Reviews for Anything but Slytherin |
---|
BDSanta2001 chapter 1 . 5/21/2008 That was cool. (Not being sarcastic) |
Monks1 chapter 1 . 5/21/2008 "I would have let Malfoy stay around in some capacity." Heh, the first thing i said wen i read the first sections of this was, if it was continued, Malfoy would be a potentially good friend/accomplice. He has that whole, sidekicky look. |
Voice of the Nephilim chapter 1 . 5/21/2008 I don't really think I can blame McGonagall for silencing the Sorting Hat song. Wow. Despite it's complete lack of violence and torture, one of the more disturbing one-shots I've read. For a one-shot, you certainly took care to provide a very vivid picture of the how the world has turned out. Rather like a Philip K. Dick story, in that the world painted is vivid enough to create a feel for it, without delving into narrative voice to bring the reader up to speed. Very well done. Brought here by the Yin & Yang false start on DLP. Best of luck on that. |
Banner chapter 1 . 5/21/2008 That was horrifying. Oh. My. God. Well done. |
TedLupin32 chapter 1 . 5/21/2008 Great idea! I would like to see more from this universe. |
Memory King chapter 1 . 5/21/2008 That was terrific! Definitely the best take on the sorting I've ever seen. The look into a dark wizarding world where Voldemort is not around was very intriguing, wouldn't be opposed to some more material in this universe. |