Reviews for Empty Chair
Led Feynman M.D. D.D.S. Ph.D chapter 1 . 12/29/2011

...oh-Oh! Barney died! I mean, um, ahem, Barney died. Tragic.
Totally Kawaii chapter 1 . 7/9/2010
This is soft, and sweet, and sad, and beautiful and I love how they realize that Barney completes them because they can't imagine life without one of the five missing.

I love the vagueness of the fic, but I'd also want more context as to why Barney was in the hospital. Still, it's nice and thanks for sharing.
FinnFiona chapter 1 . 6/23/2009
Very nice... Though I can understand why Ted would be upset, I tend to agree with your insights here-and that feels very Lily in the start as well. Sweet moment.
Argentus chapter 1 . 5/31/2009
Oh Lily. I love these sentences:

“She says nothing and the conversation flows, stilted, like a brook running over large rocks. There are word whirlpools and white water sentences and Lily feels a little lost”

“"Solemn low five," she mumbles, under her breath.” And I love her silent toast to absent friends.

She would totally be the one who screams at Ted. I really do love Ted but he was kind of a jerk about the whole Robin-Barney hook-up.

And it’s so great and in-character that Barney’s words after Ted apologizes are “Did she say yes?” : )