Oh my goodness this is so so so good! I love this song and these characters and this was completely fantastic! Great job!

Very insightful. Great job! :)

You have combined one of my favorite songs with my favorite book and came up with a very nice fanfiction. I like how you made the songfic a line by line, not stanza by stanza. It's not as tiring to read and it's very nice. I really like how you wrote this story, the ending made me sad how almost all the Blacks save two died early but in a way it isn't too bad. You've done a great job, and I'm glad I read this.

This was awesome. You really touched on the character's personalities and how they made their decisions in their lives. Great job!

This was amazing. This didn't seem like a song fic, it was just a story which related to the lyrics very well, and you were able to see the characters in an almost positive way, though the lyrics say the other. This is probably my number one Harry Potter fanfiction.

- T

I listened to the song as I read this. It was beautiful. Good job. :)

i loved that!

Really great songfic. I love the way that you portray the Blacks, my favorite HP family.

wow this was incredible. Keep up the good work

Awesome!

Wow... I love all of your Harry Potter pieces. You are utterly and completely incredible with a side of amazing! This is perfect. :D

Emma

This was incredible! I loved the parts in Andromeda where "Tonks" is compared to "Black." And the part where she is the in-between child. And Sirius's part where he is confronted by all these images of Slytherins. Actually, all of their sortings were awesome and totally in character!

And I am normally not much of a song fic-er either, but you did this one very nicely!

Wow just wow, great job!