|Reviews for winter & the third half|
| Hugone chapter 2 . 6/27/2012
This is really lovely- I find all the characters here to be realistic. It's like a characterisation of them that I've been waiting for- although written in only a few words, I think you have achieved a depth that many longer stories struggle to achieve. It is really really good. I have to say that Hermione is the stand out character here; you have managed to find the girl under all that hair perfectly. It's like this is a part of her that completely true but often overlooked. I wish more fanfics wrote her like this- it's how I thought of her all along.
| the sun in splendor chapter 2 . 7/9/2011
i've never read a story where the characters stay so true.
thank you for that.
| The Falling Moon chapter 2 . 5/3/2010
I have never read anything like this. It is so well writen, so exact. Every word creates the idea of this story and you have writen some of the most beautiful and saddest sentences i have ever read. Truly an amazing ff, that i wish i understood a little better, but still it's fantastic.