|Reviews for The Isle|
| Guest chapter 14 . 3/29
I don't know how I found this fic... but you are absolutely an amazing writer. I've not done reading yet but this is just a very beautiful and painful story so far and I love it thank you for creating this ;;;;;
| Dreams of Eternity chapter 4 . 3/17
This is a well written story; I enjoy the way that Cagalli's character has developed and grown from the Gundam series. I will admit that I have only read the first three chapters in this story, so perhaps my review will be misguided.
While I find Cagalli's character quite believable, Athrun's character is (to me) not true to the series. He comes across as, quite honestly, a dick. He seems to be taking a little too much pleasure in the power he is holding over Cagalli and his ability to manipulate and control her. BUUUT, that might just be my feminist side coming out. I just can't help wanting her to kick the sh*t out of Athrun as I read though - I think he deserves it.
But who knows? Maybe as the story progresses he will be less of a misogynistic asshole... I haven't decided if I will keep reading to find out. All I know is, I was hoping Cagalli would do us both a favor and stick a fork in his conceited eye. To my dismay, she did not in this chapter :)
| Summerrain chapter 34 . 12/5/2014
I LOVE YOU SO MUCHHH PUZZLEPUZZLE THIS STORY NEVER GETS OLDDDDD. . . EVEN THOUGH IT MY SIXTH TIME READING THIS, IT STILL GIVE THE FEELLLLLSSSS.. . LLLLOOOVEE ITTT I LOVE CAGALLI HERE, I LIKE IT THAT YOU DESCRIBE HER AS AN EPITOME OF BEAUTY, ,SOO FEMININE, ATHRUN SO MYSTYRIOUS! SO HANDSOME, SO DANGEROUS AND SO VULNERABLE. GOSH. . OKAY ILL BE REREADING THE SEQUEL FOR THE FIFTH TIME
| Midomiya-chi chapter 34 . 8/18/2014
I honestly don't know what to review, I am 4 years too late but I enjoyed reading this completed AsuGa fanfic. If there's something bothering it'll be the ending but that's me *I wanted to know what happens next so I'll check our your sequel.
Um. ...Eh Well Thanks for writing this fix and strengthening the AsuGa ship in a way. This is probably one of the best fics in the anime section. (Gundam Seed has the best written fics anyways)
At the beginning I was hesitant to read because there's was so much going on and I couldn't understand. Then I read on and got addicted. I mean like I love the way you wrote Athrun -how everyone in the world views him differently because his that persons son.
Cagalli on the other hand was a bit confusing of even annoying at some points in this fics because she couldn't help but feel like she had to keep everything to herself. Just like Athrun in a way.
I love your OC especially Athrun aides- The maids, and Durandal son. Also Ko too.
I also liked the way Yzak was been portrayed. I like practically everything in here so whatever.
| Temkin Beck chapter 27 . 3/22/2014
Ah yzak. My dear yzak, i knew there was a reason you're my favorite character!
| Reddawn Queen chapter 34 . 3/12/2014
Thank you very much for your really really great story. I'm so grateful that I can find a wonderful story like this. I just joined. I'm really think that it's very good to continue AsuCaga story like this. You're really talented writer:)
Looking forward to your another great story :)
| xx2991xx chapter 34 . 11/16/2013
Thanks for a wonderful story.
The ending was a little abrupt though, I was looking forward to see how they are gonna weather through the media storm, but there a sequel isn't it, looking forward to it )
| jaja59 chapter 9 . 11/5/2013
Hi pp, I was rereading The Isle so when Cagalli said 'Relief'. You're referring to what Blair has said when Chuck's was asking her about Nate in Victrola? Just because I read in your A/N you were a fan of gossip girl. Anyway. I don't think I would get tired of rereading your fics! ;)
| Kyral chapter 34 . 7/31/2013
First I want to say, holy crap that was long. Second bravo. I may have thought that Athrun was being kinda creepy rapey at first then his motives come out and you kinda feel like he is his own worst enemy (same for Cagalli really). Those two have always had it rougher than the Golden Couple (Kira and Lacus) and I like the way you captured that. Only thing I kinda wanted to see was maybe some Mobile Suit action? Oh and kudos for redeeming Shinn!
| mey.doyle chapter 34 . 6/3/2013
I dunno what to say more now 0:)
I just hope more and more romantic scenes in the end 3 3 :-!
| Sleepyreader319 chapter 34 . 4/8/2013
| Rawrrdoll chapter 34 . 1/2/2013
It took me almost year and half to find this fic again. And today i finish it i have to say that its one masterpiece. I cant believe all the emotions u make me feel. Good to know there is a sequel and my hope its that u update it :D i love how u write its amazing! After all the problems that took me away from reading i could say thank you for writing this! A continue to write u have talent.
| princesscagalli22 chapter 34 . 12/10/2012
Firstly, I would like to congratulate for this amazing fic!
I love the plot, the twists and turns and everything!
As of now, this is my favorite AsuCaga fic :)
I hope you'll continue your works and God Bless! :)
| Anon chapter 14 . 9/7/2012
...What the fuck is up with all the misogyny/male chauvinists values in this story?I don't even know what to say,but i'm tired of fan fictions and animus having this theme in them.
| venus hawthorne chapter 34 . 8/27/2012
This story was simply amazing.
I've only recently re-watched Gundam Seed (it's been 6 years for me) but I decided not to finish Destiny-I already had a hunch I wouldn't like it in regards to what happens between Athrun and Cagalli.
But wow, the Isle was everything that I needed to read. I love the more mature Athrun and Cagalli's feistiness despite her changing into a strong political figure. The character development was great! I think it'll be stuck in my head for a while and I'll believe it to be the real continuation of what happens to them afterwards.
Thank you for sharing such a great story! I hope to read more works from you :)