Reviews for Run that by me again?
Guest chapter 14 . 6/24
logic, wizards. your own is clearly lackin- w8. what happens to the poor muggleborns who used to be logical?
Guest chapter 10 . 6/24
yeah. thankfully, he's just mad. and not even completely so! probably worse, though, is his being terribly prone to wizard logic. hopefully, hermione when she grows up will help slowly abolish that. i know that she, being smart and a muggleborn, can help.
Guest chapter 9 . 6/24
that last line just gave me the feelin this was one a those peggy sue things, with harry and hermione goin back. i just... i know it can't be what happened, by the beginnin a the chapter, but that's the vibe i get from the end.
Guest chapter 5 . 6/24
well, in that new game, yandere simul8or, apparently like half(actually probably more, but i can't remember) the female popul8ion is in love with senpai... like seiously that is SO unrealistic.
Guest chapter 3 . 6/24
i love this. so many logical points that would have made the books themselves... actually a lot more boring but they'd make more sense!
Guest chapter 5 . 6/21
It did annoy me.
Guest chapter 20 . 6/5
yes. there was no logical reason hermione would think that. but why has she picked up the wizard ball in this chapter? this is a story where they are logical. she probably could have listened sooner. had she not been 'holding' what i like to call 'the wizard ball'(inspired by tvt). meaning that she's being illogical, because the wizard ball does that.
Guest chapter 13 . 6/4
yyeah... i can imagine the war causing mental damage. but how did EVERYONE die? honestly, there's got to be some other survivors unless noone survived, but harry did, so... nope.
Guest chapter 10 . 6/4
about the elixir. Q(the other thing is too long to type out) wouldn't just need the stone to make the elixir. it said something about 'seeing myself making the elixir', and i got the impression that since the sorceror's(or philosopher's, but i prefer this) stone was an alchemy thing, you'd need a whole bunch a equipment and stuff to make it, along with the stone, which is probably just a catalyst a some sort. i mean, what did they think happened, they squeeze it really hard and immortality juice comes out? as funny/impossible as that would be, no. and since you can apparently use it for 600 years and they still have it, they definitely don't grind it up or anything. and i get the feeling Q didn't, and would not be able to regardless of whether he did, take all that stuff anyway. after all, a small stone that fits in your pocket? can be taken back to a lab or st8ion of some sort. a lab or st8ion for alchemy? cannot easily be taken through: a trapdoor with a long fall onto creeping, strangling vines(80u8), a troll fight(even if he's 'good with trolls', also, i don't remember the order), a giant chessboard, a room with magical fire that i think might do something to the whatevers, flying a round on a broomstick to catch a key, and probably some others i forgot. so, basically: even if, somehow, he got the stone, he wouldn't be able to make the elixir immedi8ly as hermione seems to think. w0A! that a lOT A TExt$! eh, there's no word limit. or character limit whatnot.
Guest chapter 8 . 6/4
i just realized: how did the petrified people survive without eating? i'm pretty sure they weren't actually turned to stone... and i'd like a better explan8ion than magic. does anyone have any ideas?
Guest chapter 4 . 6/4
okay, one of two things happened, and i'm inclined to think it's the latter considering that he seemed to feel actual pain. the first is that ginny lied, and just wanted to be with him(which i guess is kind of sweet). as i said, probably not the case. the second is that they bonded by accident, which seems more likely as he talks about it like a thing that just happened rather than a choice.
Guest chapter 3 . 6/4
glad to see they are spreading the cure of logic(that is, the cure[to the wizarding world's insanity] that is logic, not the cure for logic) to others, such as cedric. more people will surely survive because of this. who knows, maybe sirius won't stand next to the veil of who-knows-wtf-is-in-there, or he won't pause even briely to get hit(what kind of idiot pauses to get hit? his actor in the movies), and he'll survive. shrug.
thepkrmgc chapter 16 . 6/4
these people know that horcruxes do nasty things to people, its good that they didnt let their martyr complex get in the way of logic
thepkrmgc chapter 13 . 6/4
the whole time travel thing has enough unfortunate implications without adding underage relationships to the mix
thepkrmgc chapter 11 . 6/4
even logic has limits, and the graveyard doesnt really abide its rules, but they at least got part of the problem resolved
1,907 | « Prev Page 1 .. 2 3 4 5 6 13 .. Last Next »