Amazing. Very touching and well written. Plus unlike many Vic’s it’s readable because of the decent grammar.

I just noticed he's a father of three and we're never introduced to the third child...maybe the third child was the Thalia?

Thank you for sharing this wonderful fic. Thalia and Luke very much deserves a happy ending. They're one of my ships that crashed during TLO so thanks for giving them a wonderful new beginning. I love your works and can't wait to read more. Happy writing.

They both deserved that happy ending.
well done on the story. i must be getting weak cause i let a tear fall.

That was AMAZING. The story was well written and emotional. It was soooo good.

Terrific. Incredible. One of my favorites by far.

This fic was absolutely beautiful. I've always wondered what would happen if Luke did get reincarnated, and the story is both heartwarming and bittersweet. I especially liked Luke's first reincarnation.
Keep up the good work!

I'm not an avid shipper and a massive critic when it comes to fanfic. But this blew me away and sold me one this ship. I wish this was canon. Go be an author.

This is beautiful. It genuinely made me cry. Good job.

I dont think I need to repeat what most critics have already said... THAT YOU ARE AN AMAZING AMD EXCEPTIONAL WRITER. All I can say is, your stories are absolutely timeless. This was written in 2009 and here I am, in 2017, still reading your stories. You know when you're a good author if this is your level. Kudos to you!

I so love this fanfic! Great job, author!

nice prologue and thuke angst

adam's great

very nice thuke action in this fanfic

perfect story