|Reviews for And Then There Were None|
| justification to wormtail chapter 1 . 4/2/2008
That was really, really good! I love your writing style as well as the story. Awesome job! D
| pure flake chapter 1 . 3/10/2008
I loved this.
Although it was kinda tragic, still somewhat a happy ending at the same time. Marauders' reunion.. They really are destined to be together, alive or dead, right?
| LadyPurple chapter 1 . 3/3/2008
I'm definitely not a Peter Lover. I have no idea who the hell is.
But anyway, I really loved the reunion! I'm glad Peter was booted out of that group! He was such a bastard, prick he is.
Anyhoo, enough Peter bashing, this made me cry! *shakes fist* but the reuniting was so... *sniffles* fantastic, Julia!
| hermionegranger47393 chapter 1 . 3/3/2008
*wipes away tear*
So powerful! I adored it, hun!
It hooked me in from the very beginning and the part that really made me start sobbing was the
"Where - where's Harry?"
HAHA DEATH'S PLACE. It's not heaven, it's not hell, it's not anything religious, it's DEATH'S PLACE. Like an apartment, almost... Hehe.
I loved it!
| boymayorofsecondlife chapter 1 . 3/2/2008
wowzah. this was just...wowzah.
i loved the dialouge in this fic the best. every Marauder (who spoke) seemed to really be *themselves*, y'know?
me loves happy endings _.
me loves SiRem _
ME LOVES THIS FIC _
| XxXpassionatemuseXxX chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
Aww. I love it. it was so sad at the being but i was crying even harder at the end. Question; What was Remus going to do when Tonks showed up?
Xylia Luna Orion
| Bottlebrush chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
I very much like the way you have structured this: the four deaths, then the four men finding themselves in the afterlife. It's neat and clever. And yes, they did all die for Harry - and as Harry is the one hope for the world, they died for all the world. And you succeeded in making a happy ending. There is just one thing that would make it happier, for me, and you touched on it in your Note. I wish they could have found it in themselves to forgive Peter. I know it's asking a lot, but in the happiness of their reunion they could have found the generosity to pity someone who was weak, rather than bad... Anyway, good story, well and skilfully written. I liked it.
| Jordanne chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
"we dont talk to him" that makes them sound like catty neighbours xD
this is really good. i would print it out and stick it on my wall but thats just creepy
| Technophobic.Shin chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
*sobs* so... *weeps* amazing! :D
| MisbehavingBubbles chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
LOL DEATH'S PLACE. SO AWESOME.
I loved the fact that they reunited. It was really a nice take on such a sad ending in the books. The books really left me terribly unsatisfied, so this gorgeous writing really made it seem brighter. I love you! :D
| XAdorkablexXxHotshotX chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
Aw. Really tearjerking, but amazing. I loved it.
| IdOnTwAnTyOuToSeEmEcRy chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
Just really heartwarming. Let's you appreciate the horror that is Deathly Hallows. I loved how it can make you cry and laugh in happiness. It was overall, incredibly sad but extremely great as well!
The writing was really excellent. I have no complaints!
| xXWriteXMeXAXStoryXx chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
Aw. So sad!
I really loved the overall plot with the 'and then there were three' and counting down and stuff! It was really nice to see it go to none and come back up again.
*sniffles* reminds me of DH. You put that really awful book in a good light! :P
| MiloVentimigliaIsLove chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
WOWZERS. I cried when all of them died (even Peter, even though he's an asshole wuss) and it was SOO sad to hear James say:
"Where - where's Harry?"
*bursts into tears*
I thought it was amazing. Great writing, seeing as it actually made me cry! :D
Lots of love.
| PaddyWaddy chapter 1 . 2/27/2008
This was amazing..I thought you wrote the Peter part pretty neuteral! Now they can shag like bunnies for forever..