I just found this story yesterday and I am very happy with it. It is an amazing fanfiction! Your characters have a lot of depth and seem so real, which is rare in fanfiction and even some "professional's" work. But it's been more than five years since you've updated?! I really hope nothing happened to make you not want to finish this or not able to. I would love to see how everything goes after this! Please come back and update! .

I think Al's perspective would be cool, I especially want to know his feelings about the huge fight... On that note, I am slightly mortified to say that some bits in these last couple of chaps have has me in tears, like the huge fight and the Weasley-Potter clan group appreciation for Rosie.. And how James was being insufferable. I'm glad Fred got him to see the light, but honestly, it made me mad. If I had been in her position, my anger would have dulled my mortification and I'd probably have yelled after why was said about ruining creevey and wart-ifying that dude, something alon the lines of 'I know every secret in this family, I carry it all! But no one ever thinks about me enough to notice that I've liked someone for 3 freaking years! The only people that know have either been told in deeper confidence or they have actually paid attention to my feelings! And guess what James? That binds the total o people who care up to TWO! So yes, I hurt Albus. But he's been hurting me for years. Ive been putting his wellbeing in front of mine for my entire life, and he doesn't even have the decency to let me figure out my own feelings about guys who are interested? This is my life, James, MY LIFE. And it's not fair that you guys aren't letting me live it!'

Rant over. Rest assured ( man I sound pompous ), I like how you did it, it totally portrayed Rosie and her hurt, I just needed to get what I think out of my system. Also, I think I cried because I could feel an see the emotion and hurt behind their words, especially when Rosie was yelling at Albus. I can't even see her clearly on my head, but I could imagine all this because of the groundwork you put on earlier to this story.

I can't wait for an update, I think I prefer rosies POV but I'm not sure... You seem more comfortable writing her feelings than Scor's, and it makes her POV more enjoyable. Not that Scor POV isn't enjoyable, Rosie POV seems to be natural. Maybe it's cos I'm a girl and relate?

Whatever.

Anyway. Not meaning for the last line, or this one to sound apathetic but I'm too lazy to backspace this much.. Which makes me wonder why I bother typing... Bad JJ. Okay, rambling over.

Cheers

Sherbetgirl :)x

Question: is your Lysander a boy or girl?

Fantastic story, but um... I would just like you to know that it's 2010.

Write something? :D :P

Hey,

I've been reading this story since you started writing it and I've been waiting for you to return to it. I really hope you come back and update soon!

Kat

please up-date i'm really loving the storyline, can't wait until Al finds out :)

Do we have to write our name? When is the ending, or this is? I love this story, but how do I know if it is the continuation of Harry Potter by J. ?

please update this story. its really good and i really want to see Al's reaction about his 2 best friends dating, that would be really cool.

so PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE update as soon as u can ;D

ok . i'm sorry if i soung stupid but i don't get it is fred gay or what?

can't wait to see what happens next! update soon please!

Great story! I just finished reading it! You write so well. I was soo drawn into your story that I couldn't turn my computer off to go to bed. Oh well. I'm glad I didn't, though. Your story is amazing. The way you captivate the characters and their aspects is incredible. I can't wait to hear about the Hogsmeade trip! Please update soon!

Please keep on writing this story! It's one of the best Rose/Scorpius fics I've read!

stories from other characters pov would b interesting 2 read D

loving the story-keep it up P

Oh oohh oh I think I may have understood the Hellogoodbye reference. Admittedly I only have one song by them but it is so perfect. Bestfriends. Love the song and I absoutely adore this fan fic. I really like how the intensity of Rose and Scorpius' relationship matches their earlier feelings.

Bit of a shock we didn't even know Poppy and I still feel bad that's pregnant at such a young age. I love that Rose is a spitfire she's got a fair bit of a tmeper that one and I love it. Can't wait to read the rest.