| Reviews for Ithaca is Gorges |
|---|
  jk chapter 17 . 1/21/2016 I thought papa c and Edward were gonna make out for awhile there...soooo gross |
| jk chapter 4 . 1/21/2016 I so hate Edward right now...bella promised to stay safe...my one condition...(?) His condition? condition to what? I promise ill break your heart and never come back...on one condition... WTH? Edwards a fucking idiot. Bella would be smart if she told him to go fuck himself and shove his condition up his ass. I hope Bella isn't the weak pathetic one from the books! I hope shes alright and getting it on with jake! |
 jadeEyre chapter 19 . 1/8/2016 Awesome story! definitely a unique idea. Loved hearing from Carlisle so much as well a rounder and more fulfilling backstory to Carlisle. Thank you ;) |
| Guest chapter 19 . 10/18/2015 Fantastic story and perspective about Carlisle that many of us have wondered about. Thank you! |
| nmturcios chapter 19 . 10/15/2015 it was awsome! loved it! |
| Scarlett chapter 19 . 10/13/2015 I love this story its so touching |
| Amanda chapter 19 . 8/23/2015 So beautiful. Thank you for writing this story. |
| CreativeWritingGirl chapter 19 . 7/27/2015 This was absolutely remarkably written. I was blown away by the quality and eloquence of this. This was precisely how I imagined this time in New Moon. Excellent job! |
| tullochsophia chapter 19 . 5/23/2015 This book was enthralling. I enjoyed every chapter. Congratulations on such an outstanding view into Edward's and Carlisle's POV. Well done, keep up the spectacular work. |
| Momatu chapter 1 . 5/17/2015 I found this story on a rec list from Raum, and I'm really liking it so far. I typically read things from either Edward's or Bella's pov. I've read Charlie's pov before, but unfortunately that fic was never finished. I think this is the first time I'm reading something from Carlisle's pov. Off to read more! |
| KimiD chapter 3 . 4/27/2015 Talk about the one affecting the all... wow Stubborn Idiot I want a dad like Carlisle! So many emotions, no wonder Jasper was being taken down Em could not stand to watch his brother pull himself apart, they are all scattered to the 4 winds... and Bella is the glue that holds them all together but Edward is so blind sighted he cannot see it. Oh but a mother's love, she Has the perfect solution no one is listening... |
| KimiD chapter 2 . 4/27/2015 the only word to describe his condition... TORTURE! |
| KimiD chapter 1 . 4/27/2015 We very seldom get to get inside of Carlisle mind and I know it has to be fascinating as he has been around for quite some time He truly has a father's heart and being a doctor is fit for his compassion and kindness... great pov |
| Wendyg63 chapter 19 . 1/5/2015 Bravo. Thank you |
| Wendyg63 chapter 17 . 1/5/2015 A lot packed in this chapter-sadness, longing, fear, anxiety and in the very end acknowledgment and love. Thank you |