|Reviews for Revenge|
| monbade chapter 6 . 7/3
Bella wouldnt have been in the school when James was 7th year she was born in 1951. Andromeda was in 43 and and Nirissca was in 55. All three would have graduated well before James did as Sirius and James were born in 59/60 both graduated in 78
| Emma snail chapter 11 . 6/3
The ending wasn’t that great , but I really love the storyline and plot ! Wished there were more chapters though, but overall, good job !
| Heart chapter 1 . 2/24
GO LILY! GO LILY!~
| unfittingpuzzlepieces chapter 11 . 2/11
Awww, I really liked this! Especially your Marauders are perfect. Though I also loved your version of Lily messing up and regretting stuff
| Wolfie0103 chapter 11 . 2/16/2017
Wow. Just wow. I love this so much, especially the relationship between Lily and the Marauders. I think that's exactly how it would be like. I've read loads of your stories (practically all of them) in one hit and they're amazing! You're definitely one of my favourite authors!
| smallwjl chapter 11 . 9/21/2016
well that was a bit of an emotional roller coaster. very well down!
| MarinaJackson chapter 2 . 8/3/2016
awww poor James... poor unsuspecting naive James
| Lala-rainbowlight chapter 11 . 7/28/2016
BEAUTIFUL, AND THE MARAUDERS ARE AMAZING!
| Lala-rainbowlight chapter 7 . 7/28/2016
You crushed my heart with the palm reading part 'both a short life-line' omggg...
| jaztazgirl chapter 11 . 7/27/2016
Molly, it was perfect. I can't even begin to explain about the beyond miserable day I'd been having until I read this fic. I can't even remember what had me so down anymore, and let me tell you, THAT'S the sign of truly great writing. Your words have been my savior. I'm eternally grateful. I truly hope you continue to write, it's your gift to share with the world.
| Guest chapter 6 . 2/19/2016
I'm backing out of this story now, as I'm really disappointed in it, and rather frustrated because it had an excellent premise - in fact, the exact premise I've been DYING to find in a Jily story, and while the beginning started out well, the execution was just terrible. Why the hell is Lily such a doormat, I mean this story mentions Snape being her once-best friend so it doesn't have the excuse of having missed Lily's characterization in both the fifth and seventh books.
I get that Lily would feel a bit guilty over her Prank given how deeply it hurt James, but I can't at all believe she'd be tormented to the point of crying everywhere and cutting herself off and barely speaking for a YEAR over a relatively minor prank that James (arrogant dick that he was at this age, remember this wasn't long after he'd literally asked her out in the grossest way possible -while torturing her best friend - and played a hand in the breakup with her best friend. Which, whatever you may think of him, undoubtedly would have hurt Lily and inspired a sense of revenge) quite frankly deserved.
Where is her spark? At the very least, I believe she would've felt some sense of karmic justice being served, we know she has a slightly vindictive streak in the books. Regardless of whether he loved her or not (which Lily had no way of knowing so she can't feel overly guilty about that), James wasn't entitled to basic respect for his feelings from Lily considering how he disrespected hers by asking her out in such an unwanted way.
*sigh* Again, great premise, but I really think you way overdid it on Lily's guilt, to the point where I'm just annoyed with both characters. Yes, Lily did a terrible thing. And she should own it, own the effects of it, and get the hell over it rather than draping herself in self-pity and self-flagellation.
| Girlygirlyay chapter 11 . 11/9/2015
| guest chapter 11 . 7/19/2015
this was so good :D
you're a truly amazing writer.
| Emily Irene chapter 9 . 4/24/2015
I seriously love this.
| Alma chapter 11 . 4/11/2015
Such an amazing story. I think it is really interesting to see how you wrote before "boyfriend", the fact that the cute emo owl and I share a name was just an added bonus. I stayed up until 2.30 am thanks to this, I jut couldn't stop reading! Thank you for writing this amazing story complete with jokes, banter, drama and romance, a perfect combination! I don't know if you'll ever see this, but thanks for writing it!