Reviews for It's an Odd Coincidence |
---|
Liliesshadow chapter 57 . 2/26/2010 HA! i wanna see Boromirs face when he saw Storm! |
Sirius-Black-is-not-dead chapter 57 . 2/26/2010 Great story, and the perfect ending for it to be picked up in a sequel! I loved reading your fic, it was really unique and was one of the best readings I have had for a while. Congratulations on finishing, I expect that you will have many positive reviews since it is done now. Good luck with the rest of your stories! |
Isis the Sphinx chapter 57 . 2/26/2010 You brought Boromir over. I feel bad for him. The wedding was fantastic, btw. Looking forward to the continuation. Keep writing! |
L. Byron chapter 57 . 2/26/2010 great chapter..please continue, I hope more middle earth characters will come. Wonder what Marie or kittie will think if they see a legolas or glorfindel |
Liliesshadow chapter 56 . 2/21/2010 lol love her parents! also the end of this chapter before the A/N made me laugh! |
Wtiger5 chapter 56 . 2/20/2010 And so two become one. Well done. |
annon chapter 56 . 2/20/2010 Hi, Love the story. Will be sad to see it ending soon. Question: What's happening with Scott? You seem to have forgotten him. |
Turtle Kid the Woolgatherer chapter 56 . 2/20/2010 It probably shouldn't have, because it really wasn't ~that~ funny, but Logan thinking iambic pentameter is "ambivalent pentameter" made me laugh out loud for over a minute straight. I think you're doing well on the wedding so far, even if the Pirates of the Caribbean wedding was simply awesome. |
Isis the Sphinx chapter 56 . 2/19/2010 *blinkblink* I'm really not sure what to say. Logan, in a Middle Earth wedding? And what about his world, and Scott? You be leaving a few strings untied. And I'm looking forward to Chance Encounter: V. I saw the youtube video and was impressed. Keep writing! |
zentry chapter 56 . 2/19/2010 LOL, meet the parents! |
Navig8R chapter 55 . 2/19/2010 WOW! WOW! Wow! Filler, you say? Not! _ I love this conversation between Arwen and Sidhien! It gets to the heart of things, and shows the beginning of a bond between the stately Arwen and the elvish maiden of Lorien. And we all know that "It might be years" could actually mean decades, since Telcontar reigned over the reunited kingdom for over a century, if memory serves. I think he lay down to die at the ripe old age of 190 or so. I do, however, think it would flow better with a slight modification of the wording: I think you might choose a better tense for the "making a choice" verb: “To think that I am not alone in my plight! My dear Sidhien, some might call you foolish, but I call you brave. It is not easy to choose, and I fear that both of us _made_ a choice that will cause us pain in the end.” Why not "both of us _have_made_ a choice"? And then there is a funny inconsistency in the POV for Logan's cogitation on the Houses of Healing: He felt decidedly uncomfortable in this room, for fear that he’d break something by just moving. It was like _having_ a bull, no, a bear in a room full of crystal. If you are telling this from Logan's POV, why not "_being_ a bull... in a room full of crystal."? "Brandished"? Implies waving them around in the air, gesturing/displaying threateningly. Why not "extended"? That would express his sense of alarm, and still account for the shredded sheets. I like that you have Logan finally coming to terms with the culture of Middle Earth sufficiently at this point to be explaining 20th century Americanisms and scientific terms like "claustrophobia" to his friends. As you have developed him it has been a hard-won awareness. _ O.M.G... "he had taken down ten mûmakil all on his own" Think what a mountain of carrion that would be! "Steppe gave way to tundra." If you are going south from the grasslands of Rohan, you will not find tundra: that is a geoform of the far north. Gondor is in the warm and sunny south. You would be safer to say something like "the undulating grasslands of the Eastfold gave way to the ...(pastures and fields?) of Anorien..." |
amba gurl chapter 56 . 2/19/2010 hey! love this chapter, but am kinda depressed coz this is almost over... *sniff* :( lol anyways, whats with the no logan/glorfy conflict? and i reckon u should so (in either this or the sequel...) so have some o logans students show up and be all 'aww! u didnt get a bachelor party!' lol update soon! |
Melchor chapter 56 . 2/19/2010 Nicely done! I'm a little sad to see this coming to an end...it helps to cheer me up in the middle of the week, whenever I get around to read it. Thanks for writing. |
cherish15 chapter 56 . 2/19/2010 *looks at chapter, squees* (uh-oh I sound like a sue) hehhe. I loved this chapter! Finally their reunion, how are you going to work out the going to the blessed lands thing? Is there going to be a love scene? Oh I hope there is, I just love passionate ones. Pretty please? Cherish15 |
Chaos Dragon-Fox chapter 56 . 2/19/2010 I'm glad you got another chapter out and it's sad that this story is coming to a close; but the sequel might be interesting! |