| Reviews for Your Heart Remained the Same |
|---|
   HistoryintheMaking chapter 1 . 9/27/2008 Oh my goodness. You are an angst genius. I can't even put into words how much I love this fanfic, how much work I see that you've put in and thought out and how much I appreciate your efforts, how wonderfully short sweet and simple and how beautifully you paint the picture of Jacob's life. In this realm, Jacob and Bella belong together. "The man overcomes the monster." And I don't regret it (being team edward), reading this and wondering "What if?" too. Sigh, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful. You deserve a nomination. I think I will do that when I figure out how the heck to do it. |
| Emily Stole the World chapter 1 . 9/27/2008 Oh. My. God. . . I . . .this. It is like the most brilliant post-breaking dawn story EVER written. Everything made since. I was thinking about him not having any choice during any of the books and it glad to so someone was thinking something similar. All of this seems like it could really happen. Jake is so written all over this :) |
| PhoenixFyre chapter 1 . 9/27/2008 That may be the most depressing, yet most wonderful, story I've ever read. I still have tears in my eyes. Oh Jacob... I really hope this isn't how it would go, for all their sakes! I choose to believe in the happily ever after, but I can still appreciate the what-ifs. Awesome job, you are truly talented at expressing the emotion of the characters. I'm off to read more cheerful Bella/Jake stories... Team Jacob forever! |
| hhecsi chapter 1 . 9/27/2008 oh my gawd... I am seriously crying right now.. you did a fan-freaking-tastic job with this story...! |
| Fluffy Otters chapter 1 . 9/27/2008 Oh. My. Jacob. Black. This. Was. Fantastic. And. Sad. And. Freaking. Amazing. Wow, you have left me speechless. This was fantastic. Beautiful, brilliant, sad, heartbraking, you made me cry reading this. I felt every heart-rending moment and emotion. This was fantastically well written and you made me cry with it's sadness. Geez, that's not nice. You have even got me to repeat myself. Wow, I love this. Jacob, never had a choice, it might have been better to just give in and accept the inevitable. He hung on for too long and it wasn't worth it. He eventually stopped phasing and started aging again. I'm amazed he just didn't commit suicide if he wanted to die so bad, now that he stopped phasing and lost Werewolf immortality and everything. But then after living for so long, I guess the years went by fast for him. So sad. If Bella had chosen Jacob... |