally made me cry. It's a masterpiece, really. Just amazing, I loved it
Huggels, Tomorrows Dust
| annj chapter 1 . 1/27/2008
Great! Builds up a depressing athmosphere but kinda solves it in the end. Really good. *sniff* Love the way you DIDN'T bring back Sam from the dead for once. :-D
| Angelbyname chapter 1 . 9/20/2007
This is the best deathfic ever! Sad, heartbreaking.
| KAZ2Y567i chapter 1 . 9/17/2007
Oh man, this story moved me so much I'm still sniffing whilst typing this review.
I felt as numb and as cut off from the warmth in his life as Dean felt when he learnt of Sam's death. And of the coldness of betrayal at the secret that John had kept from him. All of Dean's emotions I felt vividly as I read further, and I also cried for him when I felt that he couldn't. Then for him to finally find some happiness in the 'normal' of working in a coffee house of all places.
You managed to switch there roles with the flick of a word...masterful
This is one of the best fics I have read for a long time.
Keep up the good work. You are in my favs/alerts.
| Lilly B chapter 1 . 9/7/2007
all i have is one word for this-amazing! i cried...i really did. you did a great job!