Reviews for Persistence of Memory
kaiiju chapter 7 . 3/31/2012
...this crossover works amazingly well. Really.
DaughterofLuthien chapter 7 . 11/12/2011
Absolutely wonderful! I've always thought The Year that Never Was would be the perfect setting for a Superwho story, as those events affected America in a big way, and of course the hunters would be very influential in the underground movements. After all, they have experience, guts, and determination that most people don't, and fighting evil (whether supernatural or extra-terrestrial) is already second nature to them.

I also love that, by the end of the story, Martha has saved the world, not once, but twice, and has effectively saved the lives of both Sam and Dean. You also handled the fixed-point-in-time problem very deftly, I applaud you.

I'd love to see more stories from this 'verse! Since the apocalypse has been averted before it even began, you've changed the timeline and now anything can happen. And now that the boys now that aliens exist, I'd also love to see them dealing with some of that stuff.

Once again, brilliant job! I loved it!
Shenlong Girl chapter 7 . 9/19/2011
This was so cool! Great job, and great plot idea.
WingedFlight chapter 7 . 5/18/2011
This is absolutely brilliant. What a perfect way of crossing these two over. (Superwho FOREVER) But seriously, amazing, amazing Martha Jones, amazing Winchester boys, and amazing plot. You've combined these perfectly.
charming-witch chapter 7 . 4/19/2011
I finished reading everything now and totally love it! Great job on the story and characters. :-)
charming-witch chapter 1 . 4/19/2011
Awesome start! I've had an idea about Martha meeting Sam & Dean during the year that never was stuck in my head for a while now. But I never managed to write it down. Now I found your story and am really excited. :-) Can't wait to read more.
Silvermoon of Forestclan chapter 7 . 3/6/2011
I loved this so much! I know you can't see it, but I'm grinning really hard. XD

Stories set in this DW episode can be so emotional, ne?

Jadziwine chapter 7 . 10/18/2010
OMG I LOVED THIS STORY! i wish i was an actual episode. I'd love to see Martha snogging Dean's face off! this was bloody brilliant! you got all the characters down to a T! utter perfection... like seriously this really should have been an epi! fantastic writing skills! x
Harlyn chapter 7 . 4/5/2010
Loved it! I'd actually be pretty interested in the catch-up conversation in the bar too, but this was a great and satisfying way the Dean hell-plot could have gone.
LastScorpion chapter 7 . 3/4/2010
Wow, what a wonderful crossover!
Miggs chapter 7 . 9/19/2008
Caught my very first episode of Supernatural last night, which also happened to be the 4th Season premiere. Am now very hooked on the show, and knew that there had to be a DW/Supernatural crossover somewhere. Guess what? I did the search and your story popped up. Thank you for a very well-written Dean-tastic fic; much appreciated by this newbie.
APatchOfSunlight chapter 7 . 9/16/2008
This fic is a gift to the world! I love this story so much, it was something that had to be written, only nobody else knew it! Thanks for allowing mere mortals like myself to see this piece of awesomeness.

Guile chapter 1 . 6/5/2008
It's fics like this that make me very, very glad you're writing again. Clever melding of the two worlds, clever way to resolve the demon thing (I'm only on second season of Supernatural, myself) and I quite like the idea of Dean and Sam in the Master's little hell-on-earth episode. And we even get a happy ending!

Both Christina K and Rheanna coming back to , even if you're no longer in the Buffy fandom? Lucky for us!
Madness Hamster chapter 7 . 4/16/2008
I absolutely loved this fic! Has to be one of the best, if not the best, Dr Who/SPN crossovers I've ever read. It was so well written and the timelines could have been so confusing, but you wrote them brilliantly. Definitely going to check out some more of your stuff :)
Xayian chapter 7 . 4/5/2008
Okay, when I entered "Martha Jones" into a search engine under Supernatural I thought "Nothin's going to pop up." Then your story did, I read it and, to my utter relief, this time thought "Damn! This is good!"

The Good Points:

I don't get to read too many stories spotlighting Martha that are good, and to throw my favorite fellas into the mix was an awesome bonus. Dean and Martha...Nice. Love the whole idea behind it. You did an incredible job of combining the two worlds without stomping on the mythos of either series. I think that, except for a couple of minor things, you did a decent job of writing the characters. I would love to see you write another story with the three of them together. I also think you could totally pull off a Dean/Martha relationship. ;D *hint* *wink*

Nice job!

The Nit Pick:

I'm a stickler for keeping true to the boys so I apologize now if you find this a pain, but I just can't help myself. There are 3 things I think you may want to consider for the future. Dean doesn't smoke, although considering the circumstances I could understand him takin' up the habit. 2nd, Sam was killed from a severed spine when Jake stabbed him in the back. 3rd, just for the axe job that he did with Ruby, I believe Sam would have actually stolen a car if Ruby didn't.

In the grand scheme of things, none of this really impacted the overall story telling, but I had to share. :) Now a scene I would have loved to see you write would be the flight to England. I would love to know how many rock songs Dean would have sung through that flight. *chuckles*
35 | Page 1 .. Last Next »