Reviews for I Remember I Told You I Love You
RykOakwine chapter 8 . 4/13
I'll take ending B.

Funny enough. I mean, what normal person would not pick MJ?

Though I like The Gwen Stacy Syndrome story. But it's a *different* story. It doesn't have the same style or feel as this one. Sure, give a C. option for triad but not the silly "open relationship" posited in TGSS for the sake of being able to post more fun porn of Peter putting to the female cast of Spider-man (Randi, Candi, and Bambi? Dude, that's like so far back it was when I was a kid and when three young women living together next door were probably called "co-eds" in the Spider-man comic, or maybe even "swinging singles", like Austin Powers would pronounce it!). Make it the committed binogomous triad TGSS sorta started as or (more correctly) what *this* story's Peter, Felicia, and MJ would/should/could have if the world were fair and people were perfect.

But whatever in other stories and in the thousand weird variants of Peter Parker's existence that are all mutually exclusive considering the decades of bad writing and drama he's experienced over the run of the comic. In *this* story, the Felicia who realized it was more awesome and rare to just hold Peters hand because she loved him than all the mind-wracking, soul-shattering, body-draining cocaine boosted orgasms the Mistress Emma could ever coax out of Felicia's extremely capable body? That Felicia? She absolutely deserves at *least* ending B.

She can help Peter grow up (and, really, it's time for non-Ultimate (or whatever next reboot-retell-rewhatever Spider-man to grow up and move past the penniless young man he's been forever and, well, grow up) and frankly it's just too unjust if after finally growing up a bit herself and evolving beyond her self-limiting self-perception as a mere party girl she loses him to MJ (or anyone else).

That's where authors of novels have it made. They can end the story there, told and told well.

Whereas the Editor of the Spider-man comic has to bring in another writer to keep...telling...the...bloody...story...forever...

Give them B and let them live happily ever after.
Balanu chapter 8 . 11/7/2014
Great story, love the multiple endings, especially C since it leads right into another story!
Dr.Sugarcakes chapter 1 . 8/11/2014
I have read this work a while back and it still amazes me how well of a job you did ! Especially following a storyline like OMD. The characterizations were great, it had fun and dramatic moments. Everything I wanted while reading this. And you letting us choose the ending was just the nicest thing ever XD In other words, don't stop writing !
dm chapter 8 . 8/1/2014
Very dissatisfying and somewhat lazy ending, should've just picked B and left it at that
Guest chapter 8 . 7/28/2014
Huh?
Lord Sigfry chapter 8 . 7/6/2014
That c is a disgusting ending. Don't get me wrong, I like lesbians as much as the next guy but that was just absolutely brain bleach worthy.

Go... Just I and saw your hands off. No, that would be too easy. Gnaw at it, and revel in the pain you sicko.
Krolikson chapter 1 . 5/29/2014
I have been warned about the correct order for reading !
Satanic Park Of Madness chapter 8 . 5/8/2014
I had no idea that this was the prequel to the Gwen Stacy Syndrome. Damn. With everything that Spider man went through,he deserves to have both Black Cat and Mary Jane by his side as he does his best to keep New York safe and sound.

Talk about one hell of a story that lead up to the three of them coming together.

The ultimate middle finger to Mephisto and then to Quesada for coming up with OMD and OMIT.
warfolomei chapter 8 . 5/8/2014
C... definitely C. Especially with that TBC clause. I don't know if you planned this in 2009, but it's a nice turn of events !
warfolomei chapter 6 . 5/8/2014
Ah, those rare moments when someone manages to finally switch that serious button on. Love them.
warfolomei chapter 5 . 5/8/2014
Ah, May. If only we knew back then, what we know now.
Even after all this time, those moments still haunt my comic dreams.
warfolomei chapter 4 . 5/8/2014
One of those things no one ever likes to talk about, but still happened and mostly ignored.
Has it really been that long ? Apparently Marvel didn't learn anything from the experience.
I really want to read a fic where Parker steals someone from Osborns.
That "life insurance" bit was really funny for some reason.
warfolomei chapter 3 . 5/8/2014
Interesting contrast to what happened in the comics. With MJ been the one who quickly found someone else and then just kept appearing in Peter's life.
Jealous Felicia is just adorable.
warfolomei chapter 2 . 5/8/2014
That ending always hits me with emotions.
You really can write those two interacting, without it coming out as cliche.
warfolomei chapter 1 . 5/8/2014
Even after so many years, this story still holds.
68 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »