|Reviews for Goodbye|
| mellamaet chapter 1 . 11/29/2012
The fact that I'm reading this while listening to the Graduation version of We're All In This Together makes it even sadder :((
| MaxandFang101 chapter 1 . 8/24/2011
I've always wanted a twin, but it really must be terrible and scary having to leave each other after such a long time together. :'(
| Nightglider-star chapter 1 . 7/12/2009
| SqueakyTheDuck chapter 1 . 4/6/2009
Aw! That was awesome. I was watching HSM 3 and thinking we should have seen more of Sharpay of Ryan, and hear their thoughts about going their separate ways, and this fit the bill perfectly! Love it! Five starts!
| penguincrazy chapter 1 . 2/4/2009
Really great stroy, you protrayed Ryan and Sharpay so perfect. I have a twin brother and even though we were never as close in high school as Ryan and Sharpay, it is still weird to be aat two differnet colleges. We were never in the same classes(except homeroom) but we were still in the same school. We did not have a moment like this but I guess the feelings were the same
| Trashbags chapter 1 . 12/22/2008
THAT WAS SO SAD! but i loved it all the same
| Danny Phantom SG-1 chapter 1 . 11/28/2008
M, an Evans twin "moment." I haven't written a story for them in awhile. Too much Ryelsi love going on in my mind, I guess. :P Haha, but this moment is definitely one I'm interested in. I'd liked to have seen this be maybe a little bit longer, just because I'm a sap for sentimental dialogue, but that's just me. It's sweet the way it is. Ever since I saw the movie, I've been wondering how those two would cope without each other. Granted, they didn't get along too famously in HSM3 in general, but you know they've gotta still be feeling a little dreadful of a future without their other half. Now, we're bound to end up with Ryelsi and Chadpay together forever, eh? ;) Haha, well, anyway, this was sweet. Nice read.
| Politics.and.Prose chapter 1 . 11/22/2008
That was sweet. I think you've portaryed the "new" Sharpay very well. It seemed to me that at then end of the movie, she became very ... real. And I like that you wrote her that way.
| JuseaPeterson chapter 1 . 11/19/2008
Aw, I really like this. I like their relationship and I wish the movies had shown a bit more of them. Going separate ways has to be hard for both of them. I really like how you did this.
| autumnamberleaves chapter 1 . 11/18/2008
Aww...I've thought of this...the twins' last moments before he goes off to New York. I bet Sharpay WOULD feel like this, perfect job on the characterization. You're right, they won't be the "the twins" or "The Evans Twins" they really will be just themselves. Which even though they are sad about it at the moment, could eventually be good for them. I have a set of four-year old twin neice and nephew and I know that already it's hard to not say "the twins" and to just say "Madelyn" or "Caleb." Sharpay and Ryan have been through presumably 18 years as "The Evans Twins." Great job!
| laurae13 chapter 1 . 11/18/2008
awe,that was so good! i felt like crying! it was a unique idea that i never heard of or thought about! i liked it alot and i think you did an amazing job on it! loved it! i never thought about how they would feel being seperated after high school and yeah so thats basically all i can think of to say! good job and loved it!
| digigirl02 chapter 1 . 11/18/2008
How sweet, I could see that happening when the twin's seperated.
| Penny chapter 1 . 11/18/2008
I love how she wouldn't admit that she's going to miss her brother. She does care as evidenced by giving him the Star Dazzle award in HSM2. I really like how he can tell that something is off with her. That part with Chad is funny. She seems to care about Kelsi and is on board with Ryelsi being together. They probably have never really been separated for too long, especially since they are twins, you captured their fear very well.
| angellwings chapter 1 . 11/18/2008
aw, that was so not OOC! That was Sharpay being the sister-Sharpay not the dictator-Sharpay! We know she can be like via the end of HSM2 and her forfeit of her trophy to Ryan.
So in short...I LOVE THIS! You almost had me crying! I was tearing up!
Such a cute Evans Twins moment. And her threat for him to be nice to Kelsi...SO SWEET!
Great fic! You have been favorited!