Wow. Although I’m glad the episode actually ended with Dean dyingotherwise no Cas! -this would have been a really good alternative. Thank you for writing it!

I almost choked on my spit on the end XD

LMAO

I keep reading this over and over. I just love how you had Sam in this, freakin' awesome. Everything is just so well put and God I love it! I like a darker Sam trying to be good but that 'unpure' part of him fighting to get to the surface. Oh man it's just soooo cool! Also Dean was, ugh-I just can't get enough. It was all just amazing. God I want more stuff like this T-T I know this was a quite a few years ago, but I'm still going to read this... again... and again...

Yesssssssss! Perfect ending.

Too bad the season didn't end that way. It got waaay to angsty. This was great

Sam would have been a damn good lawyer.

Aww! That was so sweet:,)

-The Winters Child-

Awwww...Adorable.

I loved it. :*) And the ending? I started cracking up. Just fantastic. XD

awww, thats awesome, _ a nice alternate ending to the season

I really, really, Really love how this ends. "for the sum of 25, no chores for three weeks and two bags of M&Ms" Perfect.

Wow! Pretty cool DD

The fight in hell was just amazing. And the ending was just cute

I really liked it ~

See ya next, then o/

Rosetta

OMG that was awesome. The ending was great Dean selling his soul to Sam for M&M's I can so see that happening. Loved it.

Alright, so this was, how should we say? Awesome. Yup, awesome is in fact THE word. The description of the first tunnel of Hell was great, definitely un-Hell like as addressed, but blood sliding up from the floor endlessly is a tauntingly scary image that hilariously didn't phase Sam too heavily.

"I know who I am without Dean. I can't..." Loved this line, really captures the psyche of someone embracing a last, desperate measure of a plan.

The arguing between Sam and the Judge was great. Gotta love the Judge of Hell accusing Sam of "splitting hairs". The fight scene that followed was well written from the ax manifesting, Sam's realization of his dark laugh, and his tormented thoughts of the animal he's become. I'm a huge Dark Sam fan, so I'm clearly a piece of this work as it makes it all appear as Pre-Dark Sam. Of course, he doesn't turn into Boy King here, but it's still all very good stuff.

My favorite part (along with the closing lines) would be when the Judge deceives Sam, only allowing the contest to allow to show Sam his potential. To allow him a sliver of what he could be if he only just gave into the blood dripped into him.

The Dean-in-Hell moments were well written, to be simply put, but I love how Dean sold out to chocolate, being chore-free for three weeks, and $25. Lol, at that time Sam may have been the one who got suckered, but it all panned out, right? Awesome, awesome, piece.