Reviews for Elementary Calculations
meg.edwards27 chapter 13 . 5/30/2019
very sad to see this story has not been updated in so long. following just in case the author ever decides to come back to it. this story has the potential to become one of my favorite fanfictions.
Handers chapter 13 . 5/14/2019
A shame this story was never finished, the plot is interesting and the writing is nice.

Maybe you could just post the plot as you had intended for it to go?
Guest chapter 12 . 5/1/2019
Shame it’s discontinued, brilliant story.
csheila chapter 3 . 3/22/2019
Good for Harry. Never argument Dursley’s didn’t abuse him, since “no proof” of physical abuse. Emotional scars run deep.

Not to say I don’t enjoy an alt Dursley story (or reforming Dudley)
That2-one3-girl4 chapter 13 . 3/22/2019
It's a brilliant fic. It's sad that it hasn't been updated in 11 years. It's truly a shame that fic goes incomplete. I really like where this is going...
Halo Star Wars X-over fan chapter 3 . 3/21/2019
The whole Mother’s sacrifice is entirely true and makes perfect sense actually. All you have to do is do maybe a handful of “dark” rituals use some runes. Sacrifice your magic, life and soul and Bam you have a extremely powerful protection. Not to mention magic is all about Intent if you’ve forgotten. So with her Intent of sacrificing every little bit of herself whatever ritual she preformed or prepared before in the case it’s ever needed, it makes perfect sense it works out the way it did.

Not to mention Lily as stated several times was a absolute Genius and supposedly created several things before her death. Not only that in FanFiction at the very least maybe even canon Lily was a “Unspeakable” essentially meaning she had access to extremely ancient, obscure or dark rituals, spells amongst other things.

So all in all if in this particular case all the above was true, then it’s not far stretched for the whole Mother’s loving sacrifice to work out.

All it means it you were just looking at the plain literal words and wasn’t ever bothering to look at the underlying details or hidden facts. Story’s absolutely never tell you the details straight of in your face unless it’s absolutely needed. Since it’s always up to the readers discretion and interpretation of the tidbits of details they are given, to decide what it means. Otherwise it wouldn’t truly be a story.

Anyways that’s all just felt like responding to that little thing.
malcadicta chapter 13 . 2/22/2019
Damn I loved the story and your creepy!Harry. Am I 11 years too late to this fic? Yes. Is the chance of anyone even reading the review pretty much nonexistant? Probably. Still a really good piece, I I love the execution, you avoided most of the more cliche problems the smart!Harry genre often brings and I really wish this wasn't discontiniued…

Hope you're well and still writing. Even more hope that I can some day find more things written by you.
kaftan chapter 13 . 1/8/2019
Wow, this is a good story. Sorry to see this one discontinued. Hope you are well and just busy doing something else. Thank you!
csheila chapter 6 . 1/5/2019
Damn, can Dumbledore create Dark Lords.

This was truly heartbreaking. Perhaps this why you haven't yet finished story.
csheila chapter 4 . 1/5/2019
Love it.

It really seemed unlikely all the teachers would ignore Harry's plight. Unless we MOB Dumbledore actively interfered.
csheila chapter 2 . 1/5/2019
Good job.

Regardless of what canon advocates argue, Dursley's abused Harry. You have given him outlets to approach the problems. Both his parents were brilliant so he has the genetic make up.
Dark-Prince-of-Clowns chapter 9 . 12/25/2018
I LOVE creepy Harry! :D

Especially because his threat is so subtle of an implication that nobody else would have thought it hinted at him being behind anything... at least bot without a penisiev. And even then, it's a mere small suspicion, requiering a mind similar to Snapes to be caught.

Keep writing this wonderfully interesting work!.
Dark-Prince-of-Clowns chapter 6 . 12/25/2018
dumbledore really shot himself in the foot, didn't he? If I were in Harry's shoes, I'd side with the enemy of dumbledore and aim to destroy his entire life after pulling that shit. Death is too good for him.

I'm really looking forward to see what Harry does tho. I keep my fingers crossed he goes dark, at the very least.
Dark-Prince-of-Clowns chapter 2 . 12/24/2018
I'm surprised he hasn't found the library section on the occult yet.
All magic is fundementaly fuled by emotions... numerous of the most popular and commonly found in library books such as Satanic Rituals by LaVey (yeah...there are books by him in almost every library I've visited, which is many) and various occult books of the more whitchy folkmagic sort (and angels and to variating degrees demons) is also very common.

And that is without mentioning the ever popular Necronomicon. (Based on Lovecrafts work, published as if it's the real deal, filled with lots of dark, powerful rituals.)

Any wizard visiting the local library too much will either become a trelawny-esque angel lover, or a Dark wizard in no time. XD
Drew86 chapter 12 . 12/16/2018
Albus is a right old bastard! Manipulative old goat! YOU ARE NOT GOD! I love this story and hope to read more in the future! Faithful readers await!
2,119 | « Prev Page 1 .. 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 18 .. Last Next »