|Reviews for River of Blood|
| bhoney chapter 1 . 3/21/2009
Loved the name of the motel "Limberlost Motel". Seems very fitting. ;)
And I loved this: “How many prime numbers between 25 and 50?” (Because Dean totally could have been a mathlete in school, too, if he’d wanted.)
I think Dean is really smart, and I love fics that portray him that way.
I also loved this glimpse into their shared past: "Dean felt like he was 10 years old again. Fiercely pretending to be more brave and strong than he really was, so that his little brother would feel safe." Aw...
And this cracked me up: "Dean would never admit this, but sometimes he just lets the Impala pick a direction. He trusts her. And suspects she has a nose for good pie." LOL And I have to admit, I loved the idea of Mrs. Wick’s Pie Shop (especially the sugar creme pie, which sounds delicious). Oh, if only there really were such places...And this made me giggle too: "Besides. Dean has his priorities. There’s pie."
Great description of the town. You really set the scene well. LOVED Dean's enthusiasm over the idea of a zombie hunt, so endearing.
And this was a beautiful description, and so telling:
"Sam doesn’t think Dean even realizes he is doing it - savoring the taste and smell and touch of the most mundane activities. He’d expected his brother to be in a constant hurry, rushing to fill each hour of his last year with as much action as he could. But Dean isn’t...Dean … is lingering. As if letting go of each moment hurts.
That thought hits Sam like a punch to the heart, stealing his breath for a moment." Oh, boys. *sniffle*
And I loved this from Sam: "Because brothers – they belong together, right? They’re supposed to fight the enemy side by side." Wish that sentiment would creep into Season 4.
It makes me a little nervous that Sam's keeping the book a secret and has been looking for a spirit without bones. He definitely has something up his sleeve. And then you go and end this on a cliffhanger? Cruel. LOL that's why I only read completed stuff, this would've given me an ulcer. LOL
Great start. Intriguing and very well-written, and the boys are really in character. I look forward to reading more.
| CB Walters chapter 14 . 2/24/2009
Wow, another great fic! First off, I gotta say, I think it's so cool that you did all this research with family history and all that. That's a great family story, and I'm thrilled that you chose to share it with us. :)
Sort of along with that, I loved how well you used historical details. I'm a total Civil War geek (though my area of interest is Gettysburg), so I was so excited to see how historically accurate this fic was! The way the army worked, the types of weapons they used (and how to shoot them!), even some of the speech patterns ("seeing the elephant") were so spot on that I really felt like they were back in time.
Which leads to...the boys! :) You did such a great job capturing the essence of their brotherhood, which is really what makes them so interesting. When Sam said he'd rather stay in 1863 (and either die a long painful death or be horribly crippled), I almost started crying. That just seemed like such an in-character offer for him to make. And I was just as pleased with Dean's reaction, and his insistence that they go back to their own time. Sam's motivations seemed spot on all the way through it; I could really see him exhausting every single possible way to save Dean, even if it meant dipping into black magic. It was a different, more desperate take on the "Sam trying to get Dean out of his deal" idea, and I really liked it for that reason.
There were some other details that I really liked as well. The first was the idea that Sam getting shot had some lasting effect. Considering the fact that he was cursed at the time, that idea was interesting, made sense, and put a darker spin on the hilarity of BDABR. Another detail I thought was interesting was the idea that the boys saved things from John's lockup. The show highlighted a few interesting bits and pieces, but that place was huge, and I could see them finding all kinds of things, including something as dangerous as that spell book. It made me wonder what else might be in that lockup.
Anyway, I'm totally rambling now. This was great, and I can't wait to read more from you. I hope you're hard at work at your next fic. :)
| kalina-blue chapter 14 . 2/18/2009
This story was absolutely amazing. The fact that you did all the research really showed throughout the story, lending credibility and realism to it.
I also like how ic you portrayed Sam and Dean. Your story would settle into canon nicely.
Thank you for sharing such a brilliant fic.
| Narelena chapter 14 . 2/16/2009
Wonderful story! And what a neat personal connection you have to the events and people. I enjoy historical fiction in the published world, and was thrilled by your excellent combination of fanfic (because who doesn't love Sam and Dean?) and history. Your pacing of the plot was very nicely done, and your characters were believable and well-developed. In short, your fic kept me up past my bedtime-probably my number one indicator of interest. Thank you for sharing your work!
| Linnie McCary chapter 14 . 2/15/2009
I suspected there was something personal about those Griffith brothers, partly because your fic began in Indiana, and I know that's in your profile. What a great job you did bringing your kin to life, and leaving "River of Blood" as a kind of legacy for those who come after. You did a great job with including the horrific details of those terrible days of bloodshed, including the wounded soldiers frozen to the ground by their own blood, and the wild boars feasting on human flesh. (Did I say a great job? Yes, but...ew!)
When I was tramping around Chickamauga, it felt odd to be both starry-eyed at the 'romantic history' of it, and appalled and sickened by what it must have been like on those two days. At one point, as I traipsed across one of the fields in my silly little sandals, the woods at my back, I couldn't help but shudder, picturing the carnage, hearing the screams of the injured and dying, knowing I was on ground that once had been soaked in blood. It's really quite a place.
Terrific work, Harrigan. You should be proud, and I'm sure you are!
| Linnie McCary chapter 13 . 2/15/2009
Well done, my friend, and right up my alley! Again, lots of fabulous history, great job parallelling (is that a word?) the two sets of brothers, with their mirror effects, and tying the whole megillah to the Crossroads Deal. (btw, I met Scott Bakula last year. He's a very, very charming man.) My kitchen has yet to be cleaned, but I have thoroughly enjoyed my Sunday afternoon with your fic!
| Linnie McCary chapter 12 . 2/15/2009
Some lovely (horrific) images in this chap: "The light from the lantern cast a small pale puddle of light that scraped the forest floor as Lew joined him" and "the darkness of night drew back over a soldier’s face like a shroud."
But most of it? Just broke my heart. What beats these brothers' love for one another?
| Linnie McCary chapter 10 . 2/15/2009
re Chapter 9: Butterflies-now I know this is a dream, somehow (so intriguing!) because, if memory serves, the days of the battle were actually unseasonably cold. Oh, and then you SAY it's cold. Huh. Maybe I always just equate butterflies with warming weather.
re Chapter 10: I wonder how many of your readers besides me recognize that song. In fact, along back at about Chapter 2 or Chapter 3, I almost added "Tramp, tramp, tramp, the boys are marching" to my comment, but decided you wouldn't get the reference. I believe now that I was wrong! :)
Interesting parallels you're making here, between the sets of brothers. Also, I appreciate the irony that Lew mistakes the toxic spellbook for a Bible.
| Linnie McCary chapter 8 . 2/15/2009
The first part/half of this (Dean's musings about being in Sam's dreams) was FASCINATING and FABULOUS.
Great shiver: The quote from Isaiah.
Great chuckle: John Winchester, master of the stick-figure Wendigo.
| Linnie McCary chapter 7 . 2/15/2009
Oh, now we're getting to what I've been waiting for! *rubs hands in gleeful anticipation* Oh, Sammy, this is SO dangerous! Great job, these long chapters with barely a mention, building the suspense, and now bringing Sam's plan back amidst the carnage of war.
WONDERFUL anxiety raiser: "Sam wondered, belatedly, if the owner had attempted the spell and disappeared. If he’d never returned."
This, too: "But with this ritual, ‘summoning’ apparently didn’t mean what he’d expected. Sam worried now what else ‘binding’ might mean, and how this might go wrong too."
| Linnie McCary chapter 5 . 2/15/2009
"Winchester was sitting on his haunches next to the dead man, calmly re-loading his musket. Sam loomed over him, and tucked a finger under his brother’s chin to better see the blood on Dean’s face. Dean shook him off and wiped his jaw with his sleeve." There's love and heroism and stoicism, all right there. I adore these boys.
Lovely, in a completely unheroic way: "The pale gray smoke didn’t float away; it seemed to hover over the battlefield, like a curse in the air. Some soldiers buckled under the weight of it, hands to knees and gulping for air. Others tried to raise their arms over their heads in triumph but lacked the strength."
Great job with the skirmish!
| Linnie McCary chapter 4 . 2/15/2009
Great tension: "The skirmishers came tearing back, bursting over the ridge with chests heaving, wild-eyed as if the hounds of hell were chasing them. A deep rumbling sound like thunder swelled and Dean realized that it was cavalry they had stumbled across. The Sixth Georgia Cavalry burst into view and didn’t slow. It was like they never even saw the rank and file of Croxton’s brigade, 10 rifles, drawing a bead." Loved Dean not wanting to fire, killing someone based on the color of his outfit.
| Linnie McCary chapter 3 . 2/15/2009
"A Union soldier he didn’t know was standing there, tall, clean-shaven, no stripes on his uniform sleeves. Bright green eyes were drawn to the coffee like a hungry dog eyeing a bone." Yay, Dean! *bg*
"'Damn,' Leamon breathed out, craning his neck back." Yay, Sam! *ebg* (even bigger grin!)
Great job with the little details: seeing the elephant, the coffee, the weevils. I wonder if Leamon would've wondered if they were Rebel spies...I'm SO curious about where this is going!
| Linnie McCary chapter 2 . 2/15/2009
I haven't read your reviews for this fic, but I'll bet every one of 'em for Chapter 2 mentioned this line:
“I will always find you, Sammy.”
Now, normally this would be too AU for me to read, Strict Canon-Girl that I am, and despite the time-travel of "In the Beginning" (also too AU for me, go figure, since it's now canon, but sue me...)
However, you wrote it, and it's written very well, and it's Chickamauga, moments after I just re-read my LJ posts about my trip, thanks to you, and I'm very VERY curious about what Sam had actually intended.
I was accidentally at the battlefield on its anniversary, so in addition to the ranger tour, I heard the reenactors and their cannon-fire, and spoke with several of the...hmm, I'll call them volunteer traveling historical docents, because they weren't reenactors...camped out in front of the museum with their horses and gear. They knew a lot of fascinating stuff about the weapons that would've been used at the battle, and one let me hold and aim his (unloaded) rifle. Heavy!
Now I'm really anxious to get to your notes! Lead on, Macduff!
| Linnie McCary chapter 1 . 2/15/2009
Loved the art on your LJ page (and, dude-Chickamauga? That was part of my fabled 2007 trip, and now I can't wait to read this!) I'm going to review here on ff, however, because I'll do a much better job.
Also, I DO remember passing by this story before, because something about the summary made me think it was a crossover. I think it was the use of the man's name. Since I don't watch any TV other than our boys, I avoid crossovers-they don't make much sense to me. My loss, obviously!
First laugh after Painesville? Mathlete. Next one, plus great observation: "The best way to get Sam really invested in the job is to appear disinterested, make his pre-law brother build a case to support the merits of the hunt."
LOL. I've been wondering if you have a thing for baseball/softball. Why? It struck me with the doctor's name in "Lifeline," which I read immediately before "BMR" and the references in its opening 'graphs. Sure, here you've kind of got the excuse of WIAWSNB, but I'm still thinking you're a fan!
Super work with the atmosphere of the spell (drat that Sam!) and the transition...